# My Humidor - Cigar Journal — user reviews > 56 indexed App Store user reviews of My Humidor by Ethan Johnson, rated 4.77/5 from 402 ratings. - Source: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/my-humidor-cigar-journal/id6639582700/reviews - App overview in markdown: https://appshunter.io/ios/app/my-humidor-cigar-journal/id6639582700.md - Rating breakdown: 5★ 172 · 4★ 23 · 3★ 3 · 2★ 0 · 1★ 6 ## What do users think of My Humidor? Overall sentiment: positive **Pros** - 👍 Easy to use and intuitive interface - 📊 Effective inventory tracking across multiple humidors - ⏰ Automatic aging tracking for cigars - 📸 Photo attachment capability for cigars and reviews - 💰 Free app with optional affordable ad removal ($0.99-$3) - 📝 Comprehensive review and journaling features - 🔄 Simple cigar transfer between humidors - ⭐ Half-star rating capability - 🛠️ Responsive developer with regular updates - 🔌 Offline functionality - 💎 Better features than competing paid apps **Cons** - 🐛 Occasional crashes and bugs reported - 📧 Spam email issues upon account creation - 🔍 Limited cigar database and vitola options - ⭐ Auto-generated star ratings not user-controllable - 🖼️ Photos don't transfer from humidor to review section - 🔎 No search/sort functionality across humidors - 📱 Clunky rating interface - 🚫 No online/cloud sync or group features - 📋 Limited cigar size and tobacco type descriptions **Commonly reported bugs** - App crashes on some devices - Spam email flooding upon account creation - Star rating selection sometimes limited to 5 stars only - Clunky and unresponsive rating interface - Navigation issues and poor performance **Most requested features** - Photo persistence from humidor to review section - Manual control over overall star ratings - Ability to track multiple purchases of same cigar separately - Cigar database with descriptions and specifications - Search and sort by aging time across humidors - Additional vitola sizes (Lancero, Double Robusto, Gordo, Rothschild) - Pricing system with MSRP and collection total cost - Separate fields for Marca, Vitola, Box code, and date added - Ability to log photos when cigars enter humidor - Bulk quantity reduction button for recently smoked cigars - Partial cigar transfer between humidors - Data export functionality - Online sync and group/friend sharing features - Pipe tobacco tracking app (similar concept) - 10-point rating scale with sliders instead of stars ## Newest reviews (15 of 56) ### 5/5 — Lieblingsapp *2025-08-24, version 2.3.1* Genau was ich gesucht habe! Eine Übersicht seiner Sammlung/ seines Bestandes. Man kann mehrere Humidore erstellen, jede Zigarre einfügen mit Bild und Preis (beides optional), dazu ist es kostenlos. Man kann seine Zigarren bewerten. Einfach perfekt! ### 5/5 — It does one thing and it does it well *2025-08-05* Finding an app to actually allow me to track my cigars has been very difficult. Either they suddenly take away functionality and increase the price, are insanely limited in what they can track, or missing some key feature. My humidor does not do any of this. It allowed me to simply track what I had, what I added, when I added it, and review it when I enjoyed it. I cannot recommend this enough. ### 5/5 — Change Two Thing *2025-07-07, version 2.3.0* Gave a 5 star rating as it’s a great app and I’m still using it and paid for it even after noticing that there was a lack of 2 features that could be something optional in the settings. This app is everything I could ever want. Tracks all my sticks, how long they’ve been aging, even tells me the current value amongst other things. What I don’t like are 2 things. Firstly, I can’t adjust the star rating on my sticks. The rating is automatically given based on your review and I prefer to control that aspect. What could be considered a 4 or 4.5 may be given a 3 or 3.5 and I’d like to be able to adjust that. Secondly, there are times when I have purchased a stick and it’s been aging for 7 months and then decided to purchase it again and add it to the MyHumidor, I’d like for the new stick to be separate from the aged one so that I can track them accordingly. I hope for the changes but if not I’ll still use the app and just place a date on the newest one. Thank you! Update: The developer has fine tuned this app and honestly it’s perfect. Well worth the little bit of money they’re charging to go ad free. Not only is this app extremely, reasonably priced, it’s user friendly and gives you every thing you need! Great for beginners and veterans alike! There’s another one called Cigar Scanner that allows you to monitor your humidity level and some other things but I don’t even bother with that one. I’d