Comparison

Star Archive vs Ishigaki Star Guide

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Star Archive

Read full description

An app for visual astronomy — observing through a telescope or binoculars with your own eyes. Ā· Sky chart — 5.5 million stars with your own fields of view overlaid, opened from plans, observing and object pages. Ā· Plan and recommend — only what your aperture can show under your site's sky (1,272 objects judged in advance), placed into hour slots, rehearsed on the chart. Ā· Observe and record — step through objects on the chart, check, rate and write; review by night or by object. ā–  A built-in sky chart Ā· About 5.5 million stars to 13th magnitude and 16,000+ deep-sky objects. Drag and pinch anywhere. Ā· Sky as it looks right now (zenith up) or north up — one tap on the compass at top left. Ā· Build fields of view from your telescope, eyepieces and finder and overlay several at once. Plan objects as rings, observed ones checked. Ā· Open the chart from a plan, the observing screen or an object page, and come straight back. ā–  One unbroken night Ā· Plan — added objects settle into hour slots on their own; drag to rearrange. Tap an object for its altitude curve and suggested magnification right there. Ā· Rehearsal — walk the night on the chart before you leave. Course editing handles hour slots, order and start stars on one screen. Ā· Observing — step through objects on the chart, check them off, rate and write notes. Dictate by voice. Ā· Records — enter the night's conditions once, then review by night or by object. Long-term plans spanning months, too. ā–  Data and learning Ā· 2,400+ visual guides — how to find it and what each aperture shows. 4,600+ observing points to rate. Ā· Lists such as Messier, Caldwell, Herschel 400 and 1001, plus your own lists and courses. Ā· Star hopping with 126 routes (using the chart's field-of-view settings); Messier marathon prep and a 110-object night. ā–  Also Night mode (red screen, shake to toggle, automatic after sunset) Ā· six themes Ā· sketch albums Ā· eyepiece-view simulator Ā· tonight's clouds and seeing Ā· real-time planets Ā· spreadsheets in and out, full backup Ā· on a bigger screen at starnotearchive.com Ā· Korean, English and Japanese. Free. No ads, no purchases. No account in the app; make a web account only if you want the website. Records stay on your phone; only what you send goes up to the web (site names visible only to you). With weather on, the forecast point's location is passed to the weather service. The 13th-magnitude star data downloads only when you ask. Made as a hobby by one observer.

About

Ishigaki Star Guide

Features
Read full description

Hold your phone up to the night sky and the stars in front of you appear on screen, named. A star guide built for one sky: Ishigaki Island, Okinawa. Ishigaki sits at 24.6 degrees north. From here the Southern Cross clears the horizon from winter dawns to spring evenings, a sight never seen from mainland Japan. POINT AND FIND AR mode draws constellation lines and star names over the live camera view, so the screen matches the sky above you; with the camera off it works as a plain chart. Only the constellation at the centre of your view lights up, the others fade back. 5,070 stars down to magnitude 6.0, the naked-eye limit, with lines for all 88 constellations. THE SOUTHERN CROSS, WITH TIMES Search for the Southern Cross: if it is up, an arrow at the edge of the screen guides you as you turn towards it; if not, the time machine jumps to the next time it will be. Check tonight's sky before you go outside. STAR NAMES FROM THE YAEYAMA ISLANDS Antares is Beecha-bushi. The Pleiades are Muri-ga-bushi. Polaris is Ninufa-bushi. The Milky Way is Tingara. Tap a star to see the Yaeyama name beside the modern one, with the story attached. Search "Haimuru-bushi" and the Southern Cross comes up. FIND THE CONSTELLATIONS AND COLLECT THEM Follow the arrow until the constellation is in front of you, hold it there, and tap "Found it" to record it in your book. A guide character then talks about that constellation and suggests a nearby one you have not found yet, arrow ready. Eighty-one constellations are reachable from Ishigaki; the ones that barely clear the horizon, like the Southern Cross at 8 degrees, rank as legendary. Records only count at night at the real current time, so the book holds only what you actually looked at. GUIDED PROGRAMMES, SPOKEN Like a planetarium show, a guided programme walks you through the sky one constellation at a time. "Yaeyama Winter Sky: An Introduction" is free: on nights from December to February it takes you from Orion to the Pleiades, the Winter Triangle and Canopus low over the sea, narrated in the unhurried voice of an island elder, so you can keep looking up. Every description card can also be read aloud. More themed programmes will follow. WILL IT BE CLEAR TONIGHT? - Sky Score: cloud, moonlight, humidity, visibility, rain and pressure scored out of 100, with the best hour highlighted (needs a connection) - Tonight's Highlights: end of twilight, moonrise and moonset, the moonless dark window, the Southern Cross transit, active showers - Moon Calendar: a month of phases at a glance FINDING DARK SKY Thirty observing spots around Ishigaki and the Yaeyama Islands, each with a Bortle darkness rating and distance from you, with town lights drawn on the map. Tap one for directions. ALSO INCLUDED - Time machine: step by second to year, or play time forward and watch the sky turn - Deep sky: 19 objects including Omega Centauri, Andromeda and the Orion Nebula - A Milky Way drawn from measured isophote data, Sagittarius bulge and Great Rift included - Meteors from the active shower's radiant at a realistic rate - Sound effects and a gentle haptic tap when you find a constellation - Five languages: Japanese, English, Chinese (Traditional and Simplified), Korean MADE BY A STARGAZING GUIDE OF TEN YEARS Hoshihaku, Inc. has run the Nagareboshi-no-oka stargazing tour on Ishigaki for ten years and guided over 60,000 visitors. The explanations are the answers we give guests in the field. PRIVACY - No account, no sign-up, no name or email to enter anywhere - No advertising, no analytics, no tracking - Settings and your collection stay on your device - Coordinates are sent only to fetch the weather forecast, and are not stored - The camera draws the AR background only; nothing is photographed, saved or sent - The microphone is never used Everything but the weather-based Sky Score works offline, guided programmes included. Bearings come from the magnetometer, which reads inaccurately inside a vehicle or near steel.

Screenshots

Star Archive4 screens
Ishigaki Star Guide4 screens

Verdict

The call

Star Archive and Ishigaki Star Guide are too close to call on the numbers: across 5 compared parameters — price, ads, in-app purchases and device support among them — neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price Ā· Rating Ā· Positive reviews Ā· Number of ratings Ā· Update frequency Ā· Ads Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Monetization Ā· Best chart rank Ā· Devices Ā· Requires iOS

CostPrice Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Ads Ā· Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
Star Archive versus Ishigaki Star Guide: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterStar ArchiveIshigaki Star Guide
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyEvery 2 days—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPod
Requires iOS16.415.1 — better
Further details — not scored
Size284 MB32 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperKyungil Myungnobunari arakaki

In-app purchases

None

Star Archive

No in-app purchases

None

Ishigaki Star Guide

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Star Archive free?
Star Archive is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Ishigaki Star Guide free?
Ishigaki Star Guide is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Star Archive or Ishigaki Star Guide have ads?
Neither Star Archive nor Ishigaki Star Guide shows ads.

Other comparisons