Guillotine Fantasy Football User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience9.4% of reviews
Neutral4.8% of reviews
Negative experience85.8% of reviews

~ Based on 457 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is Guillotine Fantasy Football Safe?

Not enough ratings yet to assess Guillotine Fantasy Football.

Is Guillotine Fantasy Football Legit?

Guillotine Fantasy Football appears legitimate, with a few gaps. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Guillotine Fantasy Football is 73/100.

Based on 73 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

2026 updates

The updates they made this year seem solid so far. Did a public draft on the first day it was released without any issues. Hope the original GL is back in its former glory.

The worst

If it was 2010, this would be the worst app ever made. Unfathomable
It’s been two years of refunding players due the inoperable app. Why are you still trying

Fab Bids

Good luck especially if you're out of fab and your opponent is as well. Letting the app decide is going to be very fair. They won't give your opponent 5 straight bids before it cycle over to you in the last round. We have a nail biter now. Woooooo!

Bad app

Worst app I’ve ever used by far. Ruined fantasy playoffs & soured the season experience.

Unbelievable they have money leagues for this app

Devs deserve things that can’t be said in reviews. You have PAID leagues and the app is insanely bad.

Awful

How is it even possible to make an app this bad? Is Matthew Berry writing it himself? Pulled the latest update on Friday, haven’t been able to load my team or league all weekend. It’s somehow getting worse.

Terrible

Super slow won’t allow me to do anything

Terrible App

Terrible app. So inconsistent and not user friendly. After the season I will be deleting and will never use again.

This may just be the worst App ever.

I wish I could give 0 stars. Matthew Berry and fantasy life completely destroyed this app. I am sure they do not care. Before he bought out this from Paul, this app and website was phenomenal. I cannot wait to switch all our leagues to Sleeper.

Terrible App

This app is not user friendly, rarely fully functional, and slow. Group is excited to switch to literally any other platform next year.

Rebuild was rough, but best app even with warts

Best GL app even with the early season bugs.
Original GL company and gets better every week.

Worst fantasy app ever

App isn’t online with game time. Games will
Be over with no updated scoring for players on roster. App is pure trash. Won’t be using this for any leagues going forward.

Terrible app would give 0 stars if I could

Terrible app would give 0 stars if I could… app rarely loads constant errors. Can’t withdraw my money.. will never use this app again after this year is over.

Terrible

This app is awful. Look elsewhere.

UI issues everywhere

This app is a nightmare to work with. The rare times it actually loads out correctly, you still have to get through the unintuitive interface. This coupled with a total lack of visibility on what is happening in your league regarding waivers and standings leaves this app DOA. Thankfully sleeper has this format now and I can cut bait on this atrocity next year. We actually moved a league halfway through the draft because of how poor the interface is.
Show more

Worst fantasy app out there

Absolutely the worst fantasy app out there. Use sleeper for better quality

Horrible

Let me tell you about this app. I gave it a 1 star bcuz I can’t give it a -10.
I can not understand how this app is so bad. From a technical standpoint, it crashes constantly. And I can’t even tell you how many network error warnings I’ve got. Waivers get pushed back all the time bcuz of technical issues. It drops players that you didn’t select to drop when doing waivers.
Then from the user side…they don’t give you any info on players injury status. You have to use other sites to find out if guys were practicing or not. There’s literally no info on anyone.
When looking at FA’s on the wire, it’s automatically sorted by their projections for the week. You can’t filter based on yearly totals, per game averages, nothing. It’s ridiculous.
In years past, you could see all the bids on players when waivers run. Now you can’t. You just see who got the guy, how much they spent, and who they dropped. You have no way of seeing who was the next highest bid or what teams were making bids on guys, nothing. So you end up over bidding on everyone you want bcuz you have no idea what the market is like. It’s so lame.
At this point, they should go back to writing out your whole league on a sheet of paper, scan into a computer, and email it to everyone in the league. It would be way more user friendly.
Show more

Hot Garbage

I pray every week that I lose and get chopped in my fantasy league just so I never have to open this app again

Can’t even get my roster to load.

Seen varied issues with the app over the past few months including inability to make start/sit selections, at this point the app just spins its wheels and refuses to open my league info.

How could it be this bad

It is truly unbelievable how horrible this app is. I feel like you have to try to make it this un-user friendly, clunky, and jumbled. I understand not having the fanciest and latest & greatest in features, but my god they couldn’t even nail basic stuff.