rather use my hygrometers app for that information anyways. I have to be honest when I say I haven’t used the other app but that’s because this one gives me every thing I need! Thank you!!! ### 5/5 — Best App for Cigar Aficionados *2025-07-05* This is an excellent app for keeping track of not only what’s in your humidors, but your personal reviews of all of your cigar experiences. And the developer continues to make great updates based on user feedback. I definitely recommend the add-free version, as it’s well worth a couple of bucks to have an uninterrupted experience. ### 5/5 — Excellent App! *2025-06-23* I have been using this app for several months now and absolutely love it. It is well worth paying for. I have two humidors and I am able to keep an accurate tally of every cigar in both. But beyond that is the journal where I am easily able to keep a log of every cigar I smoke and give a full and detailed review of all aspects of the experience. The fact that it will automatically remove a cigar from my humidor when review it if I choose is very convenient so I don’t have to worry about forgetting to update my inventory. Also on occasion I will move cigars from one humidor to the other, and the app makes it super easy to update. The developer regularly updates the app and I have had no issues or bugs. Keep up the great work! ### 5/5 — Quite Complex but Covers Everything *2025-06-19, version 2.2.0* Took quite a while to catalogue the existing contents of 3 humidors, check prices paid etc. but the app is flexible enough to cope. I like to retain details of cigars smoked so have created another humidor named “Cigars Smoked” for future reference. ### 5/5 — Change Two Thing *2025-06-15* Gave a 5 star rating as it’s a great app and I’m still using it and paid for it even after noticing that there was a lack of 2 features that could be something optional in the settings. This app is everything I could ever want. Tracks all my sticks, how long they’ve been aging, even tells me the current value amongst other things. What I don’t like are 2 things. Firstly, I can’t adjust the star rating on my sticks. The rating is automatically given based on your review and I prefer to control that aspect. What could be considered a 4 or 4.5 may be given a 3 or 3.5 and I’d like to be able to adjust that. Secondly, there are times when I have purchased a stick and it’s been aging for 7 months and then decided to purchase it again and add it to the MyHumidor, I’d like for the new stick to be separate from the aged one so that I can track them accordingly. I hope for the changes but if not I’ll still use the app and just place a date on the newest one. Thank you! **Developer response:** Thank you for the feedback! This is a great recommendation. I will look into integrating this in a future release. :) ### 5/5 — The app we have needed *2025-06-15* This app is awesome. Great review platform with the ability to store pictures with each review. Similarly, you can keep track of your humidor(s) content with pictures of your cigars. ### 5/5 — Even better with the newest update. *2025-05-28* Solid humidor and cigar collection tracker. It got even better with the latest update allowing you to move cigars or copy cigars to another humidor. It would be better if you could transfer a portion of cigars from one to the other versus either moving all, or having to copy to another humidor then adjust numbers in each humidor. I really like being able to give half stars on my ratings as other apps are typically whole star. ### 5/5 — Top App *2025-05-22, version 2.2.0* Sehr gute App zum Verwalten des eigenen Z-Bestandes. Da zahle ich gerne einmalig einen kleinen Beitrag für‘s Abschalten der Werbung. Weiter so! ### 5/5 — Works good! *2025-03-22* At first I thought this was pretty simple. But after trying it I actually really like it. If you don’t want to see ads, it’s only $.99 for life for no ads, LOVE that. Love that you can copy your reviews to share them. Only thing that would make it better is if it was connected online so that you could have friends or groups. But this has been what I’ve been using for a while now and I actually like it a lot. ### 5/5 — Exactly What I Needed *2025-01-30, version 2.1.0* Easy to use and gets the job done. Catalogued all my sticks and no longer have to dig through my box to see what I have. Advanced review option is a great feature. ### 5/5 — Great app *2025-01-29, version 2.1.0* Great little humidor app. Super easy to use with decent features. ### 5/5 — Inventory Made Simple *2025-01-29* This app allows for tracking the inventory of multiple humidors, and it is outstanding. You can leave reviews, actively remove inventory