Comparison

Kiln Anagama vs Magekeep Siege

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both games, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Kiln Anagama

Features
Read full description

Most idle games hand you a number that only ever goes up. Kiln gives you one real anagama firing — a single shared temperature, drawn live in cross-section — and dares you to hold every pot in its window without cooking it. You stoke wood to raise the heat, and the chamber cools on its own. Every ware on the shelves shares that one temperature. But each pot matures only while the heat sits inside its own cone band — the colored zone drawn right into the section. A teabowl ripens low; a tall tsubo needs real heat. Hold a ware in its band and its maturation bar fills; pull it fully matured and it pays reales. That is the whole tension. Push the temperature UP to reach the high cones, but the moment you overshoot a shallow-cone ware's band top, it bloats, slumps and greys out — ruined, lost. So firing is two-sided control: build heat to ripen the big pieces, hold it steady so you don't cook the little ones. Choose your wood. The woodpile fills as you fire — red pine and bamboo charcoal spike hot to chase the high cones, white oak burns low and lays a bed of coals that HOLDS the heat so shallow wares don't cook, and cedar throws the heaviest ash glaze of all. The wood on the stoke is a real decision, made moment to moment for what sits on your shelves. And the finest pots are made at the edge. The olive top slice of every cone band is the ASH ZONE: hold a ware there and wood-ash falls onto it as natural ash glaze, worth up to double at the pull — but that slice hugs the ruin line, so the richest glaze is one overshoot from a slumped grey loss. Then the patrons arrive. Named buyers — the Tea Master, the Sake Brewer, the Daimyō's Steward — post commissions: so many wares of a kind, some demanding true ash glaze. Take an order, serve it with genuine pulls, and earn a purse plus a patron's favor. Favors buy permanent workshop arts in the Patrons' Hall — and one irrevocable signature oath that marks half the kiln as yours forever. Grow the firing: a bigger firebox raises the ceiling to reach higher cones, more stokers build heat faster, thicker walls hold it longer, more shelves fire more wares at once, and better clay widens every forgiving band. When a chamber is mastered, Open a New Chamber to bank master seals — a permanent multiplier on every ware's price — and fire a larger kiln. It runs while you're away: the fire keeps banking heat and the pots keep maturing for up to an hour free — extendable to 8 or 24 hours with a one-time purchase — and pays you on return. • One shared temperature you raise, hold, and can overshoot • Cone bands drawn as live zones — wares glow in-band, grey out when ruined • A woodpile of five cordwoods — spike the heat, hold it with coals, or throw ash • Ash glaze: ride the top of the band for up to double value — one slip from ruin • Patron commissions: take orders, serve them with real pulls, earn favors • The Patrons' Hall: permanent arts plus one irrevocable signature oath • Firebox, stokers, walls, shelves and clay to master the firing • Idle-friendly: the kiln banks heat offline (1h free, or 8h/24h) and pays you on return • Open a New Chamber prestige banks permanent seals and a larger kiln • Fully offline, no account, nothing collected Stoke wisely. Pull them ripe.

About

Magekeep Siege

Features
Read full description

Hold the tower. Grow the keep. Raid the seas. Magekeep Siege is a 3D hex-citadel sim. You are the warden of a living island — farms, lumber, mines, houses, and barracks tick in real time, even while you are away. Wave defense is one activity of that citadel, not the whole game. BUILD THE HEX KEEP • Place farms, mills, mines, houses, markets, taverns, and barracks on a hex island • Chop wall groves, bridge to nearby islets, and upgrade plots up to level 6 • Food, wood, iron, and gold keep producing for up to 8 hours while you are gone HIRE AND RAID • Hire knights from the castle once a farm is running • March them against other players' keep snapshots • Win gold — or send them to rest if the raid fails DEFEND THE WALLS • Your mage holds the battlements against rogues, slimes, and warbands • Draft blessings, cast Inferno / Frost / Storm, and grow the roof mage • Outposts, biomes, and prestige sigils deepen a long run This is an original Balcony Games title. Combat, keep economy, knight raids, and the first-session citadel tutorial were built for Magekeep — not a reskin of a wave-defense template. Third-party art (CC0): Kay Lousberg (KayKit Adventurers, Skeletons, Medieval Hexagons, Forest Nature). Recolored and used under CC0. Music: Adventure Orchestra (CC0) by AyItzMatt. Privacy: https://balconygames.com/privacy Support: alex@bitscorp.co

Screenshots

Kiln Anagama4 screens
Magekeep Siege4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is device support: Magekeep Siege at 3 against Kiln Anagama's 1. Magekeep Siege also leads on iOS requirement (15.6 vs 17.0). On price, ads and in-app purchases there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

Scorecard2 real differences · 4 level
Kiln Anagama versus Magekeep Siege: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterKiln AnagamaMagekeep Siege
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyEvery 2 months—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhoneiPhone, iPad, iPod — better
Requires iOS17.015.6 — better
Further details — not scored
Size1 MB55 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperJordan WegnerAlexandr Korsak

In-app purchases

None

Kiln Anagama

No in-app purchases

None

Magekeep Siege

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Kiln Anagama free?
Kiln Anagama is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Magekeep Siege free?
Magekeep Siege is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Kiln Anagama or Magekeep Siege have ads?
Neither Kiln Anagama nor Magekeep Siege shows ads.

Other comparisons