Solid, but not comprehensive.
I have used this card creator app for several years and feel confident stating that is the best of its type available on the App Store. However, it does show its age somewhat in places: Saga enchantments were introduced several years ago and have yet to make it into the available templates. The Planeswalker template also supports a hard limit of three abilities; no Jace, the Mind Sculptor types with 4+ or War of the Spark planeswalker with only two. Card creator does support static abilities on Planeswalker cards as of recently.
In summary - Card Creator is not perfect, but suitable for most needs.
In summary - Card Creator is not perfect, but suitable for most needs.
Show more
Response from developer
Thank you kindly for your review! Sagas are coming. I’ve been preparing ground for them for the past few weeks and they’re definitely on my radar. Other frame types as well. Planeswalkers will also gradually get more robust (as you can see in the latest update). It will take some time, but I’m all in on making this app better and better with every released version. Happy designing!
Unable to subscribe
Solid mtg card maker unfortunately I am unable to subscribe to the app and features I want to use are locked behind that paywall. I’ve deleted the app and redownloaded it twice. I’ve closed the app down hoping that would resolve the issue but nothing seems to be working. I hope this issue gets resolved in the near future so I can utilize the app and all its features.
Show more
Pretty nice, just a couple notes
1: There is no way to subscribe in app, it just says “cannot load” or something
2: Some of the text-boxes are a bit unresponsive, particularly the Plainswalker ones
3: No option for modern card borders
2: Some of the text-boxes are a bit unresponsive, particularly the Plainswalker ones
3: No option for modern card borders
Gets the job done
Very solid. Hasn’t been updated in 6 years, but there’s just nothing else. Artificer is practically unusable. CardCreator functions great no bugs
Good app but…
I wish you could put static abilities on planes, walkers, and also having it so that you could make saga’s would be nice too
Nur eine kleine Sache…
Das ist jetzt schon die dritte MTG Card Creator App, die ich ausprobiere und ich finde die aktuelle Spielebewertung (3,5) absolut ungerecht für so eine tolle App. Man hat eigentlich alle wichtigen Features und selbst, wenn man nix gescheites drauf hat, sieht das Endergebnis trotzdem immer gut aus. Ich empfehle für die Bilder eine KI wie ChatGPT zu nutzen. Nur eine kleine Sache habe ich zu bemängeln. Man kann keine Datensicherung auf irgendeinem Weg machen. Ich habe das Problem, dass ich die App und meine Karten auch gerne auf unterschiedlichen Geräten nutzen würde, aber leider geht das nicht. Es wäre sehr schön, wenn es bald eine Möglichkeit gibt, sich anzumelden o.ä.. Ansonsten gibt’s nix zu bemängeln. Klar, ein paar Sachen gehen nur für ein bisschen Geld, aber nur kleine Sachen und 6€ für drei Monate ist jetzt echt auch nicht die Welt. All in all bin ich aber sehr zufrieden.
Show more
Perfect For Everything
This app is what I wanted, after about 10 apps, I found this, it’s not Pokémon cards, it’s a unique card pack look. It is brilliant for printing out cards and saving them. If you want to make your own card pack, I prefer to use this app, the text isn’t too small like the other app I checked out, Card Creator is the app for you! But 2 Glitches and suggestions, 1. please add a search bar for seeing cards, and also, 2. The photo place, where you take a photo of the picture you want to use, why is the camera turnt at 90 Degrees? Left is up. Up is right, right is down, down is left, so please fix that, but overall amazing! 5 Stars.
You saved my butt, Thank you Card Creator
You saved my butt, Thank you Card Creator
Show more
Awesome, couple of things though.
This app is actually so much easier to use than other apps, and ever since MTG cardsmith implemented the 30-card limit this place has been a lifesaver.
There are a few obscure card types missing such as battles, plane cards and others, but that matters very little. The basics are here and that means the rest can be made with a few simple extra steps (I do it all the time by making plane cards out of land cards)!
However, there is one glaring problem: the difficulty of selecting images. The way it’s done is very confusing, and the size of the photo library is tiny. If this was updated, I’d say this would be a masterpiece of an app.
