Comparison

QQ阅读 vs 古本红楼梦

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

QQ阅读

Access a vast library of original novels, popular webcomics, and audiobooks. Discover trending titles, receive personalized recommendations, and enjoy a rich reading experience with features like detailed typesetting and exclusive fan content.

Highlights
  • Massive library of original novels
  • Popular webcomics
  • Audiobook listening
  • Personalized recommendations
  • Book rankings and charts
  • Detailed typesetting
  • Fan-created content
Features
Currently charting
Read full description

400万大神坐镇QQ阅读,为您书写全新世界;1000万册海量原著好书,尽在QQ阅读。 【热门内容】 《飞刀:我在小城当医生》:肖战主演电视剧《小城良方》原著小说,小城医生的逆袭及他的生活哲学。 《中国神探:共和国刑警崔道植》:真实记录痕检泰斗崔道植的刑侦一生,详解白宝山案、白银案等惊天要案的传奇历程。 《大王饶命》:高中生吕树在一场车祸中改变人生,当灵气复苏时代来袭,他要做这时代的领跑者。 物竞天择,胜者为王。 这是一个吕树依靠毒鸡汤成为大魔王的故事。 《我不是大师》原著。算命这个行当,萌芽于先秦,发展于隋唐,泛滥于明清;张良、诸葛亮、刘伯温,不同时期的代表人物,都在手相、面相、八字中辨认着人类的命运。 《比山更高的地方》:张馨予、巩峥主演《爱在山海间》原著,援藏医疗队与扶贫干部共谱高原传奇。 《斗罗:融合洪荒,勾魂唐三入地狱》:斗罗星意志觉醒,决定回归洪荒大陆的怀抱。防止斗罗大陆生物不适应,展开天幕并随机挑选魂师提前进入洪荒世界,于是远超斗罗生命想象的世界缓缓展开。 《我就正常上学,怎么成高武禁忌了》:江寻穿越高武世界,靠写小说同步具现荒天帝实力。在他眼里,自己就是个平平无奇的普通大学生。却不知自己早已被武道界列为不能招惹的禁忌存在! 《小人类软又横!八大兽族排队饲养》:纪筝穿越了,穿到了兽人作为星际霸主,将人类当宠物饲养的时代。好消息,她成为联邦军区第一元帅的宠物,从此吃喝不愁。坏消息,第一元帅不喜欢她,并时刻打算将她退货。 《魏庭枝》:崔含枝自幼跟随父亲读的是圣贤书,学的是与天争命。夫君一朝亡故她做了寡妇,带着儿子在周府就差被人拆干抹净,周旋三年后她毅然离府。娘家势弱,那她便寻一个更强势的!听闻北安侯年过三旬,膝下无子?没关系,生儿子,是她最不起眼的本事了。 【产品特性】 -海量精品书:海量优质内容每日更新,总有一款适合你; -福利大放送:阅读时长兑换、等级礼包、漫画礼包、听书礼包、会员礼包,一站领取; -个性化推荐:每日推荐好书,QQ阅读更懂您的口味; -图书排行榜:十年经典、完结好书,排行榜告诉您当下最火书籍; -书籍精排版:图文并茂的电子书,不一样的阅读体验; -来听有声书:看累了?听书帮您解放双眼,用耳朵聆听世界; -漫画随意看:你看书我买单,漫画壕礼送不停; -同人聚集地:斗罗、斗破等热门IP,衍生作品看不停! 【自动续费】 注意事项: 1、服务名称:QQ阅读会员自动续费。 2、本服务是在您已开通QQ阅读会员服务的前提下,为您提供的自动续费服务。如您开通QQ阅读会员服务,则视为您授权QQ阅读有权在您的QQ阅读会员服务即将到期时,从您的自有充值账户、与会员账号绑定的iTunes账户(以下统称“账户”)余额中代扣下一个计费周期会员费。该服务实现的前提是您已将QQ阅读会员账号与上述账户绑定,且可成功从上述账户中扣款,因上述账户中可扣款余额不足导致的续费失败,由您自行承担。 QQ阅读会员服务有四种订购方式可供选择: 第一种:18元/1个月,每1个月自动续订。 第二种:25元/1个月。 第三种:198元/12个月。 第四种:60元/3个月。 3、购买1个月且自动续费的QQ阅读会员服务的账号,会在到期前24小时,自动续订并扣除相应费用。 4、如需取消自动续订,请至少提前24小时操作取消。您可通过下述方式中止或终止本服务: 苹果应用内支付(IAP支付,in-app purchase)自动续费用户退订方法如下: 打开苹果手机“设置” --> 进入“iTunes Store 与 App Store”-->点击 “Apple ID”,选择"查看Apple ID",进入"账户设置"页面,点击“订阅”,选择QQ阅读包月服务取消订阅即可。 同一个appleid只能给一个QQ号码开通自动续费服务。 更多详细内容可查阅: 《QQ阅读软件许可及服务协议》: https://yuedu.reader.qq.com/h5/about/lawAgreement?agreementId=28 《QQ阅读用户个人信息保护及隐私政策协议》: https://ih5.reader.qq.com/h5/about/lawAgreement?agreementId=131 《QQ阅读付费服务及充值规则协议》: https://yuedu.reader.qq.com/h5/about/lawAgreement?agreementId=29 【特别声明】 -在《QQ阅读》中,用户使用平台账号(QQ号)登录,能够同步本应用中部分数据。用户在该应用中购买的代币“阅币”仅限于在此应用中使用。腾讯平台上的虚拟货币, 比如Q币、Q点等都无法在本应用内使用。 -本软件的内容和QQ书城或任何其他QQ电子书支付的服务无关。在软件中,用户无法使用以前在QQ书城或在其他QQ电子书服务使用QQ币购买的任何内容。 -本软件的微信账户与QQ账户信息互不相通。 【联系我们】 -在线客服:QQ阅读->我的->帮助中心->联系客服