that’s been smoked and never question what is in stock again. If you have many different sticks, multiple humidors and fancy yourself an enthusiast or aficionado, this app is an excellent tool! If you just smoke blunts, you do not need it. ### 5/5 — Best Journal *2025-01-28, version 2.1.0* Been the perfect way to keep track of all my sticks/boxes in multiple humidors. Super easy to Use. Really enjoying this app. Way better than other keeps. ## Most critical reviews (10 lowest-rated) ### 1/5 — Bugs and Phising *2024-11-04* Upon creating an account it flooded my inbox with spam emails of all sorts: pornography? gambling and cigar ads. This is unacceptable for an educational app **Developer response:** Hi there, Thank you for your feedback. I want to clarify that My Humidor does not allow users to create an account or provide any personal information, including an email address. The app operates entirely without collecting or storing your email or any other personal details, and therefore could not send you any emails—spam or otherwise. It’s possible that the emails you received were unrelated to our app. If there’s anything more specific you’d like to share, please feel free to reach out to us directly so we can help clarify further. Thank you for your understanding! ### 1/5 — Terrible app *2024-11-04, version 1.1.2* Terrible app. Full of bugs, constantly crashes, and the features feel like a poorly executed copy of other cigar journals out there. Navigation is clunky, and it doesn’t add anything new or unique. Save yourself the frustration and try a different app. ### 1/5 — DO NOT DOWNLOAD *2024-11-04, version 1.1.2* I downloaded this app today and it crashed my phone. I don’t know if it is riddled with bugs or there is some malicious software now installed on my phone. I AM BEYOND CONCERNED!!! Has anyone else had the same issue? ### 3/5 — Lacking quality of life features *2026-05-03* Lacking AI image capture. This is pretty standard stuff these days. Scan a cigar or receipt and auto add. You have to manually fill out each cigar’s details. Other apps you can search a database by make and select the vitola, type, etc. Until these features are added, this is really just too manual for quick updates and adding, etc. App has potential but not really that advanced. ### 3/5 — Could be a game changer, but... *2025-04-13* I really wanted to love this app, but unfortunately it's lacking two critical features I simply must have. First, I need to be able to log a photo of the cigar when it enters the humidor. I have over 1000 cigars across 20 humidors and the band appearance helps me find the one I'm looking for quickly. Secondly, I need to have a search (or sort) across humidors by aging time so I can smoke by aging time if desired---which is most of the time. If these changes were made, this would be my go to app for my cigar hobby and I'd happily pay more for it. ### 4/5 — Add Feature *2026-03-21* I been smoking cigars for about 3 years on and off. Recently, for the past 4 months, I’ve been digging deeper into the lifestyle and building my pallet up so I can start comparing different types of cigars. This has been helping me keep track of different types of sticks I’ve added to my actual humidor. The only problem I face is adding my cigars to the “humidor in the app” and transferring it from the humidor to the review section “with the picture” would be great if you were to transfer the picture over to the review section. ### 4/5 — Images shouldn’t delete *2025-11-22, version 2.3.1* Excellent app. However, when I add a photo of a cigar and then smoke that cigar to update my humidor, the original photo that I took should remain in my review. ### 4/5 — Fun app *2025-05-09, version 2.1.4* I like the concept and the ability to review and tag a pic. It makes the event more memorable. I like knowing what I thought and what I have on hand. Pretty basic but pretty useful ### 4/5 — Very handy app *2025-01-13, version 2.0.1* It’s nice to see when you put a cigar in your humidor. Please add Lancero to the sizes of cigars. Thanks ### 4/5 — Great App For Every Cigar Connoisseur *2024-12-14* So I absolutely love the app!!! But… I wish you would add more vitola’s, including like Double Robusto and double of other things (these manufacturers just keep making more… maybe add in a fill in option), and also add a pricing system, including an “MSRP” as optional, and then a “what you paid” as well as a totaling system for the collection. And like the last guy said the overall rating should be based off of how we rate the previous aspects. Also add an option to add picture for what’s in the collection and not just for reviews. But I absolutely