Comparison

MeshSat vs RADIO 4DAT

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side β€” with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

MeshSat

Features
Read full description

MeshSat turns an iPhone into a MeshSat gateway. Pair it with a MeshSat node, a pocket-sized box with a Meshtastic LoRa radio and a RockBLOCK 9603 Iridium modem, and one phone can send and receive over the mesh and by satellite. It keeps working when the mobile network and the internet are gone. It also works with any plain Meshtastic radio, for the mesh only. The node is open hardware anyone can build (https://github.com/meshsat/meshsat-fieldkit); its firmware and this app are open source (https://github.com/meshsat/meshsat-ios). Status: pre-release. This is a prototype under active development. It has never been deployed to a real user and has never been used in an actual emergency. Do not rely on it for your safety. What it does: β€’ Mesh: Meshtastic over Bluetooth LE: text, positions, telemetry, waypoints, node info and traceroute. β€’ Satellite: Iridium SBD through the node's RockBLOCK 9603, up to 340 bytes out and 270 bytes in. Messages wait in a queue and are retried until they go out. The app opens a satellite session only when there is something to send, when the modem rings or when you check the mailbox, never on a timer, because every session costs a credit. Passes are predicted on the phone, with no internet needed. β€’ Text messages: MeshSat opens the Messages composer with the text ready, compressed and optionally encrypted for a MeshSat kit; iOS lets no app send or read texts by itself. β€’ APRS through a KISS TNC over TCP (Direwolf, for example) or directly to APRS-IS. β€’ Hub, optional and open source: the phone reports to a MeshSat Hub and takes remote commands. β€’ TAK: the Hub's TAK positions on the map; the phone's own position and an SOS go to the Hub as Cursor on Target. β€’ Reticulum and LXMF: the phone is a Reticulum node with an LXMF address, as Sideband and MeshChat speak it, with voice notes and photos in a chat; over TCP, a Sideband on the same WiFi, the node's RockBLOCK 9704 by satellite, or an RNode radio over Bluetooth. β€’ Safety: hold the SOS button for 3 seconds and the SOS goes out on every route the phone has, each retried until it is sent, until you cancel it. A check-in timer and zones drawn on the map. β€’ Optional: keep the gateway running in the background, reporting your position and relaying while the app is off screen. β€’ The map works offline down to country level. Night mode turns the whole app red. Satellite messaging needs a RockBLOCK modem and Iridium credits from a provider; Iridium is a paid commercial network. Internet connections: the bundled world map covers country level; closer in, map tiles come from OpenStreetMap's tile servers while you look at the map online. Once the MeshSat node's satellite modem has been seen, Iridium orbit data is downloaded from celestrak.org, or tle.ivanstanojevic.me if that fails, when the stored copy is more than a day old, checked at most every 12 hours; before that only when you tap Update on the passes screen. The Hub, APRS-IS, Reticulum over TCP and its listener for peers on your WiFi connect only when you set them up, and a field kit you add under Setup is reached at the address you give it, or through the Hub relay. Node firmware is downloaded from MeshSat's releases on github.com only when you tap Check for update. Feedback from Setup > Help > Support leaves through your own mail app, only when you send it. Nothing else goes online. Permissions: Bluetooth, for the node and an RNode; location, for the map, passes, zones and SOS, and Always only for the background gateway; the camera, for QR codes; notifications, for incoming messages, warnings and an SOS; the microphone and speech recognition, only while you hold the button to record a voice note; a photo you pick, only to send it. A welcome page says what each is for before iOS asks. Privacy: the app has no analytics and no account, and sends nothing to MeshSat. https://meshsat.net/privacy/ Documentation, and a table of what has and has not been verified: https://docs.meshsat.net/ios/

About

RADIO 4DAT

Features
Read full description

RADIO 4DAT turns the low-cost radios you already own into a planned, legal backup communications network. Tell it your group size, how far the farthest link is, the terrain and your license, and it recommends the radio, antenna, channel plan and the lowest transmit power that still closes each link. It knows the rules: without a license it plans only license-free services (FRS, LoRa mesh, Wi-Fi), and it shows exactly why an option is blocked. WHAT'S INSIDE β€’ Plan: a build for your team in seconds, with relays, vehicles and the heads-ups your phone needs β€’ Kit: track your radios, batteries, tests and reorders; sign in to keep the same kit on every device β€’ Gear guide: commercial radios, LoRa boards, receivers and accessories, each tagged with whether you may transmit with it β€’ Survey: a simulated spectrum view showing how a $40 receiver flags interference and jamming and takes bearings β€’ Link: the physics of range, antenna height and power, with an estimate of how far others could hear you β€’ Modem: how text and positions travel over a voice radio to ATAK or iTAK, with legal paths only, and a Mask mode for speech through a mask β€’ Network: situation-aware routing across cell, Wi-Fi, LoRa mesh, radio and satellite, with automatic fallback when a link fails β€’ PACE card: a one-page comms plan to hand to your team β€’ Rules: the radio regulations that trip people up, in plain language β€’ Guide: hands-on tutorials, from a LoRa mesh text net to an off-grid push-to-talk network Civilian and military modes use the right vocabulary for each. Everything works without an account; sign in with Apple or Google only if you want your kit on every device. Team sharing is coming in RADIO 4DAT Team. This release is a planner with simulated radios: it does not transmit. Radio integration follows in a later release. It is a planning aid, not legal advice; transmit only where you are licensed or authorized. Built by 4DAT LLC, a service-disabled veteran-owned small business.

Screenshots

MeshSat4 screens
RADIO 4DAT4 screens

Verdict

The call

MeshSat and RADIO 4DAT are too close to call on the numbers: across 5 compared parameters β€” price, ads, in-app purchases and device support among them β€” neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price Β· Rating Β· Positive reviews Β· Number of ratings Β· Update frequency Β· Ads Β· In-app purchases Β· Monetization Β· Best chart rank Β· Devices Β· Requires iOS

CostPrice Β· In-app purchases Β· Ads Β· Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
MeshSat versus RADIO 4DAT: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterMeshSatRADIO 4DAT
PriceFreeFree
Update frequencyEvery 2 daysβ€”
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhoneiPhone, iPad β€” better
Requires iOS17.0 β€” better18.0
Further details β€” not scored
Size78 MB2 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperKyriakos Papadopoulos4DAT LLC

In-app purchases

None

MeshSat

No in-app purchases

None

RADIO 4DAT

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is MeshSat free?
MeshSat is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is RADIO 4DAT free?
RADIO 4DAT is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do MeshSat or RADIO 4DAT have ads?
Neither MeshSat nor RADIO 4DAT shows ads.

Other comparisons