Mafia Mystery Reviews: Is It Legit?

Customer Experience

Positive experience54.7% of reviews
Neutral8.5% of reviews
Negative experience36.8% of reviews

~ Based on 318 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say about Mafia Mystery

Is Mafia Mystery Safe?

Mafia Mystery appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Mafia Mystery is 88/100.

This assessment is based on 2,356 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.4/5.

Safety Analysis

84.0% of ratings point to a safe experience
3.1% of ratings suggest some concerns
12.9% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 2,356 App Store ratings for Mafia Mystery.

Is Mafia Mystery Legit?

Mafia Mystery appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Mafia Mystery is 100/100.

Based on 100 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

RECOMMENDED

I love this game so much, been playing it for five years now.

Come join us!

Awesome game & a fun community!

Too many things behind a paywall subsirctoon

I love the style and game by itself like among us but in text mafia , but A lot of things behind a paywall subsirction , like extra customization slot , making matches YES , you can’t make games if you’re not subscribed , and coins need a grind , and most skins cannot even be bought without a subsirction , and yada yada yada , if they removed that aspect then the game would’ve easily been a 4-5 star chill game
Show more

AMAZING GAME

Super fun, strategy building, and good for team building. Amazing community, brand new features, and so many roles and lineups. PLAY ITT

Download DOWNLOAD 43 times

My life was very boring before I found out about this game. I recommend downloading it. I, am postman pat.

5 stars

In game it says 5 star ratings =more updates so we better get some

Band

I was band for no reason on the first day got the game for an hour

AMAZING

AMAZING FUN GAME

Hackers

Hacker hacked into my webcam creepy

Fun, but has toxic people, and game glitches

The game is pretty fun and slightly addicting at times! Which is to say it’s good. And I really appreciate the devs for adding new roles from time to time and somewhat listening to the community. ^^

However, occasionally the day/night cycle glitches and skips a few nights. I also remember there used to be bots (fake players) in the past, though fortunately that got fixed!

The players, especially the new and really experienced ones, can be quite toxic and unforgiving of mistakes (trust me, I’ve made lots of them). But I know thats kinda out of the developers’ control, so I’m only taking away a star for the glitches.

I get that some people are mad about the removal of exp games and other updates, but to be honest, it’s not all bad.

Of course- thank you, Toast Mobile, for being great developers!
Show more

This game is trash

The gameplay is boring, the community stupid, the people who manage the game have no desire to improve it. A terrible game, would give it 0 stars if I could

Bad app

Lowkey wouldn't recommend too addicting

Chaos and Mental Exhaustion

I started off genuinely loving this game, but the May 2026 update changed everything. Since the update, there has been a massive shift in the lobbies. More experienced players are now flooding regular lobbies and using it as an opportunity to insult, ridicule, humiliate, and bully less experienced players. I myself have been subjected to verbal abuse and online bullying as an adult. That is never okay.

I am highly disappointed in the developers' decision to make these changes without considering the impact on the player experience and community. What was once a fun and engaging game has become demoralizing at times. People need to be aware that this kind of toxic environment can genuinely impact your mental health. No update is worth that.
Show more

Good game

It’s fun

AMAZING

I fell in LOVE with this game!!!

Super fun game

This game is really fun to play u can play with ur friends and invite me to at with you. The game quality is good and u
can play on ur phone.

Game Broken and staff won’t do anything.

So my mafia account has been hacked or doxxed idrk but everytime I redownload the app it doesn’t fix anything. The game staff are always inactive as well as whenever you put a new support ticket in they never do anything about it.

Ranked??

Folk.

Biased and racist game

Admin is biased and lets racism slide, will be punished if you speak out against it, do not play this game if you have any self respect.

Toxic players plus random bans

@Swoopert is targeting me and giving me issues and the game doesn’t want to fix it bc I’m a free to play player instead of a pro. I than get banned for 12 hrs bc of it so if your new you got a target on your back