Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly User Reviews

Customer Experience

Positive experience27.8% of reviews
Neutral11.1% of reviews
Negative experience61.1% of reviews

~ Based on 18 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say

Is Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly Safe?

Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly appears mostly safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly is 83/100.

This assessment is based on 264 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.2/5.

Safety Analysis

79.5% of ratings point to a safe experience
4.2% of ratings suggest some concerns
16.3% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 264 App Store ratings for Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly.

Is Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly Legit?

Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Coin & Value Identifier-Coinly is 83/100.

Based on 83 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

👍

I like this app because I learned new stuff and I can sell it too

Response from developer

Hi! We're glad to hear you're enjoying the app and finding it informative while also being able to sell your items! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Wrong coin ID

You quoted me for a coin which not only was not the one I pictured it was a different year and country, and metal. Scam!

Response from developer

Hi! It’s disheartening to hear about your experience with the coin identification. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and want you to know that we take such feedback seriously. Your insights are valuable, and they help us improve the app. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Miss the mark

Some of the coins that I scanned the picture didn’t come out well and the reading was wrong

Response from developer

Hello! It sounds like you've experienced some challenges with scanning coins, and we're grateful for your feedback. Your insights are invaluable as they help us understand where improvements can be made. If you have more details about the specific coins that didn't scan correctly, please feel free to share them at support@coins-scanner.app. Thank you for helping us enhance the experience! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Unbrauchbar

Vier Versuche, dreimal komplett falsch. Sofort auch das Probeabo wieder gelöscht und die App auch

Response from developer

Hallo! Es tut uns leid, dass die App Ihren Erwartungen nicht entsprochen hat und Ihre Versuche erfolglos waren. Ihr Feedback ist uns wichtig und wir danken Ihnen dafür. Wir hoffen, dass Sie uns in Zukunft eine weitere Chance geben, Ihnen ein besseres Erlebnis zu bieten. Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Sort of works..

I use it to get a general idea of the value of quite a few gold coins I inherited, and it works….. sometimes. It’s about 50/50 whether it accurately identifies the coin and melt values are always wrong but it does let me know if it’s rare or not. It seriously struggles with coins in protective casing even if they’re clearly visible with a thin protective layer only. It would have to improve a lot to get me to subscribe. I’ll continue to check on the app and revise my review if it improves over time. 👍👍
Show more

Response from developer

Hi! Thank you for sharing your experience! We appreciate your feedback on the app's performance with gold coins and its challenges with protective casings. Your insights are invaluable as we strive to enhance accuracy. We're glad it helps identify rarity, and we hope to earn your trust in the future! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

The app doesn’t recognize all coins.

I took a picture of my coin and It’s pulling up a different coin.

Response from developer

Hello! Thank you for sharing your experience with us! It’s concerning to hear that the app isn’t recognizing your coins accurately. We appreciate your feedback and encourage you to contact us at support@coins-scanner.app to provide more details about the specific coins. Your insights are valuable to us! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Not reliable

This app is not reliable. Every time I scan a coin I get off something went wrong. Come back later. Then when it does identify a coin, it gives you completely the wrong coin.
I’ve been able to match more through Google photos than I can through this app which I paid a year membership and I’m trying to cancel but it doesn’t work
Show more

Response from developer

Hi! It's disappointing to hear about the issues you're facing with scanning coins. We appreciate your feedback on the app's reliability and the challenges with cancellation. Your experience matters to us, and we’re looking into this. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

I like this app

Honestly for identification and quick valuations this thing is perfect. I inherited a bunch of coins from my grandfather and had no clue what I was looking at. This app is a game changer!
Found out I had a 1943 wheat penny that’s actually worth something!
Now I scan everything that comes to hand, hoping to find something else valuable:)
Show more

Response from developer

Hello! We're delighted that the app has become your go-to tool for coin identification and valuations! It's fantastic to hear about your valuable discoveries from your grandfather's collection. Happy scanning for more hidden treasures! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Fake

Scam all around- this app is identifying 1972 coins as silver. Tried to complain but the feedback button says unavailable. Of course! But the favorable review button works, hmmmm.

