# Baseball Card Maker (Ad Free) — Make Your Own Custom Baseball Cards with Starr Cards — user reviews > 41 indexed App Store user reviews of Baseball Card Maker (Ad Free) by PocketSensei, rated 1.00/5 from 2 ratings. - Source: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/baseball-card-maker-ad-free-make-your-own-custom-baseball-cards-with-starr-cards/id447642270/reviews - App overview in markdown: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/baseball-card-maker-ad-free-make-your-own-custom-baseball-cards-with-starr-cards/id447642270.md - Rating breakdown: 5★ 0 · 4★ 0 · 3★ 0 · 2★ 0 · 1★ 2 ## Newest reviews (12 of 41) ### 3/5 — Good but won't let order cards *2016-06-18, version 2.6.2* It works except when u try to print/order the cards nothing happens ### 2/5 — Crash *2016-05-11, version 2.6.2* I have used this great app but now it crashes. Fix it please. ### 2/5 — Please Fiz *2016-05-03, version 2.6.2* App crashes when I add a picture to a card. please fix ### 2/5 — Great app but ads on paid version! *2015-07-30, version 2.5* I paid for this app and somehow ended up with the ad version after an upgrade. Worse yet when I click "get ad free version" it has the "Open" button in the App Store. The developers screwed something up here and I'm not happy. Trying to make cards for my spring baseball team and keep getting routed to the App Store to download advertisers apps! ### 3/5 — Cards look good but sound is awful *2015-04-17, version 2.5* This app has a continuous background sound of a crowd at a game. It cannot be turned off. I am forced to shut off the volume on the phone to tolerate the app. ### 4/5 — I like it *2015-02-22, version 2.4.2* Great app, works well. The only problem I have is that you can't customize player positions. You can only choose from their preset list. It has a nice authentic baseball card look. ### 4/5 — Awesome *2014-07-13, version 2.3* Simple, easy to use. Only complaint? I wish there was a way to auto populate name, number, team, etc. Creating dozens of cards and it's a pain to re-key the exact sane info over and over. Saving a player profile would put this app over the top. As is though, we'll worth the price. ### 4/5 — Great app. *2012-12-16, version 1.2.5* I have used this for baseball and soccer. I have also ordered the cards and they came out great. Unfortunately I have updated the last retro 75 baseball and now it won't open. I hope when it is fixed that I have not lost my cards that I have made up. ### 5/5 — Starr Cards *2011-09-07, version 1.00* The best custom card maker on the app store. Users can now create cards with their faces on the front, and their stats on the back too. Best of all, the cards can be printed out to a size of choice. All included with a life-like virtual card album to display as many as you can create. Worth every cent. ### 5/5 — 5-Star diamond *2011-08-07, version 1.00* Brings pro style cards to amateur players like myself. I can totally see these becoming collectables or heirlooms. ### 5/5 — So fun *2011-08-05, version 1.00* Using this app for all the guys on my slowpitch softball team! ### 5/5 — Awesome app *2011-08-03, version 1.00* This app was quick and easy to use and made a card my kid loved. I think the quality is amazing. ## Most critical reviews (10 lowest-rated) ### 1/5 — Free is better *2023-04-09* Free app has more templates to use than the bought one I suggest keeping free one you have to buy extra templates after paying 1.99 free one has 2 extra retro versions to choose different templates ### 1/5 — Demand A Refund!! *2014-04-27, version 2.2.1* This app I'm sure is a great app but scince it won't download all the way I don't know that! It has been stuck in the same spot for days! ### 1/5 — Broken app, want refund *2014-01-20* I paid for this app and it won't work on my iPhone. I reinstalled, and still the same. ### 1/5 — App Won't Open *2013-08-20, version 2.0.3* The app won't open it's a complete waste of money same with the football one too. DONT BUY SAVE YOUR MONEY!!! 