Really Good
Cottage and Rugby with fake dating
A must listen
Lovely book, fantastic story very engaging just a fabulous listen.
Quite a moving story.
Good
I love
Theo
Well Done
18 DAYS IN HEAVEN
Nice Read
Great Binge Listen
Enjoyable and well written
Loved it!
What kept blowing me away is that this all actually happened in the 18th century. These two ships went from near-Antarctic waters — the Roaring 40s, how did they even stay warm? — all the way to Tahiti and Hawaii. A multi-year voyage. And somehow the two ships of Cook’s third expedition stayed together the whole time. Spoiler alert: not that many men die. It reads like science fiction.
Sides’s portrayal of Cook and his officers is really well developed. Cook comes across as flawed but genuinely incredible. And the history feels balanced — respectful to the Polynesian perspective and the English one. You don’t walk away with a good-guy/bad-guy framing. Just real people with real demons and real virtues. Imagine being an 18th century English sailor running into Polynesian societies for the first time. Staggering.
On the audiobook: Peter Noble is fine — not distracting, and the book is so good it barely matters. He’s South African, which gives the accent which I generally really like, but he does the “consonant pop” thing where hard Ts and Ps really punch through. For some reason that drives me nuts — but it doesn’t distract from this great book. Not my favorite narrator, but perfectly listenable.
One tip if you don’t do it already: the audiobook + Kindle combo was fantastic in general, and it’s so nice for this book for the Hawaiian and other Polynesian pronunciations. Read at home, listen while driving, fly through it keep up your reading momentum. Highly recommend the dual approach.


