guides

Fake iPhone app discounts: how to spot an inflated "was" price

By Andrew Keymaster··7 min read

The short version: check the price history, not the strikethrough

A "90% off" badge on an iPhone app tells you almost nothing. On October 12, 2026, AppsHunter's own price-change data shows apps whose "was" price was set just weeks before the sale, and one that sat at $400 for under three weeks before dropping to a few dollars. The fix takes two minutes: look at how long the higher price actually lasted, how many people paid it, and whether the app has been this cheap before. If the old price was short-lived or unproven, the discount is marketing, not a bargain.

This guide walks through four real price histories from the App Store as of October 2026, then gives you a checklist you can run on any "sale" before you tap Get. Our broader look at where the steepest discounts come from is in the App Store pricing report; this post is the practical companion for a single purchase decision.

How an inflated "was" price works

The App Store has no rule that an app must have sold at its list price before it can be marked down. A developer can raise a price, wait, and lower it again, and every listing aggregator that tracks "previous price" will faithfully report the drop as a discount. Nothing illegal has to happen for the percentage to be meaningless.

What you can't fake is the record. Every price change is timestamped, so the question becomes: how long did the "was" price last, and did anyone pay it? A price that held for a year with thousands of ratings is a real list price. A price that appeared three weeks ago on an app with one rating is a number someone typed.

Case 1: the $400 screen-share app

CastNow Screen Share (a Utilities app) is the cleanest example we found this week. Its price history on AppsHunter reads:

Date Price
August 29, 2026 $0.99
September 18, 2026 $0.99 $400.00
October 6, 2026 $400.00 $2.99

That is a 99% "discount" from a price that existed for 18 days. The app has a single rating on the App Store, so there is no evidence anyone ever paid $400. When we re-checked against the live App Store price on October 12 it had moved again, to $1.99. The honest description is an app that has cost between $0.99 and $2.99 for its entire life, with a temporary $400 placeholder in the middle.

Treat any discount above 95% with suspicion. Real sales on real apps tend to land between 30% and 80% off.

Case 2: a to-do app that was $59.99 for two weeks

ADHD To Do List: OneList, a Productivity app, is currently $4.99, and AppsHunter's deals feed shows it as a 92% drop from $59.99. The history tells a different story:

  • May 12, 2026: $4.99
  • July 18: raised to $9.99
  • August 8: cut to $3.99
  • September 8: raised to $59.99
  • September 23: cut back to $4.99

So the $59.99 price lasted 15 days, and across the four months before that the app never cost more than $9.99. It has only three ratings. The sensible read is that $4.99 is simply the app's price, and the "sale" is a number that came and went. If a lower price existed before (it was $3.99 in August), waiting a few weeks costs you nothing.

Case 3: the app that flips between $9.99 and $59.99

SwiftCall: Auto Dialer & CRM from The Basic Software Company is a more interesting case because it's a real product: 149 ratings averaging 4.4. It's priced at $14.99 today, which AppsHunter reports as a drop from $59.99.

SwiftCall: Auto Dialer & CRM
The Basic Software Company · Business
151 ratings

This app streamlines cold calling by automatically dialing through your contact lists. It offers CRM features to manage leads, schedule follow-ups, and track performance. Enhance team collaboration and efficiency with advanced tools.

$59.99View app

The price log is a seesaw. It moved between $29.99 and $59.99 through the first half of 2026, then the swings got wilder: $14.99 (June 27), $3.99 (July 4), $14.99 (July 17), $59.99 (August 1), $17.99 (August 5), $9.99 (August 12), $59.99 (September 5), $9.99 (September 8), $59.99 (September 13), and $14.99 (October 4). That's roughly ten price changes in about three months.

What this means in practice: $59.99 is a price the app returns to, but it's not clearly a price people pay, since the developer keeps leaving it. The lowest price we've recorded in 2026 is $3.99, so today's $14.99 is not the best you've seen. If you want it, a lower price has appeared several times in the past quarter. If a dialer app genuinely helps your work, the difference of a few dollars isn't worth stressing over, but you shouldn't believe the "75% off" framing.

