Comparison

Phantom Rose Scarlet vs Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both games, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Phantom Rose Scarlet

Embark on a roguelike card adventure where you build a deck and make strategic decisions. Collect over 100 cards and items by defeating enemies and rescuing others. Manage your card cooldowns for efficient combat and explore dangerous areas to defeat powerful foes.

Highlights
  • Roguelike card adventure
  • Deck building
  • Card collection
  • Strategic combat
  • Exploration
  • Permanent death
Features
Read full description

◆ A Roguelike Card Adventure Phantom Rose is an indie game by solo developer & artist makaroll. Build your card deck and make careful decisions while you explore as each death may be permanent. ◆ Defeat and Collect Collect over 100+ cards and powerful items by defeating phantoms & rescuing other maids in distress ◆ Manage Your Deck There's no luck-based card draw during battle. Instead, manage your card's cooldown to defeat your foe swiftly and efficiently. ◆ Explore Through Dangers Venture through areas of interest, danger, and place of safety to reach and defeat the crown phantoms for large rewards Languages: English 日本語 (Japanese) 한국어 (Korean) Official Twitter: https://twitter.com/phantomrosegame Official Discord: https://discord.gg/phantomrose

About

Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~

Collect a variety of witches through free gacha pulls in this idle game. Enjoy high-quality artwork and unique episodes without any in-app purchases or mandatory grinding.

Highlights
  • Free gacha pulls
  • Collect diverse witches
  • Idle game elements
  • High-quality artwork
  • Offline play
  • Multi-language support
Features
Read full description

"Witch Gacha" is a free game where you can collect witches through gacha pulls, and you can play without spending money until the end! All you have to do is continuously spin the gacha for free! Spin the 10-consecutive gacha without spending any money! There's a chance to get high rarity guaranteed when you pull the gacha a certain number of times! The illustrations of the witches range from bewitching beauties to cute little girls! Enjoy the quality artwork of girls reminiscent of classic RPGs, spin the gacha to kill time, and aim to complete all the witches! You can view the unique episodes and rarities of the acquired witches at any time! It's not just a regular gacha game; it also has idle game elements! Enjoy the excitement of pulling gacha continuously while leaving it idle! It eliminates the typical tedious elements found in many games, making it recommended for those who love task-oriented games! Furthermore, depending on the rarity, you can enjoy luxurious effects reminiscent of magic, making it addictive and making you want to spin it again and again! It's an interesting gacha-focused game that eliminates elements like character development, multiplayer, rankings, daily quests, and grinding for materials found in typical social games. Download "Witch Gacha" now and enjoy the latest and most popular gacha game for free! [Features of this game] Easy to play for both adults and children with simple controls, making it a gacha game app that anyone can enjoy! Completely free until the end! No in-app purchases or stamina, so you can spin the gacha whenever you like! Supports Japanese, English, Korean, simplified Chinese, and traditional Chinese, making it enjoyable for players worldwide! No online elements! A completely offline new game that you can enjoy!

Screenshots

Phantom Rose Scarlet4 screens
Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is rating: Phantom Rose Scarlet at 4.9 against Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~'s 4.0. Phantom Rose Scarlet also leads on ratings volume (2.5K vs 9) and review sentiment (86% vs 77%). Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~'s advantage is in-app purchases (none vs 17) and iOS requirement (13.0 vs 16.0). On price, update cadence, ads and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Phantom Rose Scarlet sells 17 one-off in-app purchases. Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ asks for nothing beyond the download.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Phantom Rose Scarlet holds the better App Store score, 4.9 against 4.0. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: Phantom Rose Scarlet has 2.5K ratings behind it against 9, so its average is the more settled of the two. Written reviews point the same way: 86% of Phantom Rose Scarlet's written reviews are positive against 77% of Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~'s.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

Both ship on a similar rhythm, roughly monthly. The most recent releases landed on October 29, 2026 and October 24, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard6 real differences · 4 level
Phantom Rose Scarlet versus Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterPhantom Rose ScarletWitch Gacha ~Witch Collection~
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.9 (2.5K ratings) — better4.0 (9 ratings)
Positive reviews85.7% of reviews — better76.9% of reviews
Number of ratings2.5K — better9
Update frequencyMonthlyMonthly
AdsYesYes
In-app purchasesYesNo — better
MonetizationFree with in-app purchasesAd-supported — better
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPad, iPod — better
Requires iOS16.013.0 — better
Further details — not scored
Size195 MB197 MB
Age rating12+4+
DeveloperStudio Maka LLCRieveldtGames

Customer experience

Phantom Rose Scarlet

All ratings2,544 ratings
Positive98.5%
Neutral0.8%
Negative0.7%
Written reviews161 reviews
Positive85.7%
Neutral6.2%
Negative8.1%

Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~

All ratings8 ratings
Positive75.0%
Neutral12.5%
Negative12.5%
Written reviews13 reviews
Positive76.9%
Neutral23.1%
Negative0.0%

Bugs and requests

Phantom Rose Scarlet

Reported bugs

3 issues
  • Crashes after watching ads
  • Inability to progress past certain levels
  • Unresponsive UI elements

Requested features

5 requests
  • More enemy/level variety
  • Expanded story/lore content
  • Difficulty settings/customization
  • Multiplayer/co-op mode
  • More free cosmetic options

Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

In-app purchases

17 purchases

Phantom Rose Scarlet

One-time17
  • XP Booster$0.99
  • 3 Inventory Space$1.99
  • Classic Reina$2.99
Show 14 more
  • Summer Reina$2.99
  • Bunny Reina$2.99
  • Supporters Package$4.99
  • Starlight Reina$4.99
  • Neon Reina$4.99
  • Witch Reina$4.99
  • Cat Reinya$4.99
  • Magical Reina$4.99
  • Nightwear Reina$4.99
  • Midnight Reina$4.99
  • Skin Package 2$6.99
  • Skin Package 3$6.99
  • Skin Package 4$6.99
  • Skin Package 1$7.99
None

Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Phantom Rose Scarlet free?
Phantom Rose Scarlet is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ free?
Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Which has better reviews, Phantom Rose Scarlet or Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~?
Phantom Rose Scarlet is rated higher. Phantom Rose Scarlet averages 4.9 out of 5 from 2.5K ratings, while Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ averages 4.0 from 9 ratings.
Do Phantom Rose Scarlet or Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ have ads?
Both Phantom Rose Scarlet and Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ show ads.
Which is updated more often, Phantom Rose Scarlet or Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~?
Phantom Rose Scarlet ships an update monthly, and Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ monthly. Most recently, Phantom Rose Scarlet was updated on October 29, 2026 and Witch Gacha ~Witch Collection~ on October 24, 2026.

Other comparisons