Comparison

Cookie Critic vs The Cookie Index

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Cookie Critic

Features
Read full description

Cookie Critic is the home for people who take cookies seriously. Every cookie is rated by real cookie lovers, so you always know where to find the best one, whether that's down the street or across the country. FIND THE BEST COOKIE NEAR YOU • See the top-rated cookies nationwide or narrow it to your city • Open the map to find highly ranked bakeries close by • Filter by type: chocolate chip, sugar, double chocolate, oatmeal and more RATE EVERY BITE • Score any cookie from 1 to 10 and write a quick review • Add photos so others can see what they're getting into • Log a new bakery straight from the map in seconds BUILD YOUR CRAVER LIST • Swipe through cookies and save the ones you have to try • Keep a must-try list for your next trip • Feeling indecisive? Let Cookie Critic pick a random cookie for you JOIN THE COMMUNITY • Track how many cookies you've tried and your average score • Share your critic profile with friends • See what other critics are eating and where From neighborhood bakeries to famous dessert spots, Cookie Critic helps you skip the disappointing cookies and go straight to the great ones. Questions or feedback? We'd love to hear from you at the support link below.

About

The Cookie Index

Features
Read full description

The Cookie Index is the world's chocolate chip cookie database — built by people who take the question "where's the best cookie?" far too seriously. FIND THEM Every bakery, café, deli, and restaurant on the map. Search any place on Google Maps, or open the app and see what's rated near you. RATE THEM A quick guided rating: texture, chocolate, character, then your score out of 10 — down to the decimal. Add a photo so the rest of us know whether it's worth the drive. RANK THEM Live rankings by city and worldwide, ranked by plain average — no mystery math. See which spots are climbing and who the top cookie critics are. ARGUE ABOUT THEM Follow friends to see exactly which cookies they rated and what they thought. React to ratings. Get notified when someone follows you back. PRIVATE BY DEFAULT Every rating is shown anonymously. Your name appears only to people whose follow request you've accepted. Block or report anything that doesn't belong, and delete your account any time from your profile. THE RULES There is one. This is for chocolate chip cookies ONLY. No snickerdoodles. No oatmeal raisin. No exceptions.

Screenshots

Cookie Critic4 screens
The Cookie Index3 screens

Verdict

The call

Cookie Critic and The Cookie Index are too close to call on the numbers: across 5 compared parameters — price, ads, in-app purchases and device support among them — neither pulls far enough ahead to decide it. What separates them is feature set and interface, not measurable difference.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ScorecardNo meaningful differences
Cookie Critic versus The Cookie Index: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterCookie CriticThe Cookie Index
PriceFreeFree
Rating5.0 (9 ratings) — better—
Number of ratings9 — better—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
DevicesiPhoneiPhone
Requires iOS17.016.4 — better
Further details — not scored
Size4 MB37 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperDEREK JAY FELDBenjamin Rhyne

In-app purchases

None

Cookie Critic

No in-app purchases

None

The Cookie Index

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Cookie Critic free?
Cookie Critic is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is The Cookie Index free?
The Cookie Index is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Cookie Critic or The Cookie Index have ads?
Neither Cookie Critic nor The Cookie Index shows ads.

Other comparisons