Baseball manager 25
This game is so cool whenever I play it that it is very fun and also when you’re like up to like it kind of like calm your brain down and I hope you like a motivate yourself so I mean I would inspire people to play this game
Love this game
I love this game but I was wondering when the best one will come out or at least update teams after the trades that were done this season
Unsuitable for long saves
The draft/minor league system is broken whether or not you install rosters
Because
There are no minor league contracts, draft picks stay in “other leagues” and can only be signed directly to the 40-man roster
Therefore
Draft picks never develop. Development is broken, the attribute specialization page especially.
Therefore
Trade weight is absurd, a 68 overall 25 year old with 4 star green potential is weighted similarly to a recent draft pick with the same potential for example
Therefore
Playing a save for 2+ seasons is… just not fun.
Some other details
- scouting should be enabled all season, there’s so many rounds in this draft versus other sports.
- I would hope for specialized stat views in specific windows, eg showing contact and power instead of hit/pow/fld in the batting order attribute screen.
- there are ghost players created when they could be drawn from the minor league or force you to play someone out of position.
- the frequency that the best players resign or somehow avoid free agency makes it skippable depending on the year.
I love the basketball and football versions and I’ve played these games for years and buy premium for custom rosters etc. Just offering constructive criticism.
Because
There are no minor league contracts, draft picks stay in “other leagues” and can only be signed directly to the 40-man roster
Therefore
Draft picks never develop. Development is broken, the attribute specialization page especially.
Therefore
Trade weight is absurd, a 68 overall 25 year old with 4 star green potential is weighted similarly to a recent draft pick with the same potential for example
Therefore
Playing a save for 2+ seasons is… just not fun.
Some other details
- scouting should be enabled all season, there’s so many rounds in this draft versus other sports.
- I would hope for specialized stat views in specific windows, eg showing contact and power instead of hit/pow/fld in the batting order attribute screen.
- there are ghost players created when they could be drawn from the minor league or force you to play someone out of position.
- the frequency that the best players resign or somehow avoid free agency makes it skippable depending on the year.
I love the basketball and football versions and I’ve played these games for years and buy premium for custom rosters etc. Just offering constructive criticism.
Show more
The basketball one is the best
It would be cool if it had actual players names and the ratings are kinda goofy
Game doesn’t work
It keeps saying that my lineup is invalid so then I press auto lineup and it keeps giving me the same message so I can’t simulate any games. I’ve played the basketball version of this game and know that that game works but if you don’t buy the pro version then it doesn’t let you play past the 6th season. It’s annoying because it advertises itself as a free to play game and when you actually play it you realize that settings are restricted so you can’t change certain things without buying the pro version and you can’t play as long as they tell you you can when downloading the game. It’s kind of deceptive and wrong. If they were going to do this then they may as well just make it so you have to pay to download. No one wants to buy the pro version anyway once they’ve already downloaded some sort of version of the game. It’s actually a kind of bad business model that I think should be fixed
Show more
