1. Home
  2. 🎮 Games
  3. American Football Superstar
  4. Reviews

American Football Superstar User Reviews

American Football Superstar
🎮 Games
⚽ Sports
📝 Word

Customer Experience

Positive experience42.3% of reviews
Neutral11.5% of reviews
Negative experience46.2% of reviews

~ Based on 26 written reviews from the US App Store.

Is American Football Superstar Safe?

American Football Superstar appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for American Football Superstar is 93/100.

This assessment is based on 622 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.7/5.

Safety Analysis

92.8% of ratings point to a safe experience
4.7% of ratings suggest some concerns
2.6% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 622 App Store ratings for American Football Superstar.

Is American Football Superstar Legit?

American Football Superstar appears legitimate, with a few gaps. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for American Football Superstar is 75/100.

Based on 75 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Most RecentHighest RatedLowest Rated

Boring!

Game is so boring! You don’t have control over your player, just upgrading stats and clicking “Next” to either have the game simulated or clicking through an offseason that ends when it wants to. When your stamina runs out, you have to either spend diamonds or leave the game open for hours to get it to fill up. No, the stamina doesn’t fill up while the app is closed. Also, SEVEN HOURS FOR THE SEASON COOLDOWN?? Before starting a new season, you have to wait 7 hours for the cooldown. That’s after clicking “Next” through a boring offseason. You can also spend diamonds to skip but it’s 200 diamonds. Worst “football” game to ever exist!
Show more
Mighty WeaselMighty Weasel

Response from developer

We sincerely apologize that you did not have a satisfactory gaming experience. We will continue to evaluate and optimize the in-game stamina recovery mechanism and the cooldown period between seasons. If you need assistance, please contact our VIP customer service team at tojoygame@gmail.com.

Not what was advertised

The ads I saw and the images on the app page are mostly lies. You don’t get to play in game, let alone have any control of it. It’s just a boring simulator that can’t even be bothered to get stats right.
KageNekemKageNekem

Response from developer

Thank you for playing and supporting our game! We hope you enjoy exploring all the exciting content we have to offer. If you encounter any issues or have any questions, please feel free to contact our VIP customer support team at tojoygame@gmail.com. We are always here to help!

Bad game

Game wasn’t like the pics. You don’t even actually play.
Boss83083Boss83083

Response from developer

Thank you for your feedback. We sincerely apologize that the game content did not meet your expectations. We place great importance on game quality and are constantly striving to improve. Please send your specific suggestions to tojoygame@gmail.com so that we can do better.

There’s potential

There’s potential here. I like the game so far. It’s something easy I can do to pass the time without having to get too involved. I do not understand a couple things about this game though. Like what are the pad shards for? Why do I have to spend gems I can only get 5 of every so often on this game time “stamina” that says whether I play better or worse? Why do I have two staminas? There is just not a lot of explanations in this game currently. I have more questions, but I think you catch my drift. Do more explaining of the features of the game.
Show more
Mississippi-Boy_Mississippi-Boy_

Response from developer

Thank you for your feedback; we will evaluate and improve the guidance regarding various in-game items and props. Fragments are used to upgrade the sports gear you use, while Stamina simulates an athlete's mental and physical condition. If you would like more details about the game mechanics, please feel free to contact us at tojoygame@gmail.com.

Really Want to Like

Game isn’t exactly as advertised in ads. I came expecting in-game playability or some level of control. There’s also no way to view stats to see how you stack up with other teams, and no modifiers that seem to give teams an advantage so winning seems random, and somehow I’m always on a losing team.
With no stat cap, there’s no way to tell which stats are helping your team the most.
And once you go pro, you’re making so much money it becomes obselete. Maybe some way to use the money to purchase more training or stats, or the cheerleaders, shards, tactics, etc. I see the potential here. Hope for some updates soon.
Show more
PuzzleMaster13PuzzleMaster13

Solid

Decent game quick and easy. Ads help a lot for once
Bh4510Bh4510

Game is

Lovely
Mr.messy5Mr.messy5

Most boring game

No action just picking stats you don’t get to play the qb
botz botzbotz botz

Response from developer

Thank you for your feedback. We sincerely apologize that the game content did not meet your expectations. We place great importance on game quality and are constantly striving to improve. Please send your specific suggestions to tojoygame@gmail.com so that we can do better.

