北京一卡通 vs 中广家书
Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.
北京一卡通
Read full descriptionHide full description
北京一卡通 app已支持iPhone和Apple Watch开通北京手机一卡通。用户使用Apple Pay刷北京一卡通乘坐公交、地铁等公共交通工具，省去携带实体公交卡的不便，感受耳目一新的移动生活方式。用户也可以使用北京一卡通 app，在线完成对开通的北京一卡通手机充值，享受快人一步的感觉。 主要功能有： • 开卡：使用iPhone和Apple Watch开通北京手机一卡通卡。 • 充值：完成对iPhone和Apple Watch中公交卡的充值。 • 退卡：不再使用卡时，可以将卡内余额及可退服务费退还至指定账户。 • 乘车码：享受扫码乘车的便捷。 • 更多功能：在线客服、交易记录查询、网点查询等。
中广家书
Read full descriptionHide full description
主要功能包括： 1、【纪念堂管理】： 认领成为纪念堂主办人后即可管理纪念堂，并可邀请其他人成为管理员共同管理编辑纪念堂信息、审核和管理纪念堂数据等 2、【瞻仰逝者纪念堂】： 用户可访问认领、管理和浏览过的纪念堂，根据用户身份状态显示逝者纪念堂信息，包括：浏览纪念堂逝者头像、名称、生卒年、个人生平、权限范围内的相册数据等 3、【访客来宾互动】： 3.1.献花：用户可点击献花，为逝者献上一束花以表哀思，可分享该页面到社交平台 3.2.签到：用户可做签到操作，选择与逝者关系、寄语以表达哀思，管理员账号可查看签到名单，并支持图片导出到本地，以及删除签到记录等操作 3.3.留言和精选留言：用户可对逝者进行留言怀念，访客用户留言仅自己可见，管理员可查看所有，并可删除用户留言；管理员可设置精选留言，所有用户均可见； 3.4.人生事记：用户还可添加逝者相关人生事记，缅怀逝者，留存纪念 3.5.新建相册和上传照片：管理员和主办人可创建逝者怀念相册，以及上传添加照片和视频，并设置查看范围，保护隐私安全 4、【线上祭礼】： 未来版本将推出线上文化祭礼重点功能，将文化与祭祀相结合，将礼仪与怀念相连接。全新的线上祭扫体验，即将上线 纪念堂续费服务协议：https://manager.zhongguangshimei.com/?&type=6#/useragreement 自动续费服务规则：https://manager.zhongguangshimei.com/?&type=7#/useragreement 隐私政策：https://manager.zhongguangshimei.com/?&type=1#/useragreement
Screenshots
Verdict
The clearest difference is rating: 中广家书 at 5.0 against 北京一卡通's 1.5. 中广家书 also leads on update cadence (every 3 weeks vs every 2 months) and review sentiment (29% vs 18%). 北京一卡通's advantage is ratings volume (146 vs 2). On price, ads, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.
Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS
Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.
中广家书 holds the better App Store score, 5.0 against 1.5. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: 北京一卡通 has 146 ratings behind it against 2, so its average is the more settled of the two. Written reviews point the same way: 18% of 北京一卡通's written reviews are positive against 29% of 中广家书's.
北京一卡通 ships an update every 2 months, 中广家书 every 3 weeks. The most recent releases landed on November 6, 2026 and November 3, 2026 respectively.
| Parameter | 北京一卡通 | 中广家书 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Rating | 1.5 (146 ratings) | 5.0 (2 ratings) — better |
| Positive reviews | 18.2% of reviews | 28.6% of reviews — better |
| Number of ratings | 146 — better | 2 |
| Update frequency | Every 2 months | Every 3 weeks — better |
| Ads | No | No |
| In-app purchases | No | No |
| Devices | iPhone, iPod | iPhone, iPod |
| Requires iOS | 13.0 | 12.0 — better |
| Further details — not scored | ||
| Size | 170 MB | 427 MB |
| Age rating | 4+ | 17+ |
| Developer | Beijing Municipal Administration & Communication Card Co., Ltd. | 中广视媒(北京)文化传播有限公司 |
Customer experience
北京一卡通
中广家书
Bugs and requests
北京一卡通
Reported bugs
71 issues- App crashes on startup
- App crashes when enabling Face ID
- App crashes when detecting VPN
- Cannot connect with WeChat
- Cannot sign up without Chinese cell number
Show 66 moreShow fewer
- Verification code not received
- Cannot log in
- Randomly deducts money
- App flashes and exits
- 4G connection fails to load
- Cannot recharge for a whole day
- Universal link fails
- System busy error
- Foreign phone numbers do not receive verification codes
- Cannot select country/region for phone number
- App detects VPN and crashes
- Cannot recharge, money deducted but not credited
- App requires forced upgrade to recharge
- SMS verification not sent
- Foreigners cannot upgrade/add money
- Passport number not supported
- App and phone card upgrade leads to health code association issues
- Bus overcharging
- App requires login for all actions
- App bans specific nationalities
- Recharge function shows unexpected error
- Username requires letters, numbers, and underscores
- Login button disabled for SMS login
- Password input box disabled for username/password login
- Feedback redirects to login view
- Double charging on bus
- Cannot scan code on city buses
- QR code not refreshing at station
- Charged full fare for whole trip when QR code fails
- Physical card recharge fails to link with WeChat
- Cannot perform real-name authentication with passport
- Date/time picker for transaction appeal is unresponsive
- App shows end of trip but charges full fare on next ride
- Refunds for incorrect charges are not processed
- Cannot input passport number for foreigners
- Coupon not applied for discount
- Lost card/money after phone flashing
- No transaction history available
- Cannot scan code on city buses
- Cards disappear with money
- Login does not support auto-fill or copy-paste
- WeChat login experience is poor
- Recharge fails, money deducted
- Refund process stuck on 'refunding'
- Customer service unprofessional and slow
- Electronic invoice submission unresponsive
- App takes a long time to open
- Recharge fails, showing query timeout
- Cannot use other payment methods
- Existing balance cannot be used for recharge
- Card disappears from wallet after a period
- Face recognition fails
- Sweep failed happens very often
- Charge failed and money lost
- Bus not easy to scan
- Cannot use Alipay for recharge
- Cannot log out of account
- iPhone X crashes
- Cannot download the app
- Card disappears after phone loss
- Digital card has a fee
- Cannot bind existing physical card
- Face ID causes app to crash
- Server connectivity issues
- App is slow and buggy
- Incompatible with iOS 11.4
Requested features
11 requests- Improve real-time bus tracking
- Add discount information
- Improve transaction history display
- Allow binding of existing physical cards
- Improve customer support responsiveness
Show 6 moreShow fewer
- Provide clearer instructions for bus scanning
- Add dark mode
- Improve login process (auto-fill, copy-paste)
- Allow registration without Chinese phone number
- Support passport numbers for foreigners
- Improve refund process transparency
中广家书
Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.
In-app purchases
北京一卡通
No in-app purchases
中广家书
No in-app purchases
