Comparison

Idle Forge vs Idle Haystack

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both games, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Idle Forge

Features
Read full description

A little forge that doesn't need you. Light the hearth, hire an apprentice, and watch the smithy fill with workers, furnaces and stranger things. Idle Forge is an idle clicker and blacksmith tycoon built to be calm: it earns while you're away, asks for nothing when you return, and never punishes you for having a life. MADE TO RESPECT YOUR TIME • Progress continues while the app is closed. Sleep is a strategy • No daily-streak guilt, no timers that expire while you're at work • Rewarded ads are always optional, always a bonus, never a toll • Tapping helps, but it's a pleasure, not a duty: your workers swing the hammers A FORGE WITH SOMEWHERE TO GO • Dozens of generators, from apprentice to things physics won't explain • Reforge to melt it all down for Embers and permanent power • Then Recast: melt the golden anvil down for Gold, and spend it on perks that change how the next climb plays • A living workshop you can watch: every worker you hire is down there on the floor, hammering • Catch drifting fire wisps for a frenzy of production • Achievements, milestones, a daily gift, and yes, an actual ending at the top of the ladder QUIET BY DESIGN • The forge's own sounds (hammer, embers, quench), no music, no noise • Every effect can be switched off, from vibration to embers • Your save is yours: export it as a code, carry it anywhere, no account Free to play. Rewarded ads are opt-in, and everything they grant can also be earned by playing. A short ad may play after a Reforge, at most once every five minutes.

About

Idle Haystack

Features
Read full description

There is a needle in this haystack. There is a needle in the next one too. Tap the stack. Straws fly. Somewhere in there is a needle, and the only way to find out where is to keep digging. FIND THE NEEDLE Every haystack hides one needle somewhere between a third of the way down and the very bottom. Sometimes you get lucky on the tenth tap. Sometimes you earn every single straw. HIRE HELP Farmhands, a barn cat, a seasonal crew and eventually a combine thresher. They keep digging while the app is closed, for up to eight hours, and they never ask for a break. COLLECT ELEVEN NEEDLES From the entirely unremarkable Sewing Needle to the Golden Needle, the Obsidian Needle and the one they told you about. Six rarity tiers. Better luck pulls better needles. BALE OUT Clear eight haystacks and you can burn the whole barn down for a permanent hay multiplier. You keep the collection. You lose everything else. It is worth it. ONE THUMB, NO PRESSURE No timers demanding you come back. No lives. No punishment for putting it down for a week — the crew will have been busy. Idle Haystack is free to play and supported by optional ads. Watching one is always your choice: nothing in the game is gated behind an advert.

Screenshots

Idle Forge4 screens
Idle Haystack4 screens

Verdict

The call

Idle Forge and Idle Haystack are too close to call on the numbers: across 5 compared parameters — price, ads, in-app purchases and device support among them — neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price Ā· Rating Ā· Positive reviews Ā· Number of ratings Ā· Update frequency Ā· Ads Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Monetization Ā· Best chart rank Ā· Devices Ā· Requires iOS

CostPrice Ā· In-app purchases Ā· Ads Ā· Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
Idle Forge versus Idle Haystack: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterIdle ForgeIdle Haystack
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyWeekly—
AdsYesYes
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPod — betteriPhone, iPod
Requires iOS15.015.0
Further details — not scored
Size78 MB117 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperErik Tobias Rinde TharaldsenZIGL Ltd

In-app purchases

None

Idle Forge

No in-app purchases

None

Idle Haystack

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Idle Forge free?
Idle Forge is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Idle Haystack free?
Idle Haystack is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Idle Forge or Idle Haystack have ads?
Both Idle Forge and Idle Haystack show ads.

Other comparisons