Importing duplicate,multiple items and hotkey
Is it possible to avoid setting the minimum version to macOS 15?
----------------- 3.4.3-------------------------
• "Multiple items of information" does not work.
(I haven't kept up with 3.4.1. I don't know if this version has fixed this problem.)
•Need multiple selection and hotkey functions to facilitate the selection and deletion of multiple records.
----------------- 3.4---------------------------
Still unfixed bugs.
----------------- 3.3.7 -------------------------
There are also duplicates of imported bookmarks, but there is no check to see if the bookmarks are duplicates. Moreover, the processing speed during reload is too slow, and there is no pause button. You need to wait until all processing is completed before all thumbnails can be displayed normally at once. Please add hotkey and multiple selection functions
----------------- 3.3.5 ------------------------- Importing duplicate bookmarks, merging does not work.
Multiple items of information need to be checked for deletion and tagging，and hotkey.
Not fully implemented
- required to have additional paid app “Opener”
- not tightly integrated with a browser, required to switch between apps when browsing
Response from developer
Update: May. 2 Bookmarks version 4.0.7 now supports Aloha Browser. Thank you for the suggestion Wizardion. If you have any other feedback, please let me know by updating your review, or through the feedback form in the app. —Previous response— Hello Wizardion, thank you for your review and feedback. I was not aware of Aloha Browser, and will add support for it in the next update. iOS has a limitation that requires the developer to add support for opening other apps through updates. Opener has support for a wider catalog of apps and faster than Bookmarks to update the list. It is a paid app, but provides flexibility, which is why Bookmarks has integration with it. If there are any other apps you’d like Bookmarks to support, please let me know.
とてもよいが、、
Safariのブックマークhtmlファイルが読み込めない
基本的には良いのだけれど。。
基本的には便利だしでいいけれどちょいちょい残念感というか
・AI（Apple Intelligence）によるタイトル提案などがフリーズを起こすことがある。
これはアプリのというよりAI側の問題だとは思うのでいいけれど、オフにしてもたまにフリーズする。一応オフにしてEnter連打したら通った。
・検索機能のタブを選択すると時々アプリがクラッシュすることがある
・URLを入力して情報取得が動いた時にそのまま応答停止することが頻繁にある
・サムネイルが取得されない
サムネが取得できているサイト（同一ドメイン）なので取得可能にも関わらず取得しない（されない）ことが結構ある
このあと使い続けて数時間。
ブックマーク追加をする中で多分20回くらいアプリがクラッシュした。
— 開発者様への返信 —
申し訳ございません。
URLを共有したいところなのですが、登録作業を行ってからそこそこ経っているため、どのURLでクラッシュ用が起きていたかを覚えていないため、共有ができません💦
Merci Bien
Microsoft Edgeで開けない
SafariやChrome、Firefoxでは開けるので、使うには問題ないですが。
Update ruined it
Ruined
Response from developer
Hello myreasonsmile, Thanks for the honest feedback. Version 4 has a new layout option called “simple.” This allows for a more simpler layout, which hides the tabs at the bottom. Please let me know by updating/adding to your review, if the “simple” option solves your problem. — Past Response — Hello myreasonsmile, thank you for leaving a review. From the description you’ve written, I am assuming the websites you saved shows image in grid, but not in list or column where it shows this app’s icon. This may be because the app failed to get the icon, or the websites you saved don’t have a traditional icon. You can check this out by long pressing on a bookmark, tap “Edit”, and scroll down to see the data saved. If you are able to share more details, please send me the URL of the websites in the feedback form in the app. This can be found under, Settings(gear icon), “Contact”, “Submit Feedback”.
Pretty good overall
Solid but needs improvement
However, there is no web app or desktop app so afaik it’s totally inaccessible from a computer. This is a crucial need for me (and I would guess most people who need bookmark managers) so I hope that that will be an option soon.
Some UI design choices are unintuitive as well, so onto my suggestions.
1. You can’t drag folders on top of each other, which you’d expect to be able to do. The “Move folder” button looks like a header in the edit menu, so it took me a while to figure out how to nest folders.
2. Having the create folder/tag/hashtag option underneath a modal titled New Bookmark is pretty confusing. I’m assuming this was done became the side pane is a pro feature but it feels super clunky and hard to infinitely figure out. I see that there’s a plus at the bottom of side bar as well to create a new folder but since most of content is at the top, it’s visually hard to spot on an iPad and should be moved to the top next to the settings icon. And I’m not sure 3 types of organization is needed. You can’t change the name/label of the tags anyway so I don’t know what the use case would be for it.
3. The “Ask before delete” setting is turned off by default and can be turned on. It should really be the other way around. Same thing with “Collapsible nested folders”.
4. Visually, it would be nicer to have the thumbnails fill the grid box rather than fit it. It looks ugly to have blank space on the edges.
5. The Save button disappears when you have go to edit the folder a bookmark is and you have to click back to the main menu to save. That’s confusing, the Save button should persist.
6. The hitbox for the drop down menu arrow when expanding nested folders is too small.
7. In the All page, you can see a list of folders up top but only the folders that are the first nested folder (not the top level folders or the ones nested within those). A bit of a weird decision, they should either be the current most top level folder or should be removed completely. I think it just wasn’t thought through properly because the side bar is a pro feature so I guess you need it there but once you also have nested folders from pro, it becomes confusing.
Anyway just thought I’d be helpful instead of leaving a 3 without feedback. Are there any plans for accessing through a computer?
Response from developer
Hello aureum.palatium, Thanks for the detailed feedback! The following issues mentioned is fixed in version 4, which is coming soon: #1: folders will be able to drag on top of each other to nest them #3: “Ask before delete” and “Collapsible nested folders” will be on by default, with the delete option combined for bookmark/folder/hashtag. #4: Thumbnails will have a filling background #7: “All” will only show parent folders Regarding #2, three types of organization is there for people who need them. Tags can be completely hidden, and you can also choose to not use hashtags too. For the options of folder/tag/hashtag when creating a bookmark, there will be a label added at top to better communicate what these do, in version 4(coming soon). For #5 and #6, will look into them for a future update.
Wth
Useful for Spotify!
Nicht ausgereift
Bad
Life Saver
Add a option to open URL inapp directly form shortcut.
I love it! Almost perfect
Clean minimalist UI, feels very native
Response from developer
Hello MicaelaFontana, thanks for writing a review! The app currently supports saving highlighted elements to the notes, if you are using the share sheet extension from Safari(the app icon in share sheet or “Save to Bookmarks” button in extensions). If this is not the highlights you mentioned, please elaborate in your review.
Awesome
Icons not showing
Response from developer
Hello myreasonsmile, thank you for leaving a review. From the description you’ve written, I am assuming the websites you saved shows image in grid, but not in list or column where it shows this app’s icon. This may be because the app failed to get the icon, or the websites you saved don’t have a traditional icon. You can check this out by long pressing on a bookmark, tap “Edit”, and scroll down to see the data saved. If you are able to share more details, please send me the URL of the websites in the feedback form in the app. This can be found under, Settings(gear icon), “Contact”, “Submit Feedback”.