Great game, but

Imma keep it short & simple… show every player stats I just feel that’s so important in a career game… the season cool down is a bit much, needs to be able to choose jersey number, should have more face customization options, would love it if I were able to see all the stats from each player, also HS-C ages are not accurate I feel you should start around age 15-16 when in HS & work your way up. Draft day needs work to I could be drafted 3rd round & the game says I was drafted 1st round. 1 last issue is the omission of positions like WR & just a few of the the main defensive positions such as CB & LB.
Show more
KJshowtime47KJshowtime47

Response from developer

Thanks for the amazing, detailed breakdown! We totally agree player stats, custom jersey numbers, more faces, and proper ages are huge for career immersion. We've noted your position ideas (WR/CB/LB) and are already fixing that Draft Day glitch. Your ideas are super helpful as we polish the game!If you have any further questions, please contact us at tojoygame@gmail.com

Pay to play

Pay to play with a bunch of ads
imthinkingimbackimthinkingimback

Response from developer

Thanks for your feedback. We're truly sorry that the game didn't meet your expectations regarding detail and coherence. We take game quality seriously and are constantly working to improve. Please share your specific suggestions at tojoygame@gmail.com so we can make it better.

Ok

Game is ok good time waster, but don’t expect to get positive results from gameplay unless you spend money, the amount of games per season is off also I go 20-24 some seasons like there’s actually 44 weeks in real football, download with a grain of salt you could end up being disappointed
flipeckerwoodflipeckerwood

Response from developer

Thanks for the fair review! We hear you on the balance—our goal is a game where strategy wins, not just spending, so we're adjusting progression for F2P players. We're also reviewing season lengths and scheduling to better match real football logic. Appreciate your honest feedback!If you have any further questions, please contact us at tojoygame@gmail.com

Go at

The quality is good but I can’t see the stats of my players
38?374!338?374!3

Higuhhhh

Ughhh
78788thibjkk78788thibjkk

Stats way off.

The game is so unrealistic for statistics it’s insane.
I’m a RB and every game I rush for 9 yards on 7 carries yet it says I have 6 ypc. There is no end of season stats that I can find from college. High school stats showed up oddly.
I made the college playoffs and it said I failed the contract quest where it says make the playoffs for reward. I entered the draft for the NFL and it said I got drafted in the second round yet when you click next it says you failed to be drafted. Then next season it shows I got drafted in second round pick 17 and it now says I got drafted 5th. The game is so broken it’s laughable.
Would be a fun game if they actually made the game the correct way.
Show more
=NOS==NOS=

Response from developer

We're truly sorry for these frustrating bugs! We've logged your report on the YPC math, playoff quest failure, missing college stats, and the confusing draft logic (2nd vs 5th round). These logic glitches break the immersion, and fixing them is our top priority for the next update. Thanks for calling this out!If you have any further questions, please contact us at tojoygame@gmail.com

Needs work

The ads are the only way to “train” and they don’t load so you can’t train your person same with replenishing stamina so after about 4 minutes of playing the game you can’t do anything
Review wizard 33Review wizard 33

Love it

Great game to unwind to
Stpguy44Stpguy44

game doesn’t work

the app doesn’t even open when after download… tried restarting my device and deleting and redownloading. ig the games just cooked atp.
peenboi21peenboi21

it’s not working anymore after i updated the game

It’s keep on kicking me out after i update the game
Kylie HeniseKylie Henise

It's fun

It can be fun but also annoying at times. Not sure if there is a retirement age. I'm 38 a running back and have good stats and even when my team is first seed I don't make it past 2nd round in playoffs. Very little info on what to expect
champ555142727262champ555142727262

Stat tracking

I just had a semi finals playoff win and didn’t get advance. That needs to be fixed asap. The game is fun, it would be cool to have a little control over what plays are ran. The stat tracking needs a major overhaul, as a running back none of the stats ever make sense. My latest game I had 10 caries for 10 yards, a longest run of 41 yards. And an average yards per carry of 4 yard. That’s impossible to have mathematically. I should have averaged 1 yards per carry as I only had 10 and went 10 yards. And a longest run of 41 yard then only having 10 total yards would imply that I was running backwards half the time. Also the way xp is rewarded seems like it has nothing to do with in game stats. I’ve had games where there were zeros across the board and I got more xp then games where I had stats.
Show more
yee yupyee yup