たのしい
so cute
Insanely Addicting Semi-Idle game!
Incredible game, genuinely
This game is really an all around treat . It’s perfect for idle play, popping in to upkeep your farm (with very pleasing and cute sound design and art direction! Seriously the characters and clothing options are so cute and fun to unlock!) And it feels like theres always something to look forward to with the different weather patterns and trying to get different mutations on specific plants for maximum profit. Seriously, I don’t even know what exactly it is about this game but it’s just loads of fun and super addicting. Another thing I love is the multiplayer aspect. Hopping into a discord call and just having everyone chat about their gardens is just such a blast.
That being said, I am VERY excited for future updates of this game. Since it’s still early access I believe, theres lots of room to make it even better! I would love to see more seeds and maybe some different weather patterns that leave different mutations on your plants! Or even higher rarity eggs, maybe adding furniture that impacts your garden somehow? I don’t know theres just so many options & opportunities for growth. I’m super excited to see what they add next. I honestly find myself fantasizing when I’m bored about what plants I get to harvest next, it’s an addiction at this point LOL but I love it.
All in all, super great and fun game with adorable art! Highly recommend it!
Why magic garden
Amber, Dawn
Great afk game
もっとにんきになってほしい!!
Addicted
1. The ability to get rid of seeds I won’t use. I like using a seed finder pet to find those seeds that aren’t available to buy, but I end up with over 60 seeds I don’t use. It would be great to be able to sell them like we can pets.
2. Expanding the field. I’m not saying to be able to make it obnoxiously huge, but if we are stuck with all these seeds, we should have enough room to use them.
3. Ability to put more pets on the field. If we could use 5 pets instead of just 3, it would be a lot better. I know we can buy the pet shelter thing but it’s 80B and that takes a long time to get when you first start. I’m no where NEAR that. Plus buying special eggs at 300 M makes it slower. So maybe bring the price down from 80B.
4. More seeds. There are barely any different choices and the fact the rare ones barely come in stock. I do like having the snow and dawn shops with different seeds, but there are many more that we could have. I do t have the need to buy the first 10 seeds bc I get them with seed finder. I’m overflowing with them.
5. Stability. The app is constantly restarting. It does it like 10 times in an hour. I thought it was just my phone but I play it on different devices and it does it on them as well.
Unexpected overheating
Response from developer
Hi! So sorry to hear the performance hasn’t met your expectations. This is an area I’ve been working to improve, and I’ve recently added more options to reduce head and improve battery life particularly on phones older than 5+ years such as yours. You can lower the FPS to 30 or lower and reduce the Render Scale to 100%, as well as disabling animations. If you need more help, please email me at avi@magiccircle.studio and I’ll be happy to help!
Loveee this
The graphics and animation is to die for 💗
Attends interminable
Download this Game!
Hands down the best game I've played in a while!!
My husband and I are long-distance right now, and we play this together on Discord. Honestly, it has brought us so much closer. We spend so much time on it that most nights we end up falling asleep while playing.
My only real suggestion is about the wait times. Once you start buying the more valuable plants and waiting for mutations, the harvest times get pretty long. It’s fun to watch them grow and save up for store items, but the downtime can get a bit boring.
It would be awesome to have some mini-games to pass the time while we wait!
* For single-player, a simple match-3 puzzle using the game's plants and animals, or even a little pinball game would be perfect.
* For multiplayer, classic games like tic-tac-toe or connect four would be so fun to play together.
They could give rewards like seeds, magic dust, or coins to make it worth it.
Overall, I absolutely love this game and highly recommend it, especially for couples!
Discordから
こういう系のゲームには珍しいずっとできるゲームです。
ペットが手に入る段階になるとなお、楽しくなってくる。
アーリーアクセスということなので今後にかなり期待しています。
Great Game
But there are some features we wish the game had:Trade/ selling with each other, FULL restocks of crops regardless of their cost, an activity log that tells you if you’re losing or gaining money when selling crops, how much your crops are worth before you sell them, and potted plants that you can put outside of your garden.
A cool feature in the game: You can play through discord, and your characters mouth moves when you talk. There are also NO ADS in the game which is a bonus!!
Fun AFK game
Response from developer
thanks for the great suggestion, and for the great review! happy gardening :)
Great early game, but falls hard
However, once you progress further into the game, especially when you start dealing with costs in the millions, the balance really starts to fall apart. Growth times suddenly jump to 8 hours or more, and the profit you get doesn’t scale well enough to match. It ends up feeling like you’re waiting far too long for very little return, which slows progression to a crawl and makes the game feel more tedious than fun.
The pets are a nice idea and they’re definitely cute, but their usefulness feels limited. A few of them are helpful, but having to constantly manage their hunger becomes more of a chore than an engaging mechanic. After a while, it’s hard to stay motivated to keep feeding them when the payoff doesn’t feel worth it.
Decorations are another mixed aspect. They look great and add personality to your garden, but the prices are so high that they feel almost unattainable. Spending billions on cosmetic items just doesn’t seem realistic for most players, which takes away from the enjoyment of customizing your space.
One of the most frustrating parts for me was progression being tied to luck or availability. I had a 42-day streak and still never managed to purchase a sunflower seed, which felt unfair and ultimately killed my motivation to keep playing.
In the end, I’ve uninstalled the game and won’t be returning unless there are updates that improve the balance and progression system. Magic Garden has a lot of charm and a strong start, but right now it struggles to maintain that enjoyment long-term.