Response from developer

Hi! We recognize your concerns about the app misidentifying coins and the unavailability of the feedback option. Your experience is important to us, and we’ve escalated this matter internally. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, and we appreciate your patience as we strive to improve. Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Don’t buy

Waste of money. I’ve got 3 quarters I’ve tried to value multiple times. The dates on the quarters are 1965, 1966, and 1969. Every single result showed me value for quarters from 1942-1964. All of my coins are after 1964 so it’s given me zero helpful information and it cost me 7 bucks. Thanks for nothing.
Show more

Response from developer

Hi! We appreciate your feedback and understand your disappointment with the app's valuation results for your quarters. Your experience is important to us, and we've escalated this matter internally. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, and we hope you find value in your coin collection moving forward! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Great scanning

Quick and clean 😭

Response from developer

Hello! Thank you for your fantastic feedback! We're delighted you enjoy the efficiency and clarity of our scanning features. Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Canceling membership

My membership has been cancelled for awhile. Welp they just charged my card for 0 reason. This service is numnuts

Response from developer

Hi! It’s disappointing to hear about the unexpected charge after your membership cancellation. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and have escalated the matter internally. Your feedback is valuable, and we hope to ensure a smoother experience moving forward. Thank you for sharing! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

New but good app

This app isn’t better than searching up your coin on the internet. Has tons of trip ups with the small details so maybe integrate some human interaction like manually putting in the year so you don’t have to keep redoing the analysis for the correct

year.

Response from developer

Hi! We appreciate your feedback and understand your concerns about the app's accuracy and the need for manual input for details like the year. Your suggestion for integrating more user interaction is valuable, and we’re always eager to hear how we can improve. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Your app sucks

Yeah, I think that this is the worst app I've ever seen. I've try to take pictures of about a dozen coins at least and it kept giving me an X and saying that the coin was not a good picture.! How much bloody better do you want to get it? It's right in the circle and Claire's day but this app doesn't think so! Pathetic I'm gonna try a few more coins and I'm done.
Show more

Response from developer

Hi! We appreciate your feedback and truly regret that you’re experiencing difficulties with capturing images of your coins. It sounds frustrating to not get the results you expect, and we value your input as it helps us improve. Please consider sharing more details at support@coins-scanner.app. Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Inaccurate

No matter how many different coins a show, the information they give is completely inaccurate. Dates are wrong and everything.

Response from developer

Hey! We appreciate your feedback and truly value your insights. It’s concerning to hear that the information provided has not met your expectations. We’re committed to improving accuracy and would love to hear more about your specific experiences. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Not accurate

Not accurate

Response from developer

Hello! We appreciate your feedback regarding the accuracy issues you've encountered. Your insights are valuable, and we take them seriously as we strive to improve. If you could share more details about your experience, it would help us better understand and address the concerns you've mentioned. Thank you! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Finally I found normal app

This app is truly a gem, even for me, an experienced collector! Honestly, I've seen many numismatic programs, but this one genuinely impressed me😃 Before, to confirm the identification of a rare coin or clarify pricing nuances, I had to cross-reference data across several thick catalogs that weren't always handy, or spend hours on specialized online auctions. It was incredibly time-consuming and often tiring.

🙌Now, everything is much simpler. All I need to do is scan the coin, and the app instantly provides not only basic information—year, mint, varieties—but, critically, up-to-date pricing data. And it's not just a single figure; it often gives a price range based on condition and rarity, which is invaluable for a collector. It's great that it even finds additional details and historical references, saving time on separate searches.

🙏Thanks to this app, the process of attributing and valuing my collection has become much faster and more efficient.

Of course, for ultra-rare coins or unique varieties, an expert's eye and consultation are still necessary, but for most tasks, this app handles 99% of it. It has become my go-to tool, always at my fingertips.
Show more

Response from developer

Hi Anastasia Adams621! We're deeply touched by your heartfelt message about our app's impact on you. Feedback like yours inspires us to continually improve and push the app to new heights. We're thrilled you're having a great experience and would be grateful if you could help spread the word by sharing our app with your loved ones. Sincerely yours, Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team

Best coin app

I'm absolutely thrilled
Before, I used to spend hours digging through reference books and forums, trying to identify a coin and understand its value. I'm very far from all these modern technologies))) but my son recommended this app to me. Now, all I need to do is scan the coin, and voilà! The app instantly provides all the necessary information and, most importantly for me, the estimated value. It's incredibly convenient! The interface is so simple that even a child can figure it out, and the scanning results are astonishingly accurate. Thanks to this app, my searches have become not only easier but much more engaging. I've already managed to identify several valuable specimens in my collection that I never even knew about before
Show more

Response from developer

Hi Chriisss89! Thank you for sharing what our app means to you. These are the types of messages that motivate us to keep on striving to make the app the best it can be. We're so happy that you are enjoying our app. We hope that you will continue to support us by sharing our app with your friends and family. Sincerely yours, Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team