Comparison

英雄坛说 vs 金书群侠传

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

英雄坛说

Embark on an open-ended martial arts adventure in a mysterious land. This MUD-inspired RPG allows you to shape your destiny, from honing martial arts to living a life of crime. Experience a world with realistic needs and dynamic NPCs.

Highlights
  • Open-ended martial arts RPG
  • MUD elements
  • Player-driven narrative
  • Realistic survival mechanics
  • Dynamic NPC interactions
  • Martial arts training
Features
Read full description

玩家交流QQ群:138692017 英雄坛是一款融合了MUD(Multi-User Dungeon )要素的开放剧情武侠RPG (Role Play Game)。由于在无意间触发了远古大陆英雄坛的时空转换装置,你被传送到东方的一片神秘大陆,以后的故事就在这片大陆上展开。 游戏开始时玩家的年龄都被设定为十四岁,可以根据喜好设定性别和属性,然后你就出现在这片大陆的中心位置--平安小镇上。虽然是虚拟世界,可依然延续了真实世界的基本元素,在这里你的年龄会逐渐增长,会口渴也会饿肚子,也需要金钱来过生活。这里的NPC(Non-Player-Character (非玩家控制人物))都在貌似平静中生活着,你的出现会不会改变他们的生活呢?可能只有你才知道。不同于传统意义上的RPG ,在这个虚拟世界里没强制有贯穿始终的故事主线,你可以完全按照个人喜好决定你在这里的人生。你可以勤练武功,惩奸除恶,也可以杀人越货自甘堕落;或者什么都不做,只是四处闲逛,消磨时间。一切都由你自己把握。当然,自此身在江湖,多学点武功自然不是坏事。另外还有江湖人士放出消息,这片大陆的统治者金远见王朝将派出赏善罚恶使者,招开武林大会,能在这个大会上扬名立万那也是人生幸事。 游戏为复刻版,大家玩的开心!(ฅ• . •ฅ)ﻌﻌﻌ

About

金书群侠传

Embark on an epic martial arts journey in a dynamic wuxia world. Explore rich storylines, master countless skills, and build your legend. Experience a unique adventure with romance, personal growth, and strategic combat.

Highlights
  • Rich original storyline with branching plots
  • Over 1000 characters with unique personalities
  • 600+ martial arts types with no upper limit
  • Extensive equipment and item system
  • 200+ talent settings for diverse characters
  • Dozens of martial arts sects to join or conquer
  • Idle and sweep systems for easy progression
Features
Read full description

"天下风云出我辈,一入江湖岁月催。皇图霸业谈笑中,不胜人生一场醉。提剑跨骑挥鬼雨,白骨如山鸟惊飞。尘事如潮人如水,只叹江湖几人回"。 十四本天书重现江湖,掀起了新一轮的腥风血雨。主人公一不小心穿越到了这个风起云涌的武侠世界,身不由己地随着江湖的浪潮起起伏伏,经历了无数的艰难险阻和阴谋诡计之后,最终练成了绝世神功,找到了真爱,自由自在的在江湖上驰骋! 游戏的特点: 【剧情】丰富的原创剧情,繁多的分支情节,层出不穷的悬念,幽默的对白桥段,为你打造一个与其他游戏迥然不同的光怪陆离的武侠世界! 【人物】1000+个出场人物角色,每个人物都有鲜明的个性特色,故事感极强 【神功】600+个武功种类,囊括了武侠小说里几乎所有的神功秘籍,独特的武功设定,没有武学上限,你可以变得前所未有的强大 【装备】1000+种道具和装备,丰富而多变的装备设定,让每一件装备都有可能变成神兵利器 【天赋】200+的天赋设定,每个角色都有不用的武学个性,使得每个角色都显得真实而触手可及 【称号】100+的称号系统,让主人公不再在江湖中籍籍无名,与故事情节完美结合,不同的称号,在江湖的地位大不一样 【洗练】独特的洗练系统,随性所欲的定制符合自己要求的装备,让每一件装备都称心如意 【经络】独一无二的经络修炼系统,囊括了几百个穴位和奇经八脉,完全贴合武侠小说中的武功修炼之道,使得武功修炼更有挑战、更真实、更有趣 【锻造】每件装备都有巨大的成长空间,只要你去锻造和强化,一块凡铁也能成为闯荡江湖的最大依仗 【武学】平衡的武学设定,拳掌、刀、剑、奇门、内功等不同的武学修炼道路,在任何方面的修炼都可以成为绝世高手 【门派】几十个门派林立于江湖,可以虚心以求学,可以野心以吞并,可以残忍以灭门,怎么选,全看你 【招募】完成特定的任务就可以招募各种英雄于旗下,各路豪杰枭雄都唯你马首是瞻 【挂机】轻松的挂机系统,可以一边挂机一边刷副本,累了就把手机扔到一边,过几天再来收割经验 【扫荡】方便的扫荡系统,轻松获得巨量的升级经验,原来升级可以这么简单 【奖励】游戏中的奖励层出不穷,每日奖励都给你不一样的惊喜 【战斗】全自动战斗模式,解放双手,更轻松的养成角色和欣赏剧情 【副本】精彩而富有挑战的副本,大量的奖励,等你来拿 【音乐】当怀旧的音乐在你耳边响起时,宛如又穿越到了几十年前,荡气回肠,豪情万丈 独特的故事设定,包含了大量的武侠爱情情节(分支剧情,需要探索)与人生体悟,告别无聊鼓噪的打怪升级套路,每一次游戏都给您带来一种独特的体验,让您的的武侠世界充满了丝丝的柔情和人生的酸爽! 热烈欢迎各位玩家体验游戏,并提供宝贵的建议!

