# Carnegie Learning eBook — user reviews > 22 indexed App Store user reviews of Carnegie Learning eBook by Carnegie Learning, Inc., rated 1.50/5 from 81 ratings. - Source: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/carnegie-learning-ebook/id1290408378/reviews - App overview in markdown: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/carnegie-learning-ebook/id1290408378.md - Rating breakdown: 5★ 8 · 4★ 2 · 3★ 2 · 2★ 2 · 1★ 67 ## Newest reviews (11 of 22) ### 1/5 — VERY BAD *2021-03-11, version 1.0.3* I don’t like this app at all it literally does not teach me anything and wastes my time like one workspace takes like an hour FIX UR APP ACTUALLY DELETE IT IT GIVES ME A HEADACHE thank you very much ### 1/5 — TRASH *2021-03-03, version 1.0.3* it is so hard and doesn’t give me the answers. it gives me mental breakdowns every time i try to do it. the workspaces take forever do not recommend. 😃 ### 1/5 — HORRIBLE *2021-03-03, version 1.0.3* ✨This app is so bad. Mathia is so hard sand it takes forever to complete a workspace. Girly you can’t even say the apps name at all so it is so bad. Legit hate this app delete it. LIKE IT IS SO HARD AND MATHIA DOESNT EVEN EXPLAIN GOOD ALEAST TRY TO HELP. WHOEVER MADE THIS APP DELETE IT AND FIX IT✨ Xoxo, Giggle bear💋 ### 1/5 — worst app ever *2021-01-20, version 1.0.3* Do not download this. ### 1/5 — What to do Carnegie? *2020-11-11, version 1.0.3* WELL YOU CAN’T ### 1/5 — Mathia *2020-08-27, version 1.0.3* Mathia is a very hardcore math app.it is very long and it’s super hard to understand.they don’t really explain how to do the math problems. Mathia takes forever to get a workspace done between having the technical issues and never understanding what’s going on.Its very hard for parents to help their children at home and so you cannot get it done very well at home.These are all major problems when it comes to homework and class work.It is also just super stressful for most kids and it is so hard to get any other homework done since Mathia is so time consuming. ### 1/5 — Literally the worst *2020-06-15, version 1.0.3* Teachers who assign this are so lazy. I can’t even log in. Never download this app, so terrible. Their website isn’t any better. ### 1/5 — doesn’t work at all *2020-03-27, version 1.0.3* it’s horrible it doesn’t work at all!!! ### 1/5 — Won’t let me login *2020-03-14, version 1.0.3* Due to the Coronavirus epidemic, our teacher has assigned to work on while school is closed. The problem is the app won’t even let me log in. They need to improve this. ### 1/5 — It doesn’t work at all *2019-12-19, version 1.0.3* This app doesn’t work at all and the website is awful to use in a phone so I’m forced to use a computer which is stupid. It needs an update please ### 1/5 — Hate it *2019-12-15, version 1.0.3* It’s so bad and nothing will work and it has too many problems ## Most critical reviews (10 lowest-rated) ### 1/5 — MATHia. *2026-03-08, version 1.0.3* If I could write the word “hate” on every single atom of the observable universe it would not compare to a billionth on how much I HATE Mathia. ### 1/5 — It dosent show all the pages of the books *2025-10-12, version 1.0.3* Horrible 😟 ### 1/5 — Not good fog *2025-02-20, version 1.0.3* This is the worst learning app ever it would not let me log in and it had bugs and it took hours for me to finish 1 unit do not recommend. ### 1/5 — Tiring. *2025-01-20, version 1.0.3* Educators and/or parents please do not use this app. Coming from a unbiased standpoint as a student without the “all homework=bad” point of view, this app is just awful. The lessons take hours to complete. There’s a variety of different lessons that can be assigned, within these lessons there’s multiple “stats” you must fill up to complete the level, each stat accounts for a different part of the problem and it can take 10 or more problems to fill up one stat. However, if you make a mistake these stats will completely start over. In the current workspace I’m on, there’s 8 stats I must fill up but their can be more. There’s little to no explanation on what you’re supposed to do, so often times I just kind of memorize the patterns within each problem without actually understanding the math or reasoning behind it. While there is a “step by step” option, the explanations are often extremely confusing and worded weird. The actual app itself is extremely disengaging with dull colors, boring mechanics, and like I previously stated, over complicated, (but somehow also very surface level) explanations of the concepts your child is learning. After I’m done with the workspaces I find myself with no new knowledge or understandings of math, which is really disappointing because I love to learn. So while I could be doing something actually useful to me, I’m stuck doing repetitive lessons. I’m already not the best at math, but these lessons if anything just confuse me more. Another thing I noticed is a lot of the things they teach are completely irrelevant to what my teacher is talking about in class, which may not be the apps fault but I figure I should bring it up anyways. For reference, I am a seventh grader, a lot of the things in Carnegie seem a lot more advanced and difficult then we’re actually learning. There’s no reason these should be more difficult, I wouldn’t be assigned more difficult lessons because to be completely honest, I have a D in math, and am in a standard class, so there’s no way I could be moved on to more advanced subjects. If you made it this far I’m begging you, there are far more better programs to teach your children. If anything this program will just teach your students or children to resent math. ### 1/5 — Can’t log in *2023-06-08, version 1.0.3* Won’t let me log in Do not get the app ### 1/5 — Very bad *2023-05-10, version 1.0.3* Doesn’t let me login. I want to do my homework but can’t. I beee this app to be updated or a new app to be made ### 1/5 — Cancel Mathia Boys *2021-12-02, version 1.0.3* Plsss ### 1/5 — Can’t Log in - please read Carnegie *2021-09-06, version 1.0.3* This would be a wonderful app if I could log into it with my username and password that I use on the website on my desktop. Is this because my organization does not pay for mobile support? is mobile support extra? just curious I would love to be able to continue to work while I am away from my school and my computer ### 1/5 — Never letting me login *2021-09-02, version 1.0.3* Never letting me login ### 1/5 — Bad *2021-05-06, version 1.0.3* The never ending questions take me at least 1 day to do each. With a no mercy system, you can literaly be sitting there doing one assignment for hours because to finish you need to fill up each bar. The bars are connected to certain parts of the problem, and if you get that part right it fills it up ( a little, usually have to get it right 10 times to get it right.)but you can be completely done with everything except a simple little part of a problem that just wont show up, making you sit there for hours. Then, on top of that, if you get it wrong, it will make the bar go down. I’ve had many cases where I’ve been very close to finishing, only to be set back hours because of a miss click. The never ending problems are terrible. The way the app teaches is even worst. When I’m beginning a subject in it, it talks in a way I STILL can’t figure out even after I’m done with that subject, (with a very good understanding on the subject too) it talks in a college grade manner. I’m in advanced English and I’m doing great in math, but when ever I hop on mathia it brings me down, I can’t understand a thing and if anything does teach me anything. I’ll have a basic understanding on something mathia completly destroys that. ## Most praised reviews (1 highest-rated) ### 2/5 — Can’t login!! *2020-10-19, version 1.0.3* I’ve tried and tried but this app does not let me log into my Carnegie account. It would be good if it actually let me login. --- *Data collected daily from the US App Store and indexed by [AppsHunter](https://appshunter.io/). User reviews are verbatim App Store reviews. Ratings, prices and chart positions refresh continuously; this snapshot is from 2026-06-10.*