Leave a Review Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon
Unrealistic
When I watch the gameplay silly things will happen and then they get out or get safe when that is completely wrong. Pls fix this game!!!ukshrviuhefr
Good or Bad??? Questionable ✅
I want to like the game. I absolutely like the idea of gameplay. However the problem I have is the same problem that everyone with either good or bad reviews has. The IQ of the players is so terrible that it’s only good to play for a little while. It would actually be really cool if it was designed to be that way until you upgraded the players IQ just like upgraded their other skills and I kept playing hoping for that but ultimately I felt like I was wasting my time on a lost cause. Perhaps someday developers will actually read through the notes and comments that they supposedly take and do something to change it and then without a doubt this game would go from questionable to great!!!Show lessBudsanapostolic
Lost Brain Cells
Upgrading the stadium, collection cash from vendors, and selling Merch were fun, but watching the game play out made me want to cry, laugh, and punch a hole in the wall. It makes no sense why a ground ball to second is being picked up by my right fielder. by the time he gets to the ball runner is headed to third and the ball is overthrown!! To top it off runner rounds third and did out thrown by my third baseman but instead of an out my catcher throws to my pitcher?!? It makes no sense.. lost 14-3, dogs hate me because I’m yelling at them over this nonsense, wife left me because I’m focused on leveling up my abilities and not our relationship, and all I have to show for it is a 0-3-2 season. DONT BUY THIS GAME.. It’ll ruin your lifeShow less@(0RN
Please Improve
I love this game and it has so much potential. It’s extremely frustrating when the base runners make the poor decision to run to the next base with zero chances of making it without tagged out. Some of the purge adds are insanely expensive and don’t payoff. The more expensive items should give you more money. The training center upgrades are also way too expensive. IT ALSO DOESN’T PAY YOU A BONUS FOR HITS ANC CATCHES LIKE IT SAYS IT WILL— this part is very frustrating. This game could be so good. Update- the game somehow lost my progress. Three weeks worth of money and my 2 best players. I’m starting to hate this game. Do betterShow lessNoahkra
Could be better
This is a great game with a great upgrade system but I wish you could upgrade a players base running skill. In the same game I hit the ball to second base and they were slow to get to the ball so my runner got to first base easily, instead of stopping at first he went to second. At which point the second baseman got me out after I took 3 steps from first. Then a couple batters later when I had a runner on second base I hit a foul ball to 3rd but it didn’t count as foul and the next thing I know, I’m out on a game mechanic technicality.
I’ve read a few of the reviews on this game from earlier this year and they all have the same problem I had and nothing has been done about it. Please fix the game before I rage quit and break my phoneShow lesssorryikilledyou
Pretty Lacking
It’s crazy that this is the same team that made Golf Club Tycoon because that game is perfect. So much customization in that game, loads of different things to purchase and make money from. Golfers you get to train and sent to events. This baseball game is so barebones is tragic. There’s literally nothing to upgrade but the stadium itself and the upgrades cost a ridiculous amount of money and barely gain you any money. The vendors are a job. Costing Somtimes millions to buy yet only earn hundreds of coins. This game is 100% dependent on you watching a x3 add to gain money from being away from the game. Atleast in Golf Club you actually could be in the game and see yourself warning money. Not to mention the baseball mechanics are god awful. Players never know when to stop running and always get throw out. And in the flip side an opposing player can run freely around the bases a lot of the time because your infielders act like they have no idea how to throw, oh and only certain defenders really ever do anything, a ball can be hit directly at the SS and he’ll just stand there on the bag and the pitcher or 2nd baseman will have to run over and grab the ball while the runner just gets easy bases. This game is absolutely putrid compared to some of the studios other titles.Show lessKingSquiid
Whoever coded this needs to watch baseball
Base running is stupid, most of the times the base runners will continue running even if the fielder has the ball which results in an easy out.Joherd89
Never Played Baseball Before Tycoon
This… this is the absolute worst thing I’ve seen. Whoever made this has never even heard of baseball before. Leveling up your team does nothing, even with great stats your team looks like a group of 5 year olds who just learned what a baseball is. The game doesn’t even follow baseball rules, not even close. Just played and got the third out of the inning, but after I got the out the runner on third continued to run to home plate and the score counted. After the third out. That plus my catcher throwing the ball back to pitcher when a runner was HALF WAY FROM THIRD TO HOME PLATE made me delete this waste of time and stress and write my first review ever about anything.Show lessandbdhsisl
Developer never played baseball a day in their life…
It’s pretty obvious they did absolutely no research on baseball before
Creating this app. I understand anyone can watch a game on tv but it’s so much more happening that a casual viewer wouldn’t understand.
They bombed they don’t even have the basic rules right. The players don’t have any baseball knowledge. The umpires are blind.
Common flaws:
- ball hit into outfield, runner makes it to first and tries to advance to second, if ball is thrown to second runner immediately called out BUT he can just turn back and it wouldn’t be an out?
- when on defense the other team can steal bases consistently because the infielders and the pitcher play catch (why throw to the pitcher when runners are advancing) then the pitcher tries to throw its way too late and they steal another base. I watched this happen off an infield play and all 4 runners scored
- my guy in third base tries to steal home plate while the ball is in the infield (now that’s just stupid) but what’s worse is all the other runners advance to third while my dumb guy tries to steal home and they all try to steal home and they all get out!) triple play on base stealers is unheard of
Aight one last flaw and I’ll let you go see for yourself:
Last night the opposing team had two guys on third base at the same time smh they both scored on the next playShow lessBigBullyOrg
First idle game
For my first time playing an idle game this one’s pretty fun! Love watching my team do stupid things :) would recommend !
Also are the devs going to keep updating the game?greekgodgg
