Bytebeat vs 43 Electro Swing
Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.
Bytebeat
Transform mathematical formulas into unique music by writing code. Edit your creations in real-time while they play, visualize the sound waves, and explore various modes for different audio outputs. Export your generated music to WAV format.
- Formula-based music generation
- Real-time editing during playback
- Waveform visualization
- Multiple audio modes (Bytebeat, Signed, Floatbeat)
- Export to WAV format
- Includes 29 preset formulas
Read full descriptionHide full description
t*(42&t>>10) That one line is the whole song. Bytebeat turns a formula straight into sound. It evaluates your expression while t counts up from zero, one step at a time, and writes the result out as the waveform. No synthesizer, no audio files, no samples. The formula is the music. ■ Edit while it plays - Rewrite the formula without stopping playback. t keeps running - Change a single character and the song becomes something else - A keypad holding only the characters that appear in bytebeat formulas, so one tap is one character ■ See the waveform - An oscilloscope draws the samples that are actually playing - Traces are aligned to the rising edge, so the wave stays still instead of scrolling - Instruction count and stack depth are shown too ■ 29 famous formulas - Includes the one-liners from the experiments viznut published in 2011 - Save the ones you like to favorites with your own names ■ Three modes - Bytebeat: result & 255 mapped to 0...255, the way the original sounded - Signed: treated as signed 8-bit - Floatbeat: the result used directly as a -1...1 waveform, where sin and cos come alive ■ Change the speed of t - 500 to 48000 Hz. The original bytebeat ran at 8000 Hz - Slower runs lower, faster runs higher ■ Export to WAV - 8-bit, 8000 Hz, mono, which is exactly what bytebeat is - 10 seconds, 30 seconds, 1 minute or 3 minutes ■ What you can write - The variable t, and the constants PI and E - Arithmetic, bitwise operators, shifts, comparison, logic, the ternary operator - sin cos tan asin acos atan abs floor ceil round sqrt exp log sign int pow min max atan2 mod - Everything is computed in Double and rounded to 32-bit integers only for bitwise operations and shifts. This matches JavaScript's ToInt32, so formulas you find on the web play as they are ■ No connection - No account to create - No ads, no tracking - The app never connects to the internet. It works on a plane Many of the presets come from the experiments Ville-Matias Heikkila (viznut) published in 2011.
43 Electro Swing
This app generates complete electro swing songs with a virtual band. It uses chaos mathematics to create unique melodies and rhythms, offering various styles and instruments. You can play along, export your creations, and enjoy offline functionality.
- AI song generation
- Virtual jazz band ensemble
- Multiple electro swing styles
- Chaos mathematics for unique melodies
- Offline functionality
- MIDI export
- Interactive playing pads
Read full descriptionHide full description
43 Electro Swing writes complete electro swing songs and plays them with a band. Press write and you get a whole record: old verses heard through a gramophone, builds that open the sound up, and club drops with a four-on-the-floor kick under the band and the whole band pumping around it — then a solo, a break or a big-band shout, and an ending: a turntable brake, a big-band button, or the record fading back to 1937. The band is two gypsy-jazz rhythm guitars playing la pompe, a lead on clarinet, trumpet, muted trumpet, alto sax or guitar, a three-piece horn section, upright and sub bass, keys, a swing kit and a producer's house beat. The guitar and the kit are real recordings; the horns, clarinet and bass come from an FM engine that blows and scoops and slurs like players do. All of it ships inside the app, so it works with no network at all. The songs come from chaos maths. A Lorenz attractor draws the melody and a logistic map shades the drummer and the comping, so no two bars need be alike. Chaos on its own is noise, so a small model filters it: it is rewarded for swinging intervals and learns as it writes. The CHAOS / TASTE slider decides