About

古本红楼梦

Explore classic Chinese literature with this app, offering a comparative reading experience of ancient and modern versions of a renowned novel. Discover the nuances and historical context of different editions, perfect for dedicated enthusiasts and researchers.

Highlights
  • Comparative reading of ancient and modern editions
  • Focus on classic Chinese literature
  • Detailed historical context
  • High-quality compilation of annotated ancient texts
  • Analysis of textual differences
Features
Read full description

中国古典第一奇书高质量汇编脂批古本 【红楼梦】 本应用为红楼梦爱好者特别订制,方便古本脂批红楼梦(78回)以及曹雪芹,高鹗通行本(120回)的比较阅读。本人作为红学爱好者在红楼梦研读过程中,发现通过比较古本和通行本的一些明显的区别非常有趣,越是深入的去研读就越能体会古本红楼梦(78回)的神奇,相比之下,通行本就好比“山寨版”,相形见绌。 *“刘心武:红楼梦古本和通行本的故事”* 《红楼梦》究竟是谁写的?经过红学一百多年的发展,现在大多数人形成了共识:是曹雪芹写的。那么,曹雪芹留下他的亲笔手稿了吗?很遗憾,直到现在,我们也没能找到他遗留下的亲笔手稿。曹雪芹去世前,他的书稿没有公开出版过。只是以手抄的形式,在小范围内流传。早期抄书的人,应该是出于对书稿的喜爱。曹雪芹去世以后,开始有出于商业目的而传抄的人士了。到了曹雪芹已经去世差不多二十八年左右的时候,出现了一种活字印刷的版本,印书的老板叫程伟元。他把所得到的《红楼梦》手抄本变成了活字摆印本(那时候一般不说“排印”而说“摆印”,因为书坊工人需要照原稿选出字模来一个字一个字地摆放),使得曹雪芹的这部书能够更广泛地流传。 所谓古本《红楼梦》,分界线就是程伟元活字摆印本的出现,那以前以手抄形式出现的,都可以算是古本《红楼梦》。程伟元通过活字摆印,大量印刷、廉价发行的《红楼梦》,就是“通行本”的发端。当然,因为那也已经是二百多年前的一个版本了,并且处在一个分界点上,所以,讨论《红楼梦》版本问题时,有时也把程伟元的印本,特别是他第一次印刷的那个版本(红学界称做“程甲本”),也算到“古本”的范畴,而那以后,特别是道光、咸丰年间开始盛行的《金玉缘》本,就都不能算古本了...

