Comparison

Bat Detector vs Chirps Recorder

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Bat Detector

Listen to and record the ultrasonic sounds of bats using your iPhone or iPad. This app reveals bat acoustics through heterodyne detection and 16x time expansion, making their calls audible and musical. It also offers full-spectrum recordings triggered by bat sounds.

Highlights
  • Heterodyne bat detection without manual tuning
  • 16x time expansion for audible bat sounds
  • Full-spectrum recordings triggered by bat sounds
  • Real-time sound demodulation
  • Preserves harmonic relationships in bat calls
  • Supports European and global microbats
Read full description

Simply connect an inexpensive ultrasonic USB microphone to your iPhone or iPad and open your ears up to the extraordinary world of bat acoustics.  Build a dedicated USB microphone for under £10 : https://shorturl.at/e2A3U - : or buy one pre-assembled and tested for about £65 that also operates as a standalone bat detector https://www.apodemus.eu/nl/Apodemus-Pipistrelle-Mini/00126 All European bats and most of the world's "microbats" navigate, hunt and communicate using ultrasonic sounds, too high-pitched for human hearing. Bat Detector reveals those sounds to human ears, and has two different methods to make ultrasonic bat sounds audible.  HETERODYNE BAT DETECTION WITHOUT MANUAL TUNING Firstly, Bat Detector supports the classic technique of heterodyne bat detection. Heterodyning is a simple process that operates in true real-time, demodulating the bat sounds with a carrier signal just like an old transistor radio. Most heterodyne bat detectors require you to manually tune into different species, but Bat Detector operates without any manual tuning, instead it tunes into the strongest bat signal it can hear. The heterodyne process then turns any bats sounds it hears into percussive cracks, pops and slaps, or in the specific case of leaf-nosed bats such as Horseshoe species, strange alien warbles. These are often thought of as "bat sounds" - they are not. They are sounds synthesised by bat detectors using bat sounds as a source - rhe harmonic content of heterodyned sounds is distorted and mangled, and these sounds bear literally no relationship to the sounds the bats actually made. However, operating in true real-time means that the rhythm of the bats calls is preserved, and heterodyned bat sounds - despite sounding nothing like bats - are diagnostic and distinctive, so heterodyning remains an invaluable tool for all bat workers and enthusiasts. EXPERIENCE TRUE BAT SOUNDS FOR THE FIRST TIME WITH 16x TIME EXPANSION Time Expansion was previously a very high-end, expensive option. Time Expansion in Bat Detector operates in quasi real-time, capturing small snippets of bat sound and playing them back at 1/16 speed. 16 is a number chosen for two good reasons. Firstly it brings the bat sounds down to an easy range for human hearing, the sounds generated by Bat Detector range from between 1kHz to just under 7kHz. 16x Time Expansion preserves the harmonic relationships between the bat sounds, so it is a MUSICAL transformation. The bat sounds are not only slowed down but are transposed down by exactly 4 octaves. This means if a bat calls a C#, you will hear a C#, but 4 octaves lower. You will be surprised how beautiful and musical bat sounds are when time-expanded. When used in conjunction with heterodyning, and with the accurate frequency read out on the display, bat species identification is made much easier and more reliable. FULL-SPECTRUM 384kHz RECORDINGS TRIGGERED BY BAT SOUNDS When "RECORD" is engaged Bat Detector will trigger a 5 second full-spectrum recording at 384kHz whenever it hears a bat, or at least something that it *thinks* sounds like a bat. These are not the recordings of the sounds you hear coming from the detector, but are the sounds going INTO the detector - the true ultrasonic sounds that the bats made, too high for humans to hear. You will need specialist software to examine these files after you export them from your device to a computer. DEMO MODE FOR EDUCATION AND TRAINING If you want to experience bat sounds during the daytime, in a classroom environment, or when there aren't any bats around, just turn on Demo Mode in the Bat Detector section of the settings App, and Bat Detector will loop through a collection of bat recordings from Wiltshire, England. Alternatively, if you have recordings of your own that you wish to use, create a folder called Demo in Files->Bat Detector and Bat Detector will use these in Demo mode rather than its built-in recordings.

About

Chirps Recorder

Read full description

Chirps is a bioacoustics field companion for iPhone and iPad. It helps researchers, species surveyors, recordists, students, and naturalists visualise, monitor, record, and review sound in the field without needing a laptop. Use Chirps for live spectrogram and waveform visualisation, external USB microphones and audio interfaces, passthrough and heterodyne monitoring, uncompressed WAV recording, and high-quality spectrogram export for reports. Key features: - Real-time GPU-accelerated spectrogram and waveform display - Support for built-in microphones, USB microphones, and audio interfaces supported by iOS - Automatic audio route discovery and device capability reporting - WAV recording with adjustable ring buffer, pre-trigger, and post-trigger capture durations - Live passthrough monitoring - Heterodyne monitoring with tunable centre frequency - Data review interface for recorded files - Session notes that can be edited from within the app - High-detail spectrogram review with adjustable window width - Two-finger scrolling for waveform and spectrogram inspection in review mode - PNG spectrogram export with scientific axes, grid lines, colour legend. - File sharing through the iOS share sheet - Local diagnostic log for troubleshooting hardware and audio route issues Chirps is designed for field use. Recordings are saved as WAV files in the app’s local storage and can be accessed through the Files app. If iCloud Drive is enabled, iOS can sync those files to your other Apple devices using Apple’s standard system services. This Version: Initial App Store release of Chirps for iPhone and iPad. Includes live spectrogram and waveform visualisation, WAV recording, passthrough and heterodyne monitoring, external audio device support, data review, session notes, spectrogram export, and on-device diagnostics.

Screenshots

Bat Detector4 screens
Chirps Recorder4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is iOS requirement: Bat Detector at 15 against Chirps Recorder's 17.0. On price, ads, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

Scorecard1 real difference · 9 level
Bat Detector versus Chirps Recorder: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterBat DetectorChirps Recorder
PriceFreeFree
Rating5.0 (4 ratings) — better—
Positive reviews40.0% of reviews—
Number of ratings4 — better—
Update frequencyMonthly—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationFree—
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPod — betteriPhone, iPad
Requires iOS15 — better17.0
Further details — not scored
Size136 MB5 MB
Age rating9+4+
DeveloperPhil AtkinRavi Umadi

In-app purchases

None

Bat Detector

No in-app purchases

None

Chirps Recorder

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Bat Detector free?
Bat Detector is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Chirps Recorder free?
Chirps Recorder is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Bat Detector or Chirps Recorder have ads?
Neither Bat Detector nor Chirps Recorder shows ads.

Other comparisons