Comparison

Steiner Tree vs Graph3D

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side โ€” with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Steiner Tree

Features
Read full description

This app computes Steiner trees using an evolutionary algorithm. You can place, drag, and delete points of your tree. The optimal number and position of Steiner points is computed. A minimal spanning tree (MST) connects a given set of points in a plane so that the sum of all edges is minimal. Often this sum of all edges can be reduced, if additional points are added. These points are called Steiner points, and the corresponding minimal spanning tree Steiner tree. If more than 3 points are given, it is a hard optimization problem to compute the optimal number and position of Steiner points. This app uses a simple evolutionary algorithm for demonstration purposes. It uses a population of individuals. Each individual represents a MST containing some Steiner points. The population develops towards the optimal Steiner tree in an evolutionary loop: Initially, each individual sets random Steiner points, and constructs the corresponding Steiner tree. The minimal length of the Steiner tree in the population is stored. Each individual has now a fitness value, which is the higher, the closer its Steiner tree length is to the minimal length in the population. Fitter individuals have more descendants by reproduction, and less fit individuals die out. In order to explore better solutions, reproduction does not create descendants that are identical to the parent individual, i.e. do not have their Steiner points at the same position. Rather these positions are shifted randomly by mutation, using a Gaussian distribution. How far they are shifted on average is determined also by their fitness: Good individuals shift their Steiner points less than worse individuals. How fast a good solution is found, depends thus on the population size, and the mutation strength.

About

Graph3D

Features
Read full description

Visualize graphs in 3D. Rotate, zoom and select vertices. Import graph matrix, vertex/edge file duo and newick trees. Run spring algorithm to reposition graph.

Screenshots

Steiner Tree1 screens
Graph3D1 screens

Verdict

The call

Steiner Tree and Graph3D are too close to call on the numbers: across 5 compared parameters โ€” price, ads, in-app purchases and device support among them โ€” neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price ยท Rating ยท Positive reviews ยท Number of ratings ยท Update frequency ยท Ads ยท In-app purchases ยท Monetization ยท Best chart rank ยท Devices ยท Requires iOS

CostPrice ยท In-app purchases ยท Ads ยท Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
Steiner Tree versus Graph3D: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterSteiner TreeGraph3D
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyEvery 45 monthsโ€”
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPodiPhone, iPad, iPod
Requires iOS12.012.0
Further details โ€” not scored
Size1 MB32 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperReinhard MAENNERSigmar Stefansson

In-app purchases

None

Steiner Tree

No in-app purchases

None

Graph3D

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Steiner Tree free?
Steiner Tree is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Graph3D free?
Graph3D is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Steiner Tree or Graph3D have ads?
Neither Steiner Tree nor Graph3D shows ads.

Other comparisons