Comparison

iComic vs Collect Comics

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

iComic

Read high-resolution comic pages from zip or cbz archives on your device. Enjoy seamless navigation and zooming with multi-touch gestures. Download comics from the internet or personal servers for offline reading.

Highlights
  • High-resolution comic page display
  • Supports JPG, TIF, PNG in ZIP/CBZ
  • Multi-touch page navigation
  • Pinch-to-zoom functionality
  • Built-in download manager
  • Offline comic access
Features
Read full description

Welcome to iComic, the premier application for reading comics on your iPhone or iPod Touch. iComic makes great use of the multi-touch function for simple and effective page navigation and zooming to provide the best portable comic book read you will find. iComic displays high resolution comic pages (jpg, tif, or png image files) contained inside compressed zip or cbz format archives. Using the built-in download function, comics can be downloaded from the internet or from a personal server and stored locally on your iPhone or iPod Touch. Your downloaded comics are stored on your device and so are always available for reading, even when you have no internet connection. As iTunes resizes images to a compressed format, iComic is also useful for displaying images for other uses e.g. maps, high detailed photos and ebooks (convert your pdf books to jpeg and you have a perfect reader for those large pdf files, normally unreadable due to the high memory requirement). iComic currently provides three methods for turning pages: swiping your finger on the screen; by taps in the screen corners using the Corner-Tap method; or by Multi-Touch (tap once to page forward, twice to page back). Zooming is by the familiar pinch method used in Safari and other applications or by double tapping the screen when in Corner-Tap mode. The application is very stable and can easily handle zip files up to 60MB with infrequent problems observed with files of much larger size. Individual image files inside the zip files are constrained to a maximum 3 million pixels (e.g. 3,000 pixels high x 1,000 pixels wide or equivalent) though for the sake of battery conservation much smaller sizes (~1000 pixels high) are generally used. A manual for setting up and using iComic can be downloaded from http://red.halfmoon.jp/AppStore_iComic_V1.3_FAQ.pdf The author of this application is Japanese so for excellent community support and discussion in English please visit the helpful and friendly ~*~ Ultimate icomic Thread ~*~ at www.ipodtouchfans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23759

About

Collect Comics

Easily catalog and manage your comic book collection in one place. Organize issues, track favorite series, and tag comics by author or purchase location. A user-friendly interface for all comic enthusiasts.

Highlights
  • Catalog comic book collections
  • Track individual issues
  • Organize by series
  • Tag by author/artist
  • Record purchase location
  • User-friendly interface
Read full description

Introducing the ultimate app for comic book lovers - CollectComics Say goodbye to the clutter and disorganization of your comic book collection, and say hello to an app that makes it easy to keep track of all your favorite comics! With CollectComics, you can easily catalog and manage your comic book collection all in one place. Keep track of every issue of your favorite series, and never lose track of them again. CollectComics is your platform to immerse yourself in your comic book collection. Use the app to organize your entire collection, tag comics with your favorite authors and artists, and even where you purchase your comics. With a sleek and user-friendly interface, CollectComics is the perfect app for comic book enthusiasts of all levels. Start organizing your collection today and take your love of comics to the next level! Privacy Policy: https://www.collectcomics.app/privacy-policy Terms: https://www.collectcomics.app/terms-of-service

Screenshots

iComic1 screens
Collect Comics4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is price: Collect Comics at Free against iComic's $0.99. Collect Comics also leads on rating (5.0 vs 3.1) and review sentiment (100% vs 66%). iComic's advantage is in-app purchases (none vs 2) and ratings volume (7 vs 2). On ads, device support and iOS requirement there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Collect Comics is free to download; iComic costs $0.99 up front. Collect Comics sells 2 in-app purchases, starting at $0.99 per month. iComic asks for nothing beyond the download.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Collect Comics holds the better App Store score, 5.0 against 3.1. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 7 and 2 respectively. Written reviews point the same way: 66% of iComic's written reviews are positive against 100% of Collect Comics's.

Scorecard6 real differences · 4 level
iComic versus Collect Comics: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameteriComicCollect Comics
Price$0.99Free — better
Rating3.1 (7 ratings)5.0 (2 ratings) — better
Positive reviews66.2% of reviews100.0% of reviews — better
Number of ratings7 — better2
Update frequencyMonthly—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNo — betterYes
MonetizationPaidFree with in-app purchases — better
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPad, Mac — better
Requires iOS16.616.3 — better
Further details — not scored
Size3 MB14 MB
Age rating17+4+
DeveloperY.YamamotoUncanny Apps

Customer experience

iComic

All ratings7 ratings
Positive57.1%
Neutral0.0%
Negative42.9%
Written reviews207 reviews
Positive66.2%
Neutral12.6%
Negative21.3%

Collect Comics

All ratings2 ratings
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%
Written reviews1 reviews
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%

Bugs and requests

iComic

Reported bugs

17 issues
  • App crashes when opening large comic files
  • Rotation mode becomes stuck after using 'fix right' option
  • Status bar doesn't disappear despite settings
  • Bookmark settings not saved in iOS 4.x
  • FTP upload fails with permission errors
Show 12 more
  • File numbering displays out of order (01 after 1)
  • Nested folder structures not readable
  • Landscape mode rendering issues with black space
  • Memory leaks causing frequent warnings
  • CBR files with newer RAR compression show blank pages
  • Swipe navigation not working properly
  • App crashes after finishing a comic
  • Cannot save rotation preferences
  • Crashes on iOS 5+ with certain devices
  • FTP connection issues on Windows 7
  • Blank 'read error' pages in some CBR files
  • App installs multiple times causing file confusion

Requested features

18 requests
  • CBR/RAR format support (added in later versions)
  • iTunes file transfer integration
  • Lock rotation option for reading
  • Auto-rotate to landscape for 2-page spreads
  • Improved file management and deletion from app
Show 13 more
  • Better bookmark functionality with persistent storage
  • Thumbnail previews of comics
  • Directory/folder organization system
  • Password protection for app
  • Batch file import capability
  • Page slider for quick navigation
  • Support for PDF files
  • Retina-friendly app icon
  • Improved file sorting (alphanumeric)
  • In-app FTP file pulling from servers
  • Gesture controls for chapter navigation
  • Reset read status for re-reading
  • Automatic chapter continuation

Collect Comics

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

In-app purchases

None

iComic

No in-app purchases

2 purchases

Collect Comics

Subscriptions2
  • Collection+ Monthly$0.991 Month
  • Collection+ Yearly$9.991 Year

Questions

Is iComic free?
iComic costs $0.99, with no in-app purchases.
Is Collect Comics free?
Collect Comics is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Which has better reviews, iComic or Collect Comics?
Collect Comics is rated higher. iComic averages 3.1 out of 5 from 7 ratings, while Collect Comics averages 5.0 from 2 ratings.
Do iComic or Collect Comics have ads?
Neither iComic nor Collect Comics shows ads.

Other comparisons