# iDetective Logic Puzzles — user reviews > 22 indexed App Store user reviews of iDetective Logic Puzzles by Vicente Malixi, rated 3.00/5 from 2 ratings. - Source: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/idetective-logic-puzzles/id364024345/reviews - App overview in markdown: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/idetective-logic-puzzles/id364024345.md - Rating breakdown: 5★ 1 · 4★ 0 · 3★ 0 · 2★ 0 · 1★ 1 ## Newest reviews (2 of 22) ### 3/5 — Good but needs some updates *2011-02-02* I like the application's ability to solve areas and enter them into the solution. Once I'd got the hang of how to use it, I really enjoyed it. I would also like to see the whole grid so that I can easily cross-reference clues. Update: thanks for fixing the Charity puzzle - works fine now. Please can you check Tennis Player, Liquid Steel, Sick Joke, Fall from the Sky and An Amazing Journey, all of which seem to have clues missing or contradicting one another? Thanks! ### 3/5 — Ok but a few typo's *2010-09-21* Overall a fairly entertaining game but I have found a couple of the puzzles are unsolvable without help because the clues are wrong. Hopefully this will be fixes soon as it is annoying. ## Most critical reviews (10 lowest-rated) ### 1/5 — Wot? *2014-12-02* This doesn't open on my iPhone 6. Don't download. ### 1/5 — Won't open *2014-11-16* Paid for this and it won't open at all on iPhone 5. Disappointing. ### 1/5 — -- *2014-11-14* I purchased this app and it keeps crashing, it has never opened and never been able to play it, I keep waiting for an update to see if that will fix the issue but nothing yet. No issues with any other apps btw, restarted my phone, deleted app, redownloaded it, everything! I just want it to work! ### 1/5 — Problem! *2013-06-10* The newest update wiped all my progress. 2/3 of the puzzles completed are now blank again. Not impressed. ### 1/5 — Review *2010-11-01, version 0* I downloaded this and it stopped working. The screen just gies black when I open the app. ### 1/5 — Too many errors *2010-10-08* So many errors in the puzzles. You spent time on wrong stuff. Very frustrating!! Spend money on an app... You want it to work right. ### 1/5 — Errors are frustrating *2010-05-30* This is very frustrating with the errors in it. It is an interesting concept but cumbersome to use since you can't see the whole grid at once. But, my biggest complaint is the errors. ### 2/5 — Idetectve *2012-11-18, version 3.2* After the first few puzzles the top row categories do not appear on the grids. Can't do puzzles like that! ### 2/5 — Inconsistent clues/answers *2011-07-10* Great concept but at least 2 puzzles (Tennis & Shuttle) have answers obviously inconsistent with the clues. ### 2/5 — Errors in puzzles - frustrating! *2010-04-09* I'm revising my rating after playing for a while. So far the puzzles are too easy, at least the ones that can be solved. So far I've come across 2 puzzles with errors in them. That is SO frustrating! Direct contradictions in the clues and solutions. I've submitted an error report for one, but I'm not sure it did any good. I like the concept, but hate wasting my time on puzzles that are wrong. I'd look elsewhere for a logic game. I'm giving 2 stars for the puzzles that can be solved, but that's it. ## Most praised reviews (10 highest-rated) ### 5/5 — Game is PERFECT!! *2013-08-17, version 4.1* I have this app and it is great!! I have no problems with any of the clues. As long as you have patience and work all clues through combining all the information all puzzles are solvable. ### 5/5 — READY FOR MORE!! :) *2012-05-25* Please send new update with new puzzles!!!!! So addicted! ### 5/5 — Great Game To Pass The Time *2011-07-14* I love this game. The puzzles are clever, well thought out, and interesting. Please update with more cases! I finished all of them. ### 5/5 — Great if you love logic puzzles *2011-06-22* If you like logic puzzles then you will like this app. The layout takes a bit of getting used to but once you are familiar with it then it's fine. ### 5/5 — All puzzles working perfectly in this version *2011-03-21* We've gone through all the puzzles and with this version (2.7), they're all fine. No wrong clues. All correct results. Aside from being a fun game, we just read logic puzzles like iDetective really help keep your mind sharp because it exercises all areas of the brain. ### 4/5 — Good game *2014-04-21, version 4.1* Puzzles were fun but the last one has wrong clues. Makes it hard to figure out. Be nice if there were more ### 4/5 — A lot of fun! *2011-05-26* Love the puzzles! Only one with bad clues so far. the clues in "Liquid Steel" have an error ... Correct answers claim silver goes by ship, but clue says by plane. Still lovin' it! ### 4/5 — Pollywol *2010-06-10* This app is great!!! I have the free version and there were only 3 puzzle "stories" but now there are over 30. It's great for dipping in and out when you have a spare few minutes. There are differing levels of difficulty so all the family can play their own story. Keeps my mind ticking. ### 3/5 — It's ok... *2012-08-29* Needs to be more challenging and would definitely like more puzzles. Really enjoy these type of puzzles ### 3/5 — Could b better *2011-03-06* I love this game with a few exceptions. As mentioned in other reviews, there are too many errors in the clues. The puzzles w/o errors were fun. But you pay for an app, u expect it to b error free. --- *Data collected daily from the US App Store and indexed by [AppsHunter](https://appshunter.io/). User reviews are verbatim App Store reviews. Ratings, prices and chart positions refresh continuously; this snapshot is from 2026-08-18.*