Screenshots

QQ阅读4 screens
古本红楼梦3 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is ads: 古本红楼梦 at none against QQ阅读's shown. 古本红楼梦 also leads on monetization model (free vs free with in-app purchases) and review sentiment (60% vs 52%). QQ阅读's advantage is update cadence (weekly vs every 7 months) and ratings volume (1.5K vs 6). On price, rating, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. QQ阅读 sells 10 in-app purchases, starting at $2.99 per month and 古本红楼梦 sells 1 one-off in-app purchase. Whichever you choose, the download price is not the number that matters.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

On the App Store both sit at effectively the same score — 4.4 for QQ阅读 against 4.5 for 古本红楼梦. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: QQ阅读 has 1.5K ratings behind it against 6, so its average is the more settled of the two. Written reviews are what separate them: 52% of QQ阅读's written reviews are positive against 60% of 古本红楼梦's.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

QQ阅读 ships an update weekly, 古本红楼梦 every 7 months. The most recent releases landed on November 10, 2026 and November 2, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard7 real differences · 4 level
QQ阅读 versus 古本红楼梦: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterQQ阅读古本红楼梦
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.4 (1.5K ratings)4.5 (6 ratings) — better
Positive reviews51.7% of reviews60.0% of reviews — better
Number of ratings1.5K — better6
Update frequencyWeekly — betterEvery 7 months
AdsYesNo — better
In-app purchasesYesYes
MonetizationFree with in-app purchasesFree — better
Best chart rank#122 — better—
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPod, Apple Watch — betteriPhone, iPad, iPod
Requires iOS13.08.0 — better
Further details — not scored
Size309 MB67 MB
Age rating17+17+
DeveloperTencent Mobile Games世木 林

Customer experience

QQ阅读

All ratings1,452 ratings
Positive84.1%
Neutral4.0%
Negative11.9%
Written reviews333 reviews
Positive51.7%
Neutral5.7%
Negative42.6%

古本红楼梦

All ratings5 ratings
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%
Written reviews5 reviews
Positive60.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative40.0%

Bugs and requests

QQ阅读

Reported bugs

4 issues
  • Disappearing local books and reading progress
  • Unreliable server connectivity
  • Forced updates causing data loss
  • Inconsistent UI behavior across versions

Requested features

4 requests
  • Add dark mode option
  • Improve backup and restore functionality
  • Provide better cross-device syncing
  • Enhance reading customization options

古本红楼梦

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

In-app purchases

10 purchases

QQ阅读

Subscriptions4
  • 连续包月会员$2.991 Month
  • QQ阅读连续包月会员$2.991 Month
  • QQ阅读连续包月1 Month trial$2.991 Month
Show 1 more
  • QQ阅读连续包月会员1 Month trial$2.991 Month
One-time6
  • 600阅币$0.99
  • 1200阅币$1.99
  • 1800阅币$2.99
Show 3 more
  • 3000阅币$4.99
  • 5000阅币$8.29
  • 9800阅币$16.49
1 purchases

古本红楼梦

One-time1
  • 去除广告$2.99

Questions

Is QQ阅读 free?
QQ阅读 is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is 古本红楼梦 free?
古本红楼梦 is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Which has better reviews, QQ阅读 or 古本红楼梦?
古本红楼梦 is rated higher. QQ阅读 averages 4.4 out of 5 from 1.5K ratings, while 古本红楼梦 averages 4.5 from 6 ratings.
Do QQ阅读 or 古本红楼梦 have ads?
QQ阅读 shows ads; 古本红楼梦 does not.
Which is updated more often, QQ阅读 or 古本红楼梦?
QQ阅读 ships an update weekly, and 古本红楼梦 every 7 months. Most recently, QQ阅读 was updated on November 10, 2026 and 古本红楼梦 on November 2, 2026.

Other comparisons