Great concept, poor execution
Edit: The developer said these issues have been fixed so changing my rating to 4 stars
Response from developer
Hi Sooppa1 - Thanks ever so much for your detailed review. I think I've fixed most of these issues. I've recently completely rebuilt Which Thing First? from the ground up. There are multiple lists, the iPad keyboard no longer covers what you're typing, and finished lists reorder themselves so #1 sits at the top. Being straight with you on the one thing I haven't changed: comparing a new item against the others is how the ranking is worked out, so that's still there by design. I'd be really grateful if you gave it another look. All the best, Matt in Yorkshire.
Excellent update
Response from developer
Hi wd75004 - I'm so sorry I have taken a long time to put things right. Losing your tasks was never meant to happen :( . I've just released v2, it's a complete rebuild from the ground up with proper, reliable saving, plus multiple lists so you can keep the paper method going for more than one thing at a time. If you still have it installed, your old list should carry across. Once again, I'm so sorry! Please give it another chance! (everyone who bought the upgrade automatically gets the new version). All the best, Matt, West Yorkshire UK.
Does not work
Response from developer
I’m sorry you found bugs Debrevns. I’ve completely re-written the app in the last few months so please give us another try. The new version has multiple lists, and the keyboard handling should be better behaved. All the best, Matt West Yorkshire, UK.
Bought app twice
Response from developer
I'm so sorry Arlynn1 - being asked to pay again was never meant to happen :( I've just released v2.0 of the app. It's a complete rebuild from the ground up, has multiple lists, and fixes the problem properly: the one-time upgrade is a proper purchase that restores automatically on all your devices - no paying twice, ever. All the best, Matt.
Life saver
Great way to prioritize
Very simple app good idea
-Have more than one task list for more than one job/place.
-Type more words for individual tasks.
-Move a task to the top priority spot given a near immediate situation.
I liked the idea but only four tasks without purchase it’s an app with the goal to simplify prioritizing and it limits you to simple amounts of tasks to prioritize without purchasing.... lol.
Response from developer
Hi JL! Thanks for leaving a review of my Which Thing First app a few years ago. Just to let you know I've released v2.0 of the app. It's a complete rebuild and supports multiple lists. I would be grateful if you gave it another look. All the best, Matt.
One of my favourite apps and great tech support
Still use it. Still love it.
Helpful - room for improvement
Response from developer
Hi Yonah Thanks for leaving a review of my Which Thing First app some years ago. Just to let you know I've released v2.0 of the app. It's a complete rebuild, supports multiple lists, and items do reorganize after all the comparisons have been done. I would be grateful if you gave it another look. All the best, Matt.
Excellent app
Need Multiple Lists
Response from developer
Hi Brien in Florida Thanks for leaving a review of my Which Thing First app years ago(!). Just to let you know I've released v2.0 of the app. It's a complete rebuild and supports multiple lists. I would be grateful if you gave it another look. All the best, Matt in Yorkshire.
Great Tool for Multi-taster
Lost my tasks
Please fix! Thank you!
The Best & Fastest Prioritizer
Response from developer
Hi Kurt4i - thank you, and sorry it's taken me this long to say so. "Cut through the clutter fast" is exactly what I was aiming for, so that meant a lot to read. v2.0 is out now, a complete rebuild, with multiple lists - handy if you're keeping the nonprofit and the copywriting business separate. All the best, Matt in Yorkshire.
Great concept, poor execution
Even worse, iPad keyboard covers the part of the list I was writing, so have to guess you are typing without error and shrink keyboard every time to check. Again this problem doesn't show up on the free version.
I hope the developer fixes all this, bc a great idea. Will change my rating if so.
Ideally would also have color categories, multiple lists etc.
Otherwise, Someone else will do it first!
Essential App to determine prioritization
My original review: "Other prioritization apps don't do what this one does so perfectly -- actually determine the sequential priority of your task list. You enter all your current tasks like any other app has you do. But the brilliant thing here is that the program then compares two of those tasks at a time in every combination. Each time you simply choose the most urgent of the two. The results of the comparisons determine which tasks should be done first. Thank you for allowing me to easily do "first things first!"
Response from developer
Hi mark4strom Thanks ever so much for your review, and sorry I have left it so long to update the Which Thing First app. I've just released v2.0 of the app. It's a complete rebuild from the ground up, and supports multiple lists. I would be grateful you you gave it another look. All the best, Matt.
very limited- not worth an upgrade
Response from developer
Hi lefty7guitar - Thanks for your review a loooong time ago! I've just released v2.0, a complete rebuild: adding items is much quicker, there are multiple lists, and the free version now gives you two lists of four items rather than four items in total. It's still no checkbox to mark things complete, but I should be able to work that in to a forthcoming release. Worth another five minutes if you're curious. (Better late than never?) All the best, Matt, in Yorkshire, England.
Good - not great
Example. An Office list, A Home list - Hobby Project list(s)
Response from developer
Hi DSCme - only fourteen years late (!), but you can now have an Office list, a Home list and as many hobby project lists as you like. The new v2+ is a complete rebuild and has multiple lists. Thanks for the suggestion - you were the first to ask. Please come back! All the best, Matt.
Love its concept
Response from developer
Thank you 作什么, and apologies for the very slow reply! I recently release v2. of Which Thing First? It's a complete rebuild from the ground up with a proper modern design, multiple lists, and an animation that brings your ranked list to life. I'd love to know if it's earned that star back. All the best, Matt in sunny Yorkshire England.