love it!!! I’ve supported it and will watch and continue to watch an ad every time I open it, even though I disabled ads to support the devs because this is a great app! ## Most praised reviews (10 highest-rated) ### 5/5 — Best way to manage your humidor! *2026-04-02, version 2.3.1* I use this app faithfully and it gives me a great idea of what’s on hand or what I need for my humidor. ### 5/5 — Great app to keep track of cigars *2026-03-24* Really like this easy to use app to keep track of the cigars I purchase and to review them. As a new cigar smoker, this is very helpful to log what I like and don’t like. My only feedback so far is that I wish the photos I take when I add cigars to my humidor would carry over to the reviews section after I review them. Otherwise, I have to take another photo of the cigar which I’m sometimes not in a position to do so at a cigar lounge or hanging with friends. That small addition would be great. ### 5/5 — Great App *2026-03-21, version 2.3.1* Amazing app it’s great for keeping track of all the cigars in my inventory. ### 5/5 — Great option to track favorites *2026-03-19, version 2.3.1* I have been using an app for craft beers for a while and like to try new beers. This is the same for cigars. Perfect ### 5/5 — Great tracking app *2026-02-07* I really like this app. It is simple and clean. There are a few things I would like to see in future releases but still giving it 5 stars. Future release items. Bring over the information from the humidor when reviewing. Ability to review the same cigar multiple times with time tracking on original purchase date, smoke date, time in humidor, etc. A database of known cigars with descriptions (pull from a website or other source) that can be linked to cigars in humidor and ones reviewed. Size descriptions. Tobacco type type selections Shape selections Option to export data for nerds who want to track ### 5/5 — Great App *2026-01-12, version 2.3.1* Easy to use, you’re able to add multiple humidors and Makes it easy to transfer from one humidor to the other. ### 5/5 — Absolutely perfect *2026-01-10* Gave a 5 star rating as it’s a great app and I’m still using it and paid for it even after noticing that there was a lack of 2 features that could be something optional in the settings. This app is everything I could ever want. Tracks all my sticks, how long they’ve been aging, even tells me the current value amongst other things. What I don’t like are 2 things. Firstly, I can’t adjust the star rating on my sticks. The rating is automatically given based on your review and I prefer to control that aspect. What could be considered a 4 or 4.5 may be given a 3 or 3.5 and I’d like to be able to adjust that. Secondly, there are times when I have purchased a stick and it’s been aging for 7 months and then decided to purchase it again and add it to the MyHumidor, I’d like for the new stick to be separate from the aged one so that I can track them accordingly. I hope for the changes but if not I’ll still use the app and just place a date on the newest one. Thank you! Update: The developer has fine tuned this app and honestly it’s perfect. Well worth the little bit of money they’re charging to go ad free. Not only is this app extremely, reasonably priced, it’s user friendly and gives you every thing you need! Great for beginners and veterans alike! There’s another one called Cigar Scanner that allows you to monitor your humidity level and some other things but I don’t even bother with that one. I’d rather use my hygrometers app for that information anyways. I have to be honest when I say I haven’t used the other app but that’s because this one gives me every thing I need! Thank you!!! **Developer response:** Thank you for the feedback! This is a great recommendation. I will look into integrating this in a future release. :) ### 5/5 — Perfect for what I am looking for *2025-12-01, version 2.3.1* App does exactly what I needed. I wanted to keep track of my current collection of cigars. Was easy to add and love the way it ages my cigars. Perfect! ### 5/5 — Great app *2025-11-08, version 2.3.1* I love easily being able to keep track of what’s in my humidor. One thing I would like to see is it show total cost of our cigars displayed. ### 5/5 — Humidor *2025-10-26, version 2.3.1* Really enjoy knowing what I have on hand especially when ordering online. Everything is at my disposal to know what I have and what I need. Thank you --- *Data collected daily from the US App Store and indexed by [AppsHunter](https://appshunter.io/). User reviews are verbatim App Store reviews. Ratings, prices and chart positions refresh continuously; this snapshot is from 2026-08-31.*