# Magical Girls Idle — user reviews

> 15 indexed App Store user reviews of Magical Girls Idle by Gamepub CO., LTD, rated 4.70/5 from 265 ratings.

- Source: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/magical-girls-idle/id6449244378/reviews
- App overview in markdown: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/magical-girls-idle/id6449244378.md
- Rating breakdown: 5★ 225 · 4★ 23 · 3★ 6 · 2★ 2 · 1★ 9

## Most critical reviews (10 lowest-rated)

### 1/5 — Can’t connect

*2025-05-13*

Pretty sure this is shut down downloaded and couldn’t connect

### 1/5 — Don’t load

*2025-03-08, version 1.8.1(18100)*

I just started to play but the game does not load failed to reach servers delete refreshed I have done all that I can game is broken

### 1/5 — Given up

*2023-11-30, version 1.5.0(15001)*

I’ve checked my tablet, I’ve checked the running requirements, I’ve made sure it’s up to date, I’ve even reset to see if that helps, it doesn’t 

Nothing I do will make this game load, I can’t get past a black screen. Apparently other games by this dev have had this issue.

### 1/5 — Same

*2023-11-21, version 1.4.1(14101)*

This game is exactly the same as every other game before it. Nothing new.  Not much to say

### 1/5 — 闪退

*2023-10-21*

如题，画面都没看见就退出了

### 3/5 — It’s ok

*2023-11-30, version 1.5.0(15001)*

Pretty much a rip off of idle moon rabbit but better not much to write home about but it’s ok

### 4/5 — Crashes

*2024-04-28*

I love playing the game however it is pretty dead and often whenever i watch an ad to summon when the ad is done the game will crash and i would have to rewatch it.

### 4/5 — Not a bad idle game. Might be dead.

*2024-03-15*

It does feel like this game is kinda dead. I can’t tell if it has active players or not.

### 4/5 — Good Game

*2024-02-10*

Good game.

### 5/5 — Played my literal nights off

*2024-11-25, version 1.8.1(18100)*

Polished but as it progresses i hope it is a free to play friendly as it is from the initial

## Most praised reviews (5 highest-rated)

### 5/5 — A+++

*2024-09-28*

A++++

### 5/5 — Modify Recharge Strategy

*2024-08-30*

I think you need to modify your recharge strategy, he is in is too difficult to use

### 5/5 — 值得推介

*2023-11-05*

這個遊戲超佛心

### 5/5 — Great Game >>

*2023-11-02*

Love this game. Nice side game. Perfect f2p balance. Please just add guilds.

### 5/5 — Very cute

*2023-10-26*

Great progression and fun animations

---

*Data collected daily from the US App Store and indexed by [AppsHunter](https://appshunter.io/). User reviews are verbatim App Store reviews. Ratings, prices and chart positions refresh continuously; this snapshot is from 2026-06-10.*