Case 4: a recurring half-price sale that is real

Not every big discount is a trick. Speak for Yourself is an augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) app, an Education-category tool that helps non-speaking people communicate. It currently costs $149.99, down from $299.99 as of its October 4 price change. It has 401 ratings averaging 4.6, so this is an app people actually buy at specialist prices.

Speak for Yourself
Speak for Yourself LLC · Education
408 ratings

This communication app, developed by speech-language pathologists, uses evidence-based principles to help individuals develop language and automaticity. It offers a large vocabulary with quick access to words, aiming to provide lifelong communication support.

$299.99View app

The history shows a repeating pattern rather than a one-off stunt: $299.99 in February 2023, $149.99 from April 2023, $299.99 again in October 2024, $149.99 in April 2025, back to $299.99 in October 2025, $149.99 again in April 2026, $299.99 from May 2026, and $149.99 since October 4, 2026. The $299.99 price has held for five to six months at a stretch, which is long enough to count as a real list price, and the 401 ratings suggest real buyers.

We haven't tested the app ourselves, and an AAC app is not a casual download, so check with a speech-language professional before buying. For this guide's purposes, it's an example of a discount that passes the test: the high price lasted for months at a time, there is a large rating base, and the lower price has recurred.

Verdict: a discount is trustworthy when the old price held for months and had paying customers. It's marketing when the old price lasted weeks and the rating count is single digits.

A five-step checklist before you buy a "sale" app

Run this on any iPhone app deal. Each step takes under a minute on the app's AppsHunter page, where the price history is listed.

  • How long did the "was" price last? Under 30 days is a red flag. Several months or more is a real list price.
  • How many ratings does the app have? Single digits means the old price was never really tested. Hundreds suggest it was.
  • Has it been this cheap before? If the same low price appeared two or three times in recent months, you're not seeing a rare deal.
  • Is it "free" with in-app purchases? A drop to Free may mean a subscription model or paid unlocks; see our note on paid apps that just went free.
  • Does the discount exceed 95%? Treat it as a placeholder price until proven otherwise.

For tracking a specific app until it actually dips, AppsHunter's price tracker and deals topic pages list apps with price history, and the sales page for apps shows what's currently marked down. For a worked example of reading one app's history in detail, see our Korg Gadget 3 price-history breakdown.


FAQ

Is it illegal for an app to inflate its "was" price?

We're not lawyers, and rules differ by country and by who is presenting the discount. Consumer-protection regulators in several regions have rules about reference prices in advertising. Apple's own App Store page doesn't show a "was" price at all, so the strikethrough you see usually comes from a third-party listing, a deals site, or the developer's own marketing. The practical point doesn't depend on legality: verify the history yourself.

Does a big discount mean the app is bad?

No. A badly designed pricing strategy and a bad app are different problems. SwiftCall has 149 ratings at 4.4 and may be perfectly good; it just doesn't have a stable price. Judge the app on its reviews, and judge the deal on its history.

Where can I see an app's price history?

Each app page on AppsHunter lists timestamped price changes, which is where we pulled the numbers in this post. The data is a log of observed changes, so a brief price that was changed and reverted between two checks could be missed, and the dates are when we recorded the change rather than when the developer made it.

What if the app is already free?

Free is a different case. Check the in-app purchases and subscription terms before you install, and read our guide on how to cancel any iOS app subscription if you've already signed up for something you don't want.

Prices in this post are accurate as of October 12, 2026 and change often. Always confirm the current price on the App Store before you buy.

Written by
Andrew Keymaster

Andrew runs AppsHunter.io, which tracks prices, ratings and user reviews of over 2 million iOS apps.

How we pick apps
#app-deals#price-history#fake-discounts#app-store-pricing#price-tracker#ios-app-deals#buying-guide
← Back to the blog

Comments

Type 3 more characters.