Comparison

BookCard vs Smoulder

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

BookCard

Features
Read full description

BookCard is the private, offline reading tracker that just works. No account. No ads. No 5-book paywall. Your shelf opens instantly and never leaves your phone unless you ask it to. OPENS INSTANTLY. WORKS OFFLINE. Your whole library lives on your device, so it loads in a blink — on a plane, in the subway, anywhere. No loading spinner, no server round-trip, no grey screen. YOUR WHOLE LIBRARY. NO BOOK LIMIT. Track unlimited books free. No cap that forces you to pay after five or ten books. The free tier is the real app, not a demo. SCAN ANY BARCODE. ADD A BOOK IN 2 SECONDS. Point your camera at the back cover and the book lands on your shelf — title, author, cover, page count. Search and manual entry are always there too. HALF-STAR RATINGS. FIRST-CLASS DNF. Rate in half stars (4.5 is a real rating). Did-not-finish is a proper status, not a shame. Log pages, minutes, and notes as you read. STREAKS, YEARLY GOAL, MOOD CHARTS. Beautiful stats: books per month, reading streaks, your most-used moods, and a yearly reading goal with a progress ring. Set it, watch it fill. YOUR SHELF STAYS PRIVATE. NO ACCOUNT. NO ADS. No sign-in wall, no sponsored posts inside your own shelves, no feed, no social graph. Just your books. OPTIONAL PRO — ONE-TIME UNLOCK. Pay once, keep it forever: real iCloud sync (opt-in, Apple-only), custom shelves, Goodreads + StoryGraph import with merge and dedupe, and shareable BookCards. If your plan ever lapses, your books stay fully readable and exportable. WHAT TO READ NEXT — BASED ON YOUR RATINGS. A quiet, on-device suggestion from your own want-to-read pile. No AI, no cloud, just your data. BookCard is local-first. Your shelf, logging, and stats work fully offline; search and covers need a connection. Sync is opt-in and uses only your private Apple iCloud. Terms of Use (EULA): https://bookcard.uptrail.ai/terms Privacy Policy: https://bookcard.uptrail.ai/privacy

About

Smoulder

This app is a reading journal designed for romance readers. It allows users to log finished books with details like ratings, tropes, and memorable lines. Users can also track characters, manage series, and get reading recommendations.

Highlights
  • Reading journal for romance readers
  • Log books with ratings, tropes, and quotes
  • Track favorite characters and their archetypes
  • Manage book series and get next-read suggestions
  • Randomly draw next book from your shelf
  • Import Goodreads data and scan barcodes
Features
Read full description

Smoulder is a reading journal for romance readers. Finishing a book should feel like something. In Smoulder it does: close a book and you get a ceremony, then a reading receipt — a card with the cover, your rating, the tropes, and the line you kept. Save it, share it, or keep it to yourself. Every receipt you have ever been given is kept. THE SHELF Finished books stand on shelves by year, as covers, with your rating under each spine. A year of reading you can actually see. LOGGING BUILT FOR ROMANCE Rate in stars and log the spice. Tag the tropes that got you — enemies to lovers, only one bed, fated mates, touch her and die. Note how it left you: in tears, in a puddle of fluff, or both. Keep the lines worth keeping. THE ROSTER A card for every character you would risk it all for. Add his photo from your own library, his archetype, who you would cast, and the line that did it. Numbered, collected, yours. SERIES, SORTED Smoulder knows which book comes next. Start a series and it tells you what to pick up, so you never lose your place halfway through a trilogy again. THE DRAW Cannot choose? Let the cards choose. A tarot-style draw picks your next read from the books already on your shelf. GET YOUR BOOKS IN, FAST Search by title, or scan a paperback's barcode and watch the cover fill itself in. Bringing a library across? Import your Goodreads export in one go. ON YOUR HOME SCREEN A widget for whatever you are reading now: the cover, and how far in you are. Your library lives on your device. No account required. SMOULDER PRO Smoulder Pro unlocks every paper a receipt can print on, and a roster with no ceiling. • Monthly — $4.99 per month • Yearly — $29.99 per year • Lifetime — $59.99, one payment Payment is charged to your Apple Account at confirmation of purchase. Subscriptions renew automatically unless cancelled at least 24 hours before the end of the current period, and your account is charged for renewal within 24 hours of the end of the current period. Manage or cancel in Settings > your name > Subscriptions. Terms of Use (EULA): https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/itunes/dev/stdeula/ Privacy Policy: https://croftware.io/smoulder-privacy

Screenshots

BookCard4 screens
Smoulder4 screens

Verdict

The call

BookCard and Smoulder are too close to call on the numbers: across 6 compared parameters — price, update cadence, ads and in-app purchases among them — neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. BookCard sells 3 in-app purchases, starting at $2.99 per month and Smoulder sells 3 in-app purchases, starting at $4.99 per month. Whichever you choose, the download price is not the number that matters.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

BookCard ships an update every 6 weeks, Smoulder every 2 months. The most recent releases landed on November 5, 2026 and November 18, 2026 respectively.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
BookCard versus Smoulder: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterBookCardSmoulder
PriceFreeFree
Rating—5.0 (1 ratings) — better
Number of ratings—1 — better
Update frequencyEvery 6 weeks — betterEvery 2 months
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesYesYes
Monetization—Freemium
DevicesiPhone, iPad — betteriPhone
Requires iOS18.018.0
Further details — not scored
Size5 MB4 MB
Age rating4+9+
DeveloperMitaanshu AgarwalCroftware LLC

In-app purchases

3 purchases

BookCard

Subscriptions2
  • BookCardReadingTrackerMonthly$2.991 Month
  • BookCardReadingTrackerYearly$19.991 Year
One-time1
  • BookCard Pro Lifetime$19.99
3 purchases

Smoulder

Subscriptions2
  • Smoulder Pro Monthly$4.991 Month
  • Smoulder Pro Yearly$29.991 Year
One-time1
  • Smoulder Pro Lifetime$59.99

Questions

Is BookCard free?
BookCard is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Is Smoulder free?
Smoulder is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Do BookCard or Smoulder have ads?
Neither BookCard nor Smoulder shows ads.
Which is updated more often, BookCard or Smoulder?
BookCard ships an update every 6 weeks, and Smoulder every 2 months. Most recently, BookCard was updated on November 5, 2026 and Smoulder on November 18, 2026.

Other comparisons