Cardly AI User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience13.3% of reviews
Neutral7.2% of reviews
Negative experience79.5% of reviews

~ Based on 375 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is Cardly AI Safe?

Cardly AI: Sports Card Scanner appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Cardly AI is 92/100.

This assessment is based on 10,460 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.6/5.

Safety Analysis

88.8% of ratings point to a safe experience
3.1% of ratings suggest some concerns
8.1% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 10,460 App Store ratings for Cardly AI.

Is Cardly AI Legit?

Cardly AI: Sports Card Scanner appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Cardly AI is 88/100.

Based on 88 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Card prices are way off

Scan some cards with auto and patched and prices are way off

Response from developer

We're sorry the card prices aren't matching up for you — that's frustrating. We're actively working on improving our price data and scanning accuracy. If you need any help, reach out to us at cardlyai@scate.ai. If you ever find the time, we'd really appreciate it if you could update your review and rating. Also make sure you're on the latest version of the app.

Not what I paid for!

This app is not that great period

Scan: Good, Value: Terrible

The scanning function works great and the bulk scan feature is a huge time saver (but a $10 upsell). The valuations are absolutely terrible. The app consistently comps against the wrong cards or variants even though it has properly identified the card in question. It’s super disappointing and makes me wish I hadn’t spent money on the app.
Show more

Yuck

So many bugs. Value decisions appear to be done on a dart board by a blind man

Trouble

Told me my 2023/24 Austin Matthews allure patch auto/25 was worth five dollars. It’s a $500 card. Not sure about this app.

Response from developer

We're sorry the valuation missed the mark on that card—that's a huge difference and totally understandable why you'd be frustrated. We're working on improving how we price rare cards and autos, so thanks for flagging this. If you need any help, reach out to us at cardlyai@scate.ai. If you ever find the time, we'd really appreciate it if you could update your review and rating once you give us another shot. Also make sure you're on the latest version of the app.

Do you take the chance?

Every one that collects cards knows the pain of trying apps and not very often they stay on your phone so when they want money first without any trial period the chances of someone actually paying for it is very slim cause how do you know if it's any good you could scan a card and and just like some other apps I've experienced the wrong name comes up with the card that I've scanned so why would I blindly pay for an app? Can anybody verify? Is it better than Google AI where it's free?
Show more

Response from developer

Thanks for the honest feedback—we totally get the hesitation about paying without trying it first. You're right that scanning accuracy matters, and we're sorry you had that experience with mismatched names. We're constantly working to improve the recognition, and if you need any help, reach out to us at cardlyai@scate.ai. If you ever find the time, we'd really appreciate it if you could give us another shot and update your review. Also make sure you're on the latest version of the app.

Great idea but not as accurate

This a great idea and if it were accurate it would save $80 per card to get authenticated.

No AI grading just a scanner

It would be one thing if your scanner doesn’t actually find any of the cards scanned it’s quite another to charge weekly rather than monthly without making it clear DO NOT USE

It doesn’t know the value of cards

I scanned a card that was worth minimum $6000.00 and scanned it twice, it gave me 2 different values . $13.41 and $15.36. Don’t waste your money

Response from developer

We're sorry the valuations were so far off — that's definitely not what we're going for. We're working to improve the accuracy of our scanning, and your feedback helps us get there. If you need any help, reach out to us at cardlyai@scate.ai. If you ever find the time, we'd really appreciate it if you could update your review and rating. Also make sure you're on the latest version of the app.

Could be better

I scanned a few cards I have received back from PSA as 10’s and none of them came back I the app higher then 8.

Trash

It needs money to use 👎👎👎👎👎👎

Not Sure It’s Worth $40 a year

I like the app so far but do not like that there is no option to interact with the AI when it incorrectly identifies a parallel. This app told me I had a Mosaic Genesis Alvin Kamara when it’s actually a Purple Reactive Mosaic. So now that counts as one of my limited daily scans and the app is wrong.
Show more

Don’t download if you want to get free ai grading

Gotta pay weekly or yearly to even get a simple scan of your card

Scam

Cant scan anything unless you buy pro

Not accurate

The accuracy and consistency of this app is bad. Like VERY BAD

Nothing is Free

Why offer an app for free if you have to pay to do anything with it. Not paying when I have other apps that can do the same thing. Bye!

Limited scans

The thing wrong is I am limited on the number of scans. I have emailed you a few times to ask about the batch scan limit but no response so I figured a bad review might get a response!! I’m so glad that you care about your customers. The customer service is TERRIBLE. I don’t know if I even want to do anymore business with you. Thanks for the response, that NEVER CAME!!!!!!
Show more

Ok…

Good with some cards and way off with others. I had a basic Sam Darnold card that the app was trying to tell me it’s worth $140 when it’s $1.25

Pro and batch scanning

I bought the pro version and messed around for a little while scanning some cards here and there. I finally decided to work on my 15k plus card collection and purchased the bulk scan function. I got an error of reached daily limit. I paid for unlimited and bulk. I would give this a 1 star but there are some good features if you are only doing a few cards here and there.
Show more

Accurate??

Gives different prices for a same card scanned twice….