This is an amazing app, and I’m glad it isn’t demanding money for everything. Thank you a lot for this masterpiece.
There are a few obscure card types missing such as battles, plane cards and others, but that matters very little. The basics are here and that means the rest can be made with a few simple extra steps (I do it all the time by making plane cards out of land cards)!
However, there is one glaring problem: the difficulty of selecting images. The way it’s done is very confusing, and the size of the photo library is tiny. If this was updated, I’d say this would be a masterpiece of an app.
This is an amazing app, and I’m glad it isn’t demanding money for everything. Thank you a lot for this masterpiece.
Show more
Honestly great
I think this app is awesome, I love being able to bring literally whatever I want to life. I have two minor, personal complaints, though. I would like to see a better way of unloading pictures, the current way is kinda buggy and not very intuitive. Also, I’d like to see an update where we get more card designs, like full art, Sagas, and maybe double sided (transform) cards! Other than that, great app, I would highly recommend if you like magic, being creative or being wacky.
Show more
Really good app!!!
Really good card creator. Highly recommend. The only issue is that the glossary is not very updated and does not have definitions for many effects at all. I would really appreciate if you added more! Thx!
I can’t upload photos:(
Good app, nice variability in customization, unfortunately no matter what I tried - app just doesn’t load in photos from phone. Closing it and opening it didn’t work, I gave access to photos and etc. it’s just doesn’t load in even preview of gallery to select a photo
Suggestions
Overall great app that is flexible and easy to work with, just wish the following were actual features:
-Ability to add Saga Enchantments
-It doesn’t delete your work if you don’t click ‘save’ while creating Planeswalker abilities
-Text on token creatures
-Add other tokens, not just token creatures without having to go in and change it every single time
-Able to toggle full-art
-If I have music in the background while creating, which I usually do, it pauses when I go to import an image
-Battles/Sieges (Landscape arts)
Hope this helps!
-Ability to add Saga Enchantments
-It doesn’t delete your work if you don’t click ‘save’ while creating Planeswalker abilities
-Text on token creatures
-Add other tokens, not just token creatures without having to go in and change it every single time
-Able to toggle full-art
-If I have music in the background while creating, which I usually do, it pauses when I go to import an image
-Battles/Sieges (Landscape arts)
Hope this helps!
Show more
Frame
Wie ändere ich den Frame der Karte? Es ist immer rot
Camera issues
When you go to add an image, it wants to take a picture instead of letting you add a image
Great but could be better
Overall I love this for making my sets but It would be great to get double sided cards.
Great Game, Can be Improved
This game is super helpful for designing Magic cards, but there are a few things that it isn’t capable of: 1. You can’t add abilities to tokens. 2. You can’t make your own expansion symbol. 3. For planeswalkers, you can only have 3 abilities, no more no less, which means you can’t have static abilities. 4. It would be helpful if the game kept track of the amount of each type of card you have in each folder. It would make set building much easier 5. You can’t make the oracle text have italics, of which you need in order to write some keywords like “raid” or “morbid” or fathomless descent” 6. You can’t add the symbol that means the card is double sided. Thank you for reading my opinion. Also, for those of you thinking about becoming a patron: it’s definetly worth it!
Show more
Perfeito
Perfeito
Good, could be great!
Straightforward to use. I would really enjoy a borderless frame to make cards for vertical art.
Would not recommend
It’s stupid that you have to do a pay wall basically do anything you don’t get to choose the cards rarity border or basically anything. The only thing you can choose to do is the art power, toughness and ability that’s it make it so you can have everything without having to join the Patreon just make it so you have everything at the start but there’s some ads this game was so disappointing
Show more
Improve card borders for a more authentic experience
The app is very useful and fun for creating custom Magic cards, but I noticed that the black borders are too thin and don’t match the original cards in circulation. It would be great if the developers could increase the border thickness and make the corners rounded, so the cards look more like the real ones. This improvement would make the card creation experience even more immersive and realistic.
Show more
