Comparison

Who's on Second vs Dugout Toolkit

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Who's on Second

This app helps coaches create fair baseball and softball lineups. It automatically generates batting orders, tracks pitch counts, and manages player playing time across the season. Print clean lineup cards and ensure all players get adequate opportunities.

Highlights
  • Drag-and-drop lineup builder
  • Auto-generate fair lineups
  • Track pitch counts
  • Manage playing time
  • Printable lineup cards
  • Configurable league rules
  • Season batting order rotation
Features
Read full description

The baseball and softball lineup maker built for Little League, rec, and travel ball coaches. Drag players onto the diamond, auto-generate a fair lineup in one tap, and track pitch counts and playing time all season. Print a clean lineup card, keep the batting order rotating fairly, and know who can pitch before you fill out the card. Everything works on your phone from the dugout. LINEUP BUILDER Build lineups with drag-and-drop on a visual baseball diamond. Assign players to positions inning by inning, set your batting order, and mark absent players. Click a position to quick-assign, or let auto-generate build a compliant lineup in one tap. Everything updates in real time: batting order, position summary, and rule compliance. AUTO-GENERATE One tap builds a full lineup that respects your league's rules, your batting order, and your fairness history. Handles minimum play requirements, position limits, pitcher eligibility, and more. You can always adjust the result by hand. PITCH COUNT TRACKING Log pitch counts after each game. Rest day calculations happen automatically based on your league's thresholds. Ineligible pitchers are flagged before you build your next lineup, so you never have to wonder who's available. Tracks pitches thrown on other teams too, because rest days don't reset when a player plays travel ball on Tuesday. CONFIGURABLE RULES ENGINE Every league is different. Set your own rules for minimum play, consecutive bench innings, infield requirements, pitcher limits, designated hitter, and more. Rules show real-time warnings in the lineup builder. They're guardrails, not hard blocks: you always have the final call. FAIRNESS SUMMARY See who played where and how much across the entire season. Per-player innings played, innings sat, position distribution, and pitching totals. When a parent asks about playing time, you've got the answer. SET LINEUP (SEASON BATTING ORDER) Set your batting order once. After each game, mark who batted last. The rotation handles itself for the next game, so every player moves through the order fairly over the course of the season. PRINTABLE LINEUP CARD Print a clean lineup card that fits one page. Absent players listed separately. Bring it to the dugout or hand it to the umpire. TEAM ROLES Invite assistant coaches, scorekeepers, and parents. Each role sees only what they need. Parents get read-only access to their player's position history and pitch count status. Coaches and scorekeepers can enter pitch counts and manage lineups based on their role. WORKS AT EVERY LEVEL Little League, rec, travel ball, high school, adult leagues. The rules engine is fully configurable, so it adapts to your league instead of the other way around. BUILT FOR THE DUGOUT Responsive design that works on phones, tablets, and laptops. Build your lineup on Saturday morning from the bleachers, adjust it in the parking lot when someone no-shows, and pull it up on your phone between innings. Terms of Use: https://whosonsecond.com/terms Privacy Policy: https://whosonsecond.com/privacy

About

Dugout Toolkit

This app provides offline tools for rec softball and baseball coaches to manage lineups, defensive positions, player substitutions, and team finances. It offers a simple, game-ready command center without requiring logins or internet access.

Highlights
  • Lineup builder
  • Defensive position mapping
  • Substitution tracking
  • Game notes
  • Dues tracker
  • Jersey manager
Read full description

Dugout Toolkit is the offline-first command center built for rec softball and baseball coaches who need fast, simple, game-ready tools without logins, accounts, or internet. Whether you are managing a tournament, running a weekly league game, or organizing a team of kids, Dugout Toolkit gives you everything you need right at field level. Core Features Lineup Builder Create clean, game-ready lineups in seconds. Drag, reorder, and lock players into batting positions with zero friction. Position Map Assign defensive positions inning by inning. Keep your field organized and avoid confusion in the dugout. Sub Tracker Track who is in, who is out, and who is up next. Perfect for rec-league rotation rules and equal-play requirements. Game Notes Quick notes for coaches including late arrivals, injuries, restrictions, reminders, and inning-by-inning adjustments. Dues Tracker Keep team payments organized without spreadsheets or group chats. Jersey Manager Track jersey numbers, sizes, and assignments for your entire roster. Offline-First. Zero Login. Zero Setup. Dugout Toolkit works completely offline, even in fields with no service. No accounts. No passwords. No cloud dependency. Just open the app and coach. Built for Rec Coaches Designed for adult softball teams, youth baseball and softball, tournament coaches, team managers, scorekeepers, and anyone running a dugout. Fast, simple, and reliable. Why Coaches Love It No ads. No subscriptions required. No clutter. No internet needed. Works instantly. Designed by real rec-league coaches. Optional Upgrade Unlock all premium tools with a one-time purchase. No subscriptions and no recurring fees. Your Dugout. Your Command. Take control of your lineup, your field, and your team from one clean, powerful toolkit.

Screenshots

Who's on Second4 screens
Dugout Toolkit4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is ratings volume: Who's on Second at 22 against Dugout Toolkit's 1. Dugout Toolkit's advantage is iOS requirement (16.4 vs 18.0). On price, rating, update cadence and ads there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Who's on Second sells 4 in-app purchases, starting at $7.99 per month and Dugout Toolkit sells 1 one-off in-app purchase. Whichever you choose, the download price is not the number that matters.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Dugout Toolkit holds the better App Store score, 5.0 against 4.8. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: Who's on Second has 22 ratings behind it against 1, so its average is the more settled of the two.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

Who's on Second ships an update every 9 days, Dugout Toolkit fortnightly. The most recent releases landed on November 17, 2026 and November 15, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard2 real differences · 8 level
Who's on Second versus Dugout Toolkit: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterWho's on SecondDugout Toolkit
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.8 (22 ratings)5.0 (1 ratings) — better
Positive reviews90.9% of reviews—
Number of ratings22 — better1
Update frequencyEvery 9 days — betterFortnightly
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesYesYes
MonetizationFree with in-app purchasesFree with in-app purchases
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPad
Requires iOS18.016.4 — better
Further details — not scored
Size33 MB59 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperWho's on SecondVibeCMD

Customer experience

Who's on Second

All ratings22 ratings
Positive95.5%
Neutral0.0%
Negative4.5%
Written reviews11 reviews
Positive90.9%
Neutral0.0%
Negative9.1%

Dugout Toolkit

All ratings1 ratings
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%

In-app purchases

4 purchases

Who's on Second

Subscriptions4
  • Coach - Monthly$7.991 Month
  • 2-Team Coach$13.991 Month
  • 3-Team Coach$19.991 Month
Show 1 more
  • Coach - Season$39.996 Months
1 purchases

Dugout Toolkit

One-time1
  • Dugout Toolkit Pro – Lifetime$9.99

Questions

Is Who's on Second free?
Who's on Second is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is Dugout Toolkit free?
Dugout Toolkit is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Which has better reviews, Who's on Second or Dugout Toolkit?
Dugout Toolkit is rated higher. Who's on Second averages 4.8 out of 5 from 22 ratings, while Dugout Toolkit averages 5.0 from 1 ratings.
Do Who's on Second or Dugout Toolkit have ads?
Neither Who's on Second nor Dugout Toolkit shows ads.
Which is updated more often, Who's on Second or Dugout Toolkit?
Who's on Second ships an update every 9 days, and Dugout Toolkit fortnightly. Most recently, Who's on Second was updated on November 17, 2026 and Dugout Toolkit on November 15, 2026.

Other comparisons