updated: a very nice app
UPDATE: Very much appreciate that tutorial mode is now optional. This is a good app, small install size, and it does its job very well. One of the best Hack News clients for iOS!
Old review: A nice app tarnished by the assumption I want to be forced to use a tutorial when I first open the app to explore it. The audience for this app must skew highly technical. I would be shocked if most users need this level of hand holding. Forcing me to tap the button the tutorial highlights is awful. I just want to explore your app in my own time! Make tutorial mode optional on first launch so I can opt out. Just awful first UX impression, "welcome user, I am so sure you are incompetent with apps that you must tap along with me as I guide you through features and force you to interact whether you need it or not!". YUCK.
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
---------
Response to developer: I guess everyone is different. Catering a hacker news client to people who can't navigate a simple ios app is an interesting choice. I expect this behavior in other apps, just disappointed to see it forced on me with zero option to escape until i tap where you tell me. Other apps usually let you quit tutorials if you want to. Is it too difficult to make the tutorial optional?
Old review: A nice app tarnished by the assumption I want to be forced to use a tutorial when I first open the app to explore it. The audience for this app must skew highly technical. I would be shocked if most users need this level of hand holding. Forcing me to tap the button the tutorial highlights is awful. I just want to explore your app in my own time! Make tutorial mode optional on first launch so I can opt out. Just awful first UX impression, "welcome user, I am so sure you are incompetent with apps that you must tap along with me as I guide you through features and force you to interact whether you need it or not!". YUCK.
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
---------
Response to developer: I guess everyone is different. Catering a hacker news client to people who can't navigate a simple ios app is an interesting choice. I expect this behavior in other apps, just disappointed to see it forced on me with zero option to escape until i tap where you tell me. Other apps usually let you quit tutorials if you want to. Is it too difficult to make the tutorial optional?
Show more
Response from developer
Hi Chet, the tutorial has been made optional in the latest version, thank you.
Does one thing and does it well
Per title. No complaints.
Response from developer
Noooice!
Please do not force tutorials
A nice app tarnished by the assumption I want to be forced to use a tutorial when I first open the app to explore it. The audience for this app must skew highly technical. I would be shocked if most users need this level of hand holding. Forcing me to tap the button the tutorial highlights is awful. I just want to explore your app in my own time! Make tutorial mode optional on first launch so I can opt out. Just awful first UX impression, "welcome user, I am so sure you are incompetent with apps that you must tap along with me as I guide you through features and force you to interact whether you need it or not!". YUCK.
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
---------
Response to developer: I guess everyone is different. Catering a hacker news client to people who can't navigate a simple ios app is an interesting choice. I expect this behavior in other apps, just disappointed to see it forced on me with zero option to escape until i tap where you tell me. Other apps usually let you quit tutorials if you want to. Is it too difficult to make the tutorial optional?
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
---------
Response to developer: I guess everyone is different. Catering a hacker news client to people who can't navigate a simple ios app is an interesting choice. I expect this behavior in other apps, just disappointed to see it forced on me with zero option to escape until i tap where you tell me. Other apps usually let you quit tutorials if you want to. Is it too difficult to make the tutorial optional?
Show more
Response from developer
But it’s provocative, it gets people going!
Please do not force tutorials
A nice app tarnished by the assumption I want to be forced to use a tutorial when I first open the app to explore it. The audience for this app must skew highly technical. I would be shocked if most users need this level of hand holding. Forcing me to tap the button the tutorial highlights is awful. I just want to explore your app in my own time! Make tutorial mode optional on first launch so I can opt out. Just awful first UX impression, "welcome user, I am so sure you are incompetent with apps that you must tap along with me as I guide you through features and force you to interact whether you need it or not!". YUCK.
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
Also, forcing me directly to login on an app like this makes me suspicious of the developer's intentions. I never blindly trust my credentials to a new app especially one with so few users. The app is probably trustworthy, but "tutorial mode" begs the question of why the developer thinks the most important thing to do, before you can even try the app, is to push user login. Hacker news website is perfectly enjoyable without login. In fact, there is little reason to login unless you want to participate in the site.
A very nicely laid out app that is very usable despite the nanny like hand hold that is forced on you.
Show more
Full featured but design is not great
Probably the most fully-featured HN app but I can't use it because there are too many annoyances with the design and layout. I keep it installed for notifications.