😡😤🚫👎 ### 1/5 — Won't load after update *2013-08-18, version 2.0.3* Paid for one of the other templates, then they updated the app and now it will not load. I have iPad 1. Booooooooo, please fix. ### 1/5 — Not standard size output *2013-07-27, version 2.0.0* This card maker may be ok to post a card on Facebook or to view on your computer but if you plan to print out your own cards as I did, you may want to look elsewhere. First, there is only one template, you have to purchase one of the other two if you want another look. Second, the export size is not the standard 2.5x3.5, it is an odd size of 2.5x3.75 which will not fit into a standard baseball trading card holder. Third, the .pdf that the card is exported into is password protected so there is no way to fix the sizing. If there were a way I would give this app zero stars. ### 1/5 — Buyer Beware! *2011-08-16, version 1.00* I was impressed with this software. Until I decided to edit the image I CREATED with the software I PAID for to make a collage of the cards to share with friends. I was stunned and upset to learn that the PDF exports of the cards could not be altered (at least not without adding a step or three) due to the PDF's being locked and password protected. I don't see any reason why this would be the case, or what the purpose of doing this is, unless as one other reviewer mentioned, they fear someone removing the company logo from the card. Which is truly lame in a paid app. ### 1/5 — Garbage *2011-07-28* I payed $1.99 for a boarder app!! Its just different positions and boarders! They should have had a baseball players outfit and you just insert your face! ... I wouldn't recommend this to anyone! Save your money! ### 1/5 — Enough *2011-07-23, version 1.00* We bought the app, we don't need a big Starr card on the side of the one selection of cards to save ( front and back ) I hate companies that do that stuff, I just have to make another step in cropping it out! Fix that it STINKS! ### 2/5 — Downgrading My Rating *2016-07-20, version 2.6.5* I'm downgrading my original rating for this app. A set of cards I purchased no longer appeared after the last update. I sent 3 e-mails but none were answered. I hope they will restore my cards and answer my e-mails so I can upgrade my review. Until then I will not be purchasing any new sets or any other Starr apps. ## Most praised reviews (10 highest-rated) ### 5/5 — Fun and Useful *2015-11-12* I'm still using this app after 4 seasons. Everyone enjoys their individual and team cards. Nice job printing too! ### 5/5 — Great app! *2015-03-22, version 2.4.2* This app is great!!!The cards look like they were from the 90's(no,I was not around then)but u can even print them! ### 5/5 — Ordering more cards!!! *2014-07-10, version 2.3* I ordered these for my friend's son and I am blown away by the quality. They are absolutely first class. I also need to throw an extra kudos to the customer service. I had made a mistake with my order & they were able to get it fixed for me. Now getting ready to order some for my son. Super Happy!!! ### 5/5 — Love the new vintage designs *2013-09-19, version 2.0.4* The Vintage 95 and Vintage 11 card designs are off the chain! Brilliant execution on classic baseball cards complete with stats. LOVE IT! ### 5/5 — Fan favorite *2013-07-28, version 2.0.0* I ordered one pack of cards for each of the players on my HS baseball team and have since had to place two more orders at the request of parents. Everyone loves the superb quality and attention to detail. Starr Cards have really lifted the art of custom card making to a point where they are indistinguishable from cards for pro players. Looking forward to seeing what new designs are in the works! ### 5/5 — Amazing *2013-03-03, version 1.2.5* My brother loves this app. He makes his own cards and loves showing them to his friends! It seems like every five minutes he's asking me to take another picture of him so he can use it to make a baseball card. It's great! ### 5/5 — Good app *2012-12-18* Very nice app. I'm unable to edit the backside trivia area though. Bug? Normal? Help me? ### 5/5 — Love it! *2012-05-08, version 1.1.5* I love this app, the kids on our team love it! We're excited to make a complete set for our team. ### 5/5 — Grandson T-Ball *2012-04-18, version 1.1.5* My grandson who lives out of state had his first T-Ball game & his Dad sent me photos via Facebook. I used the Baseball Card Maker to put him in the spotlight and reposted on my son & daughter in law's wall. They absolutely loved the cards & now i have their young friends calling & writing wanting to k ow what company they can send their kids' pictures off to to have converted to BB cards? The developer has made it so simple even this old grandpa can do it ### 5/5 — Outstanding! *2011-10-10, version 1.1* This app is perfect. I am in awe of it's perfection. It's design is beautiful and intuitive. I have downloaded all the Starr Card apps. --- *Data collected daily from the US App Store and indexed by [AppsHunter](https://appshunter.io/). User reviews are verbatim App Store reviews. Ratings, prices and chart positions refresh continuously; this snapshot is from 2026-06-10.*