Comparison

Beethoven Walks vs Incipit

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side โ€” with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Beethoven Walks

Features
Read full description

Beethoven Walks turns a walk in the woods into a concert hall. Created by Yellow Barn and opened in honor of Beethoven's 250th birthday, Beethoven Walks pairs the music and manuscripts of Ludwig van Beethoven with two trails in Putney, Vermont. Along each trail, Music Posts display reproductions of Beethoven's sketches and autograph manuscripts โ€” the same pages he filled while drawing inspiration from his own walks in nature. At each post, this app plays the work that those pages became. Between the posts are Listening Places: quieter spots that invite a longer pause, where the music and the surrounding landscape can be heard together. Two trails to choose from โ€ข Greenwood Trail โ€” 1.3 miles, about 60โ€“70 minutes, with 50 minutes of music across five Music Posts. Hosted by the Greenwood School at 14 Greenwood Lane, Putney VT. โ€ข Hannum Trail โ€” 2.5 miles round trip, about 2.5โ€“3 hours, with 90 minutes of music across nine Music Posts. Trailhead at 442 Holland Hill Road, Putney VT. The music Works include the Archduke Trio, the Emperor Concerto, the Pastoral Symphony, the Heiliger Dankgesang from Op. 132, the Kyrie from the Missa Solemnis, An die ferne Geliebte, the Piano Sonatas Op. 79 and Op. 110, and a late Bagatelle. How to use the app Pick a trail and the app guides you through it post by post. Tap a Music Post to start the corresponding work. The screen stays awake while you walk, and the app remembers where you left off so you can return to the same trail next time. We suggest listening without earphones โ€” the music of the woods is part of the performance. Driving directions to each trailhead are included. "It is indeed, as if every tree in the countryside spoke to me, saying 'Holy! Holy!' In the forest enchantment! Who can express it all?" โ€” from Beethoven's sketchbook, 1815 or 1816 A project of Yellow Barn. Special thanks to the Greenwood School for hosting the Greenwood Trail.

About

Incipit

Features
Read full description

Ten pieces to change what you hear. Ten times over. Most people who feel shut out of a kind of music are not missing an ear. They are missing somewhere to put their attention. Nobody ever told them what to listen for in the first two minutes, and the music does not announce it. Incipit is ten libraries, each of ten pieces in order, each piece finishable in one sitting. A guide called Chiron tells you why each one earned its place, the room it was made in, what changed because of it, one named thing it teaches you to hear, and exactly which recording to go and play. THE TEN LIBRARIES Classical Music โ€” line, harmony, form, time Film Scores โ€” the tools from Classical, on music you already know Soul & Motown โ€” the rhythm section under the voice Country โ€” craft that hides itself Jazz โ€” decisions being made in front of you Hip-Hop โ€” sampling, the drum machine, the producer as composer Rock & the Electric Guitar โ€” distortion, feedback, volume Reggae & Dub โ€” where the beat is not, and the mixing desk as an instrument Latin โ€” rhythm as a system, from Havana to Buenos Aires Electronic โ€” sound built from nothing Genres first and difficulty rising, so nothing asks for an ear you have not been given. WHAT TEN GETS YOU Not expertise. Ten pieces will not make anyone knowledgeable about anything, and anyone promising otherwise is selling something. What ten pieces do is change what arrives. Music that reached you as texture starts arriving as structure. THE TOOLS ACCUMULATE, AND THEY TRAVEL Each piece hands over one named listening tool and you keep it. Bach gives you the single line. Vivaldi gives you the returning theme, which then explains four hundred years of concerto form โ€” and turns out to be running the whole of John Williams. The backbeat you learn in Motown is the one Hip-Hop samples. The clave you clap in Cuba is the engine of a tango. A hundred tools by the end, and they work on music the app never mentions. THE MAP Each library has a map of its ten and what runs between them. Beethoven answering Mozart. Debussy refusing to resolve what Beethoven argued. Each connection appears once you have met both ends of it. WHAT IS NOT HERE No streaks. No points, badges or leaderboards. No account, no sign-in, no advertising. Nothing about you is collected or sent anywhere, because there is nowhere to send it. Recordings are named precisely, by performer and year, and open in Spotify if you have it. Spotify is not required. Where a record carries profanity, the linked edition does not. Every word is original writing produced for this app, fact-checked against sources before publication.

Screenshots

Beethoven Walks2 screens
Incipit4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is iOS requirement: Beethoven Walks at 13.0 against Incipit's 15.1. On price, ads, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price ยท Rating ยท Positive reviews ยท Number of ratings ยท Update frequency ยท Ad data ยท In-app purchases ยท Monetization ยท Best chart rank ยท Devices ยท Requires iOS

CostPrice ยท In-app purchases ยท Ad data ยท Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

Scorecard1 real difference ยท 5 level
Beethoven Walks versus Incipit: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterBeethoven WalksIncipit
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyโ€”Every 2 weeks
Ad dataNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPod โ€” betteriPhone, iPod
Requires iOS13.0 โ€” better15.1
Further details โ€” not scored
Size74 MB30 MB
Age rating4+12+
DeveloperYELLOW BARN, INC.David Hamm

In-app purchases

None

Beethoven Walks

No in-app purchases

None

Incipit

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Beethoven Walks free?
Beethoven Walks is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Incipit free?
Incipit is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Beethoven Walks or Incipit have ads?
Neither Beethoven Walks nor Incipit lists data used for advertising in its App Store privacy details.

Other comparisons