Comparison

Traders Guild vs Neumann AI

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Traders Guild

Features
Read full description

Trade Together, Prove the Edge Every mark on the chart is a person. Most trading "communities" are just feeds with tickers. The chart and the conversation live in different places, calls have no timestamps, and reputation is claimed, not earned. Traders Guild is built around a different idea: the chart IS the conversation. Join a guild and every call it makes sits on one shared, live chart: a marker with the face of the trader who made it, pinned to the candle it was made on. FIND YOUR GUILD Guilds are small communities of active traders, each with its own chart, chat and public leaderboard. Reputation and accuracy are earned one tracked call at a time. POST YOUR CALL IN SECONDS Put an analysis, a question, a poll or an alert on the chart. Add indicators, drawings, levels or other timeframes when you want to show your working. LET THE CHART KEEP SCORE Plan a trade with a Setup: long or short, with entry, target and stop. Track it and the result is recorded automatically when it hits target or stop. Once a tracked Setup is live, its levels are locked. No "I called it" weeks later. SUPPORT IT. CHALLENGE IT. Reply to any marker with one of your own: support it, challenge it or build on it. Lines on the chart connect the debate, and Theses show every debate at a glance and how the guild is split. THE CHAT LIVES ON THE CHART Talk it through live in guild and symbol chat rooms, right under the chart, or message members directly. WHAT'S INCLUDED • Live crypto charts, real-time from Binance • Markers with your face: analysis, questions, polls, alerts and Setups • Tracked Setups with automatic entry, target, stop and result • Replies that support, challenge or build on a call, gathered into Theses • Guilds with public leaderboards, reputation and accuracy • Guild and symbol chat rooms, plus direct messages • Voice dictation and image sharing in chat • Push notifications for replies, results and guild activity • Face ID app lock • Links to share charts, markers and guilds • A built-in "How markers work" guide COMING NEXT Forex, stocks and indices. Built native for iPhone. Traders Guild. For traders who put it on the chart.

About

Neumann AI

Features
Read full description

Neumann AI scans 15 forex pairs and indices for trade setups, scores them by technical confluence, and sends you a push notification when one passes your filters. Every setup is scored across eight factors: trend structure, EMA 50/200 alignment, RSI zone, key support and resistance levels, candlestick patterns, session timing, volume confirmation, and higher timeframe alignment. Only setups scoring above your chosen threshold (default 70%) are shown. Anything below 2:1 risk-to-reward is dropped silently. The scanner runs every 60 seconds. You pick your pairs, set your probability threshold, and the engine does the rest. PROP FIRM RULES BUILT IN If you're trading a funded account, Neumann knows your firm's limits. Daily loss caps, maximum drawdown thresholds, and news-trading restrictions are enforced before any signal reaches you. Supported firms include FTMO, Alpha Capital Group, The 5%ers, Funded Next, and MyFundedFX. NEWS FILTERING High-impact economic events (NFP, FOMC, CPI) automatically block signals on affected pairs 30 minutes before and after the release. You won't get a EUR/USD signal two minutes before a Fed decision. BUILD YOUR OWN STRATEGY The strategy builder lets you define your own edge. Describe your approach in plain text, upload a PDF, or paste a link to your trading plan. The AI extracts structured conditions from your description and turns them into scannable rules. Pick your entry type (market, order block, FVG, OTE, Fibonacci, S/R level), set your minimum R:R, and Neumann scans specifically for setups that match your logic. WHAT YOU GET Real-time signal scanning across 15 instruments Confluence scoring with probability percentage on every setup Entry, stop loss, and take profit levels calculated automatically Push notifications the moment a setup forms Session-aware filtering (Tokyo, London, New York) Analytics dashboard with win rate, pair breakdown, and strategy performance Signal history with outcome tracking (TP hit vs SL hit) Dark and light themes Works on iPhone and iPad Neumann AI is a tool, not financial advice. Signals are generated algorithmically and may contain errors. You are responsible for your own trading decisions. Past signal performance does not predict future results. Trading forex and indices carries substantial risk of loss. Privacy policy: https://app.neumannapp.com/privacy Terms of service: https://app.neumannapp.com/terms

Screenshots

Traders Guild4 screens
Neumann AI4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is iOS requirement: Neumann AI at 13.0 against Traders Guild's 17.0. On price, ads, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price Ā· Rating Ā· Positive reviews Ā· Number of ratings Ā· Update frequency Ā· Ads Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Monetization Ā· Best chart rank Ā· Devices Ā· Requires iOS

CostPrice Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Ads Ā· Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

Scorecard1 real difference Ā· 5 level
Traders Guild versus Neumann AI: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterTraders GuildNeumann AI
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyWeekly—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhoneiPhone, iPod — better
Requires iOS17.013.0 — better
Further details — not scored
Size44 MB32 MB
Age rating12+4+
DeveloperAlistair HennesseyDavid Solomon

In-app purchases

None

Traders Guild

No in-app purchases

None

Neumann AI

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Traders Guild free?
Traders Guild is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Neumann AI free?
Neumann AI is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Traders Guild or Neumann AI have ads?
Neither Traders Guild nor Neumann AI shows ads.

Other comparisons