Comparison

玉山E vs SHIN理想記帳

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

玉山E

Access real-time market data for stocks, options, futures, and international markets. Execute trades with an intuitive interface and visualize key financial information. Manage your accounts and customize your trading experience.

Highlights
  • Real-time market quotes
  • Intuitive order placement
  • Visualized financial data
  • Account management
  • Customizable shortcuts
  • International market data
Read full description

玉山證券E-Trader提供完整的證券、複委託、權證、期貨及選擇權等豐富的市場行情,便利直覺的下單介面,視覺化的資訊,提供完整報價、快速下單! 功能服務: 報價功能-完整的證、期貨、選擇權、國際指數、港美股報價資訊。 盤後資訊-即時財經新聞、豐富大盤及個股盤後分析資訊。 下單功能-下單介面簡易直覺化,提供證、期權、港美股多元產品交易。 帳務功能-證、期權、複委託委託、庫存、對帳單資訊清楚明瞭。 客製化-自選群組、個人化快捷功能列快速自訂。 免責聲明: -本服務資訊來源 (包括但不限於)台灣證券交易所、台灣期貨交易所、櫃檯買賣中心。而本服務內容僅為提供資訊服務, 本服務對於所有經由本服務傳送之資訊之正確性與適用性均不負擔任何責任, 並不保證所有資訊之準確, 對於任何不準確或錯漏而引致之任何損失均不負任何賠償責任。 -本服務所提供之所有資訊及其相關任何功能目的為提供資訊,非供交易或投資之目的, 透過本服務獲得之資料僅作為參考 ,非供貴使用者之投資買賣建議,基於前開資料之任何交易或投資決定,貴使用者須自負風險及盈虧,本服務亦不負任何責任。 -本服務不保證本服務之無誤及不中斷。本服務倘若出現傳輸中斷或故障等現象, 造成貴使用者使用上的不便或無法使用、資料喪失、錯誤、遭人篡改或其他經濟上損失等情形, 本服務不負任何賠償責任。 (提醒您,為保護您的帳戶安全,建議您於行動裝置上安裝防護軟體,並更新至最新作業系統版本。)

About

SHIN理想記帳

This finance app helps users manage their money through a unique proportional budgeting method, allowing them to allocate income into living, investment, and savings accounts. It also categorizes spending as 'wants' or 'needs' to promote smarter financial decisions and provides detailed reports.

Highlights
  • Proportional budgeting method
  • Allocate income to living, investment, savings
  • Categorize spending as 'wants' or 'needs'
  • Consumption analysis reports
  • Cloud automatic data upload
  • Customizable category icons
  • Daily journaling reminders
Features
Read full description

李勛 SHIN LI/新生代理財投資YouTuber 在沒有富爸爸和任何財經科系背景下,透過自行學習投資理財幸運地在25歲存到了第一桶金!將自己花心思整理的各式小資理財資訊製作成影片,在Youtube成功吸引了超過30萬人訂閱、累積4000萬次觀看。 李勛本次與台灣財經資訊龍頭公司CMoney合作,將自己獨家的記帳方法和理財思維產品化,開發了這款「Shin理想記帳」。 ––––功能特色介紹–––– 獨家1>>比例記帳法 理想記帳中的比例記帳法,是利用比例分配的方式,將每個月的收入按比例分配至「生活、投資、儲蓄」三種帳戶,並可以時時檢視各帳戶狀態,且能夠在帳戶間彼此轉帳。 能夠幫助使用者量入為出,在消費支出前就先將每個月的現金流妥善規劃,確實將財富穩定累積下來。 獨家2>>【想要/需要】報表 更在日常記帳中規劃了【想要/需要】標籤,幫助使用者在記帳時能夠思考消費目的,並能透過報表定期檢視消費細節,真正做到聰明消費。 ◆消費分析 統整整月消費狀況,幫你一眼抓出財務漏洞。 ◆雲端自動上傳資料 換手機、換平台、換版本,安全還原完整資料。 ◆帳務報表 詳盡多彩的報表,即時掌握收支狀況 ◆自訂分類icons 自由調整分類icon,多款可愛icon任你選 ◆記帳提醒 自訂每日提醒時間,系統自動提醒,不用再擔心金魚腦袋 ------- 希望透過ShinLi個人實證有效的理財記帳方法, 與你交朋友,陪伴你存下每一分夢想的基礎。 利用簡單的記帳流程,幫助你養成理財的好習慣 規劃三大帳戶讓你可以清楚看見財富的累積 協助你思考並清楚規劃每筆現金流的意義 搭配 ShinLi 總是第一手更新的各家銀行 信用卡&帳戶 優惠資訊 真正做到『聰明消費,輕鬆理財,理想記帳。』

Screenshots

玉山E4 screens
SHIN理想記帳4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is rating: SHIN理想記帳 at 4.8 against 玉山E's 1.7. 玉山E's advantage is monetization model (free vs ad-supported). On price, ratings volume, update cadence and ads there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

SHIN理想記帳 holds the better App Store score, 4.8 against 1.7. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 6 and 5 respectively.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

玉山E ships an update monthly, SHIN理想記帳 every 3 weeks. The most recent releases landed on August 31, 2026 and August 25, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard2 real differences · 8 level
玉山E versus SHIN理想記帳: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
Parameter玉山ESHIN理想記帳
PriceFreeFree
Rating1.7 (6 ratings)4.8 (5 ratings) — better
Positive reviews8.3% of reviews—
Number of ratings6 — better5
Update frequencyMonthlyEvery 3 weeks — better
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationFree — betterAd-supported
DevicesiPhone, iPodiPhone, iPod
Requires iOS13.0 — better13.2
Further details — not scored
Size76 MB98 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperE.SUN SECURITIES CO.KINGWAY MEDIA CO., LTD.

Customer experience

玉山E

All ratings6 ratings
Positive16.7%
Neutral0.0%
Negative83.3%
Written reviews12 reviews
Positive8.3%
Neutral0.0%
Negative91.7%

SHIN理想記帳

All ratings5 ratings
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%

In-app purchases

None

玉山E

No in-app purchases

None

SHIN理想記帳

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is 玉山E free?
玉山E is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is SHIN理想記帳 free?
SHIN理想記帳 is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Which has better reviews, 玉山E or SHIN理想記帳?
SHIN理想記帳 is rated higher. 玉山E averages 1.7 out of 5 from 6 ratings, while SHIN理想記帳 averages 4.8 from 5 ratings.
Do 玉山E or SHIN理想記帳 have ads?
Neither 玉山E nor SHIN理想記帳 shows ads.
Which is updated more often, 玉山E or SHIN理想記帳?
玉山E ships an update monthly, and SHIN理想記帳 every 3 weeks. Most recently, 玉山E was updated on August 31, 2026 and SHIN理想記帳 on August 25, 2026.

Other comparisons