Screenshots

英雄坛说4 screens
金书群侠传4 screens

Verdict

The call

英雄坛说 and 金书群侠传 both sit at 4.8 stars, but that hides the real split: 84% of 英雄坛说's written reviews are positive against 68% of 金书群侠传's. 英雄坛说 also leads on update cadence (every 9 days vs every 3 weeks). 金书群侠传's advantage is ratings volume (179 vs 52). On price, rating, ads and in-app purchases there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. 英雄坛说 sells 7 one-off in-app purchases and 金书群侠传 sells 6 one-off in-app purchases. Whichever you choose, the download price is not the number that matters.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

On the App Store both sit at effectively the same score — 4.8 for 英雄坛说 against 4.7 for 金书群侠传. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 52 and 179 respectively. Written reviews are what separate them: 84% of 英雄坛说's written reviews are positive against 68% of 金书群侠传's.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

英雄坛说 ships an update every 9 days, 金书群侠传 every 3 weeks. The most recent releases landed on October 24, 2026 and October 26, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard3 real differences · 7 level
英雄坛说 versus 金书群侠传: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
Parameter英雄坛说金书群侠传
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.8 (52 ratings) — better4.7 (179 ratings)
Positive reviews83.6% of reviews — better68.2% of reviews
Number of ratings52179 — better
Update frequencyEvery 9 days — betterEvery 3 weeks
AdsYesYes
In-app purchasesYesYes
MonetizationFree with in-app purchasesFree with in-app purchases
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPodiPhone, iPad, iPod
Requires iOS13.012.4 — better
Further details — not scored
Size53 MB438 MB
Age rating4+17+
Developer培培 邢光平 王

Customer experience

英雄坛说

All ratings52 ratings
Positive96.2%
Neutral0.0%
Negative3.8%
Written reviews67 reviews
Positive83.6%
Neutral4.5%
Negative11.9%

金书群侠传

All ratings179 ratings
Positive94.4%
Neutral0.6%
Negative5.0%
Written reviews44 reviews
Positive68.2%
Neutral0.0%
Negative31.8%

Bugs and requests

英雄坛说

Reported bugs

6 issues
  • App crashes after selling items
  • Game crashes frequently, making it unplayable
  • Loss of all game data after switching phones/updating app
  • Items lost due to system crashes
  • Inconsistent game mechanics (e.g., basic skills reset)
Show 1 more
  • Game locks to 5-minute background time, requiring constant screen-on or payment

Requested features

9 requests
  • Add 'Xia Ke Xing' from Bubugao electronic dictionary
  • Implement 'Huang Liang Yi Meng' for custom game modes
  • More diverse邢捕头 (Xing Captou) missions
  • Increase variety of item drops and rewards
  • Allow easier game restarts
Show 4 more
  • Add more interesting segments and sects
  • Remove martial arts quantity limits
  • Clarify how to become a disciple of others
  • Improve mobile controls (e.g., directional buttons)

金书群侠传

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

In-app purchases

7 purchases

英雄坛说

One-time7
  • 一小袋宝石$0.99
  • 潜能双倍$0.99
  • 一小桶宝石$4.99
Show 4 more
  • 潜能10倍$14.99
  • 一小车宝石$19.99
  • 一大车宝石$49.99
  • 一卡车宝石$99.99
6 purchases

金书群侠传

One-time6
  • 几块元宝$0.99
  • 一小袋元宝$4.99
  • 一大袋元宝$9.99
Show 3 more
  • 一小箱元宝$19.99
  • 一大箱金元宝$49.99
  • 一缸金元宝$99.99

Questions

Is 英雄坛说 free?
英雄坛说 is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is 金书群侠传 free?
金书群侠传 is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Which has better reviews, 英雄坛说 or 金书群侠传?
英雄坛说 is rated higher. 英雄坛说 averages 4.8 out of 5 from 52 ratings, while 金书群侠传 averages 4.7 from 179 ratings.
Do 英雄坛说 or 金书群侠传 have ads?
Both 英雄坛说 and 金书群侠传 show ads.
Which is updated more often, 英雄坛说 or 金书群侠传?
英雄坛说 ships an update every 9 days, and 金书群侠传 every 3 weeks. Most recently, 英雄坛说 was updated on October 24, 2026 and 金书群侠传 on October 26, 2026.

Other comparisons