The Secret Society User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience74.2% of reviews
Neutral10.3% of reviews
Negative experience15.5% of reviews

~ Based on 663 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is The Secret Society Safe?

The Secret Society: Mystery appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for The Secret Society is 86/100.

This assessment is based on 42,184 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.3/5.

Safety Analysis

82.3% of ratings point to a safe experience
12.1% of ratings suggest some concerns
5.6% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 42,184 App Store ratings for The Secret Society.

Is The Secret Society Legit?

The Secret Society: Mystery appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for The Secret Society is 100/100.

Based on 100 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Doesn’t operate properly

I’m on an iPhone 14 Pro Max. It keeps freezing up. I’ve deleted and reinstalled the game numerous times. It looks like a fun game….. if it would work.

The Secret Society

I used to love this but had the new updates. I used to love playing gem match but now I can rarely do it within the time frame. Once I’ve used up all my crystals etc. I won’t be playing any of the games anymore. Disappointed.

Getting Frustrated

I overall like this game. However, when you have to spend about 200 turns in the same setting to achieve an object, it gets tiresome. The whole point of the game for me is to explore multiple settings. I think this part of the game needs to be fixed.

Fun find game

Could improve with more painterly, well drawn scenes

Please fix bug

I was playing the game and it will not let me purchase anything and it said that it was an error and I tried to go back in and it’s not working

Secret Society

Great game

So refreshing!

I have been entertained by this game for many years now and the new Monster Garden scene is a revelation of more neutral, realistic colours and objects. What a pleasure to take part in! I thoroughly enjoy the yearly Christmas scenes which are created with beautiful designs and colours to celebrate a joyous season. Ever thought of creating more haunted, dark scenes, especially for Halloween? That would be really cool!Thank you so much for helping me relax and unwind! Keep it up! Looking forward to many more years of new and fabulous scenes!
Show more

Secret Society game

I’ve been playing this hidden object game for over 10 years every day. They keep adding content plus it has so much going on. Love it

Suggestion for Explorer’s Competition

I’d like to suggest displaying the Player’s progress towards the goals of 24, 56 and 90 total wins, in addition to the remaining time. I generally have no idea how close I might be to the various levels, and would like to know.

Secret Society Hidden Mystery

Game freezes, can’t play..updates need looking into.. feel like quitting!!!!

Find 500 badges of the order

I enjoy this challenge very much. Especially the way it takes me to all the different magic pictures - not just the ones involved in the current challenge. Do you have plans to have a similar challenge in the future?

IPAD doesn’t update with new game info on time

My husband plays the game on a Kindle and I play on my IPAD every time there is a new game, his game updates but I can’t get mine to update on my IPad until much later, usually the same day. This is annoying and holds me up from starting the new game.

Not happy

I have enjoyed this game for some years but I am now fed up that I am regularly being told that I have missed days when I know I haven’t .

Downward trend with recent updates

Update 2026
I have enjoyed this game for years but I will be quitting as soon as my purchased game resources run out. It seems the developers are implementing a strategy where in order to win a monthly puzzle you must purchase additional tokens. No longer can you finish simply by playing the game. This is basically a subscription. Expect to spend over an hour playing every single day, and even if you do that expect to have to buy extra resources to complete the challenge. The developers have changed the odds of collecting tokens over time, and although you can collect some tokens for “free” in the special gem match, that gets more difficult to play over time. All alternative locations to collect tokens needed for the monthly challenge are now restricted. In short, there are now so many restrictions and low odds of completing the monthly objective you almost always have to pay. I understand the devs need to make some money but I’m not participating in what has become a de facto subscription. It has been fun for quite awhile but I’m done.

Update: 2024
Game has improved since I wrote the last review. They have added some features and corrected some mistakes of the past so I now have upgraded the rating to 4 stars .
March 2019-I’ve played this game for at least 2 years and the major updates lately have been bad. Useful talismans have been removed from several scenes, several scenes have been redesigned to make the objects unrecognizable, and the rewards upon completion have been reduced. In short, the company is clearly looking for more $ to play to the point that it is now ridiculous. DON’T FALL FOR IT. Let’s send a message by not paying another cent. 2016:I've paid money more than once for this game so I find it very irritating that both a uTube and regular splash ad launches each time I play the game. Paying customers shouldn't be interrupted by intrusive ads. Both ads need to be cancelled to return to the game. The game play itself is fine and I will raise the rating if ads are removed. Update 7/18: the ad splash problem described above was fixed but the latest update has created a new problem. Zoom has been restricted so you now can’t zoom in closely to find hidden objects. Talisman rewards are hard to get. I enjoy the game overall but dislike how updates constantly seem to push users to spend more money. I have spent enough.
Show more

Lovin it

I love this game! It is challenging but fun. I love the new scenes to explore. I really liked the medallion hunt. Recommend it to my friends all the time.

Love it!

Absolutely love this game! I have been playing for many years now! Got many people hooked, but some of them deleted it because they often suggest to buy things. It’s the only game that I refuse to delete when my storage is full on my phone

Suggestion for Explorer’s Competition

I’d like to suggest displaying the Player’s progress towards the goals of 24, 56 and 90 total wins, in addition to the remaining time. I generally have no idea how close I might be to the various levels, and would like to know.

Good game

So exciting

Unfun game

G5 tech support SUCKS!!!! When players reach a certain level the levels then go CRAZY!!! Then the player is deleted from the Best Players List. They are doing very little to fix the glitch !

Hidden objects

This is by far the BEST hidden objects game out there. And the most challenging. Every other hidden object game pales in comparison to this one.