Comparison

魔法笔记本 MagicBook vs iGuanZhi

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

魔法笔记本 MagicBook

Features
Read full description

一本会回信的魔法笔记本。 用手指或 Apple Pencil 在羊皮纸上写下任何话,停笔片刻,墨迹会被纸页轻轻吸收——住在笔记本里的小精灵"墨墨"读到了,便用手写体一笔一画地回信给你。 · 真实笔触:笔压感应、墨迹晕染,像在真的纸上书写 · 会记得你:墨墨记得最近聊过的话题,像老朋友一样接着聊 · 亲子共用:家长专区可随时开关云端回信、清除全部记忆 · 简单纯粹:无账号、无广告、无内购 回信由 AI 生成(阿里云通义千问),需家长在应用内同意后才会开启;也可选择纯本地模式,不发送任何数据。

About

iGuanZhi

Features
Read full description

iGuanZhi is an offline workshop for the Guwen Guanzhi, not a static classic-text reader. Original, vernacular, and study English share one page. Recitation, Academy, a fable gallery, and Daily Essay then fold into ordinary days. The app includes 222 classical essays and about 6,500 sentences across 12 parts, from the pre-Qin age to the Ming, by nearly 50 authors. There are also more than 220 famous lines, 18 idioms grown from the essays, and 12 notes on form and craft. Yueyang Tower, the Memorials on Sending Out the Troops, Prince Teng, Orchid Pavilion, Peach Blossom Spring, Red Cliff, On Teachers, and the Chenqing memorial live in one place. Nothing here sits still. Close reading, recitation, practice, idioms, and Home Screen entries form one workflow. Walk from a famous line into an essay, and from an essay back to its idiom, form, and author. Browse by part, seven forms, theme, or author. Take Yueyang Tower. Read the original, open the vernacular, use study English as a ladder, recite with highlighting, practice in Academy, and find "worry first, joy later" in the fable gallery. One essay, several doors. Daily Essay sits on the Lock Screen. Recitation reads a section on the commute. At night you compare layers and keep a note. iPhone, iPad, Mac, and visionOS share the same texts. On iPad, long tools open as a full-screen workbench. The first launch has a seven-page guide you can skip and replay later. 1. Three-layer close reading • Original, vernacular, and English on one page, each layer optional • Bilingual, Chinese, or English reading; vertical text, pinyin, type size, sectioned long essays • Immersive mode; interface in Simplified Chinese, Traditional Chinese, and English • Comparison does not replace the original. It lets you walk between classical and vernacular Chinese. 2. Recitation workbench • Sentence highlighting; rate, pitch, and volume • Playback matrix for title, author, and body in original, vernacular, or English • Captions, continuous play, Lock Screen listening, background audio, Live Activity 3. Academy and Phrase Hunt • Fade, fill-in, sense checks, quizzes, and mastery you can review or reset • Section practice, batch lists, fable match, and Phrase Hunt from one character 4. Fable gallery, famous lines, and the form map • Idioms such as Peach Blossom Spring, the first drum, and worry first, joy later, each linked to the source essay • Famous lines, plus a map of record, preface, rhapsody, memorial, and other forms 5. Daily Essay and streaks • One essay a day, optional seasonal picks, local notification, streaks, random essay, and last read 6. Favorites, lists, and notes • Separate saves for essays, fables, and lines; lists for reading or practice; notes and history 7. Search and discovery • Prepared index, handwriting search, optional system search, authors, forms, and themes 8. Widgets, Lock Screen, and voice • Six widgets on Home Screen, Lock Screen, and StandBy • Control Center, Siri, Shortcuts, and deep links so an essay appears where you already look 9. Cards, appearance, and devices • Twelve share-card styles, accent colors, alternate icons, custom Home shortcuts • iPhone, iPad, Mac, visionOS; guides you can replay; VoiceOver labels and type size 10. Privacy • Full text offline. No account, no ads, no third-party analytics • Optional iCloud sync. Optional on-device explanation on supported devices; the essay stays on the device • Every study feature is free. An optional tip in Settings unlocks nothing The originals are public-domain classics. Vernacular and study English are made for this app, for learning only, and will keep being checked. For students who want to finish an essay, readers who want the original to stay, and anyone who listens on the commute. Open Daily Essay and begin with one piece.

Screenshots

魔法笔记本 MagicBook3 screens
iGuanZhi4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is price: 魔法笔记本 MagicBook at Free against iGuanZhi's $0.99. 魔法笔记本 MagicBook also leads on in-app purchases (none vs 1). On ads, device support and iOS requirement there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

魔法笔记本 MagicBook is free to download; iGuanZhi costs $0.99 up front. iGuanZhi sells 1 one-off in-app purchase. 魔法笔记本 MagicBook asks for nothing beyond the download.

Scorecard2 real differences · 3 level
魔法笔记本 MagicBook versus iGuanZhi: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
Parameter魔法笔记本 MagicBookiGuanZhi
PriceFree — better$0.99
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNo — betterYes
DevicesiPhone, iPadiPhone, iPad
Requires iOS16.4 — better17.0
Further details — not scored
Size47 MB23 MB
Age rating4+4+
Developer士沛 王天从 何

In-app purchases

None

魔法笔记本 MagicBook

No in-app purchases

1 purchases

iGuanZhi

One-time1
  • Reward developers$0.99

Questions

Is 魔法笔记本 MagicBook free?
魔法笔记本 MagicBook is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is iGuanZhi free?
iGuanZhi costs $0.99, and also offers in-app purchases.
Do 魔法笔记本 MagicBook or iGuanZhi have ads?
Neither 魔法笔记本 MagicBook nor iGuanZhi shows ads.

Other comparisons