Comparison

Attack Drums vs Topline Songwriting

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Attack Drums

This app is a powerful sound engine and pattern sequencer inspired by a classic VST plugin. It excels at creating drum sounds but can also be used for vocals and other instruments, featuring a unique text-based vocoder.

Highlights
  • 24-part sound engine
  • Pattern sequencer
  • Phrase Vocoder (text-based)
  • Versatile effects section
  • Inter-App Audio & Audiobus 3 support
  • MIDI Sync
  • Export song to audio file
Read full description

Attack Drums is a synthesizer designed mainly for drum sounds, but the powerful sound engine can also be used for everything else - including vocals. Based on the Waldorf Attack VST PlugIn from 2001, it consists of a 24-part sound engine, now packed with a pattern sequencer and a versatile effects section. One highlight of the effects section is the new Phrase Vocoder, a vocoder that uses written text instead of spoken words. Lyrics in - song out, adjust gender as you have always wanted! Just like Waldorf Nave, Attack Drums is a seriously in-depth musical instrument - easy and fun to use, but a sonic beast at its core! Specifications: -24 Sounds -Four independent effect slots with selectable effect: *Delay *Equalizer *Overdrive *Phaser *Flanger *Chorus *Phrase Vocoder -Reverb -Compressor -Pattern Sequencer -999 Patterns -Polyphonic steps - up to 8 notes per step -Fractional track/step timing -Audiobus 3 -Inter-App Audio -MIDI Settings -MIDI Sync -Loop function -Export song to audio file -AudioCopy / AudioPaste -Content control via iTunes File Sharing -Trigger Pads -Mixer -Recording

About

Topline Songwriting

Features
Read full description

Topline is a voice memo app built for songwriting. Hum a melody, sing a line, or strum an idea, and it is saved the moment you stop. When you want more than a bare recording, attach a chord progression or a backing track and record over it. RECORD FIRST • One big record button, always within reach of your thumb • Full-bandwidth audio so vocals and guitar sound like they did in the room • Start a recording hands-free with Siri while you are driving or playing LYRICS THAT WRITE THEMSELVES • Recordings are transcribed automatically into searchable lyrics • Fix a misheard word with a tap, or swap it for a rhyme or synonym • Search every recording by title or by any line you sang AN OPTIONAL MUSIC LAYER • Build a backing progression from the chords in your key, shown with Nashville numbers • Piano or Rhodes voicings, drone, metronome, tempo, and time signature • Import your own backing track and set where it starts • Engage or silence the chords and the backing independently for the next take MADE TO STAY OUT OF THE WAY • Recordings and lyrics live on your device • Light, dark, or follow the system • Share a take as an audio file from anywhere in the app Topline is for the first two minutes of a song: the part where you need to get it down before it disappears.

Screenshots

Topline Songwriting4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is price: Topline Songwriting at Free against Attack Drums's $14.99. Attack Drums's advantage is iOS requirement (12.0 vs 17.0). On ads, in-app purchases and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Topline Songwriting is free to download; Attack Drums costs $14.99 up front. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

Scorecard2 real differences · 8 level
Attack Drums versus Topline Songwriting: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterAttack DrumsTopline Songwriting
Price$14.99Free — better
Rating4.4 (23 ratings) — better—
Positive reviews34.2% of reviews—
Number of ratings23 — better—
Update frequencyEvery 2 weeks—
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationPaid—
DevicesiPadiPhone, iPad — better
Requires iOS12.0 — better17.0
Further details — not scored
Size97 MB51 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperWaldorf MusicRyan Dunnewold

Bugs and requests

Attack Drums

Reported bugs

21 issues
  • Crashes when loading own samples
  • Lag with MIDI clock sync
  • Inconsistent MIDI response and routing
  • Low velocity response
  • Transport controls not showing in DAWs
Show 16 more
  • App crashes on startup
  • App won't open on iOS 9
  • Display scaling issues on iPad mini
  • Sound designer page not working on iPad 2
  • Copy bug
  • Sequencer limited to one bar
  • Random velocity on pads
  • Crashes with Audiobus
  • Screen doesn't fit on iPad mini
  • Controls not working on iPad mini
  • Sound cut out
  • Locks up on iPad 2
  • Not compatible with iPad 2
  • Sluggish and slow performance
  • App closes for no reason
  • Display on iPad mini scaled incorrectly

Requested features

19 requests
  • Ableton Link support
  • Improved MIDI sync
  • Smoother IAA and MIDI integration
  • More pattern steps (64+)
  • Support for triplets and higher note divisions
Show 14 more
  • Dropbox integration
  • Disable opening animation
  • Separate outputs in iOS
  • Auto-envelope setting for samples
  • Parameter automation
  • MIDI CC parameter control
  • MIDI port/channel selection
  • Looping multiple patterns for jamming
  • Subfolders for samples
  • Interface facelift
  • Live tweaking of FX, rolls, stutters
  • Parameter locks
  • Triplet grids option
  • Ability to export MIDI patterns

Topline Songwriting

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

In-app purchases

None

Attack Drums

No in-app purchases

None

Topline Songwriting

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is Attack Drums free?
Attack Drums costs $14.99, with no in-app purchases.
Is Topline Songwriting free?
Topline Songwriting is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Do Attack Drums or Topline Songwriting have ads?
Neither Attack Drums nor Topline Songwriting shows ads.

Other comparisons