how much say each one gets. Eleven styles, and each one is a whole band: its changes, its drummer, its tempo range and how hard it swings. Electro Swing, Hot Club House, Big Band Boogie, Jump Blues, Noir Swing, Swing Hop, Balkan Beats, Charleston, Cabaret Lounge, Electro Dixie and Swing Step. Tick STYLE LOADS RIG and each style brings its own sound. The sound is half the record. Four channels — bass, rhythm guitar, horns and lead guitar — each with a voicing, a tone stack and a resonator: a gypsy-jazz guitar body, a speaker, a gramophone horn or a straight ribbon microphone. Seven one-click rigs, from Hot Club to Warehouse. Effects for the record and the club: sidechain pump, vinyl crackle, gramophone, tape wow, chorus, tremolo and spring reverb. Every song is built from its seed. Write the seed down and you can have that exact song again, note for note. A seed from the browser version rebuilds the same song here. You can play over it, too. The pads are the notes of the song's key rather than a piano keyboard, so nothing you touch is wrong, and the sixteen-step lane swings with the song and follows your host. Both play any of ten instruments through its own channel and out on its MIDI channel. Turn on RADIO and it keeps playing, picking a new style, key, scale and tempo for every song. You also get: • 11 styles, 14 scales, 12 keys, tempo and density • 15 voicings, 6 resonators, 7 rigs and 7 effects • 8 keyboard voices, from upright piano and vibraphone to accordion and bandoneon • Sampled or synthesised drum kit, switchable; brushes always synthesised • Seven-part mixer with a meter on every part • MIDI in, so your keyboard plays whichever instrument you have selected • Export a MIDI file, a WAV mix, or stems — one WAV per part (in the app; in a host you record the audio there) • A note and a MIDI channel for every drum and every house-beat hit • UI scale, so the panel is not tiny on a big iPad • Live spectrum and waveform, and the chaos engine drawn as it runs Two Audio Units, an instrument and a MIDI processor. Each part sends on its own MIDI channel and every drum has a note and a channel of its own, so one instance can drive a rack of them. The MIDI version passes your keyboard through. Both follow your host's tempo and transport, and one install registers both. The app is free and nothing in it is held back. Using the Audio Units inside other apps is a one-time purchase, and each AUv3 session plays for two minutes first so you can try them properly. No account, no ads, no subscription. Works offline. Samples: Karoryfer Emilyguitar and Big Rusty Drums, and two voices from the Versilian Community Sample Library, all CC0.
Screenshots
Verdict
The clearest difference is rating: 43 Electro Swing at 5.0 against Bytebeat's 4.3. 43 Electro Swing also leads on iOS requirement (15.0 vs 17.0). Bytebeat's advantage is in-app purchases (none vs 1) and ratings volume (3 vs 1). On price, ads, monetization model and device support there is nothing between them.
Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS
Both are free to download. 43 Electro Swing sells 1 one-off in-app purchase. Bytebeat asks for nothing beyond the download.
43 Electro Swing holds the better App Store score, 5.0 against 4.3. Both are backed by a comparable volume of ratings — 3 and 1 respectively.
| Parameter | Bytebeat | 43 Electro Swing |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Rating | 4.3 (3 ratings) | 5.0 (1 ratings) — better |
| Positive reviews | 66.7% of reviews | — |
| Number of ratings | 3 — better | 1 |
| Update frequency | — | Every 4 days |
| Ads | No | No |
| In-app purchases | No — better | Yes |
| Monetization | Free | Free |
| Devices | iPhone, iPad | iPhone, iPad, iPod — better |
| Requires iOS | 17.0 | 15.0 — better |
| Further details — not scored | ||
| Size | 3 MB | 40 MB |
| Age rating | 4+ | 4+ |
| Developer | Ryo Tsudukihashi | Soft Brew Mobile |
Customer experience
Bytebeat
43 Electro Swing
In-app purchases
Bytebeat
No in-app purchases
43 Electro Swing
- AUv3 Unlock$2.99
Questions
Is Bytebeat free?
Is 43 Electro Swing free?
Which has better reviews, Bytebeat or 43 Electro Swing?
Do Bytebeat or 43 Electro Swing have ads?
Other comparisons















