Some bugs need to be fixed
Used to be good, very buggy now
Additionally, seems like no one really plays it anymore, I get matched with the same person every game.
Very fun
Fun but live play issues
Complete disappointment
Love it
Font size too small
Awesome
Crappy software
Educational Purposes
Help!
Missing
Response from developer
Thanks for the review! Please let us know if you find any bugs by emailing us at investorisland@fool.com or using the issue reporting system in the main menu.
Fun Game
Great concept
Fabulously intelligent game, a blend of stocks and chess
Cool down
Needs Work
Too Random, ruins strategy, Pay to Play
Secondly, the opponent matching scheme is deeply flawed. I was frequently put up against players rated higher than me, not just one but in some cases three levels higher. Can’t really compete in those situations, they just have more upgrades to the stocks and more perks.
Third, when you lose against a stronger opponent your ranking suffers. So it’s really hard to climb the ladder (see pay to play comment above).
Fourth, I understand why they want the stock market as part of this given it is the Motley Fool, but it ruins the game IMO. Despite the best strategy, you can still lose just because someone’s choice of stocks outperforms your selection. Also your selection of available stock is limited by your ranking which is difficult to climb unless you pay to play.
So, after six months of seeing if this could be the strategy game for me, I’ve deleted it. It came after I lost a game, where despite a great strategy (I had the lead throughout and was poised to win) the opponents stocks lit up and mine fell apart in the final three turns. Takes the fun out of it when you play perfectly but still lose.
Take the randomness out of it and make it a one time purchase and I might have bought it. It’s a fun game, well put together and the strategy aspects are sounds. But too random and pay to play ruins it overall. Plus they don’t respond to your in game comments to the support team, at all.
Response from developer
We really appreciate your time and this feedback -- you make a number of valid points. I can say that we're continually balancing perks and we have some improvements to the matching system coming soon that should make the pairings more fair and allow you to climb the ladder, get more stocks and more perks! Also apologies if we missed your support request, we try to get to them all, but occasionally miss a few. If you want to drop us a note at investorisland@fool.com, I'd be glad to answer any questions.
