👍
I like this app because I learned new stuff and I can sell it too
Wrong coin ID
You quoted me for a coin which not only was not the one I pictured it was a different year and country, and metal. Scam!
Miss the mark
Some of the coins that I scanned the picture didn’t come out well and the reading was wrong
Sort of works..
I use it to get a general idea of the value of quite a few gold coins I inherited, and it works….. sometimes. It’s about 50/50 whether it accurately identifies the coin and melt values are always wrong but it does let me know if it’s rare or not. It seriously struggles with coins in protective casing even if they’re clearly visible with a thin protective layer only. It would have to improve a lot to get me to subscribe. I’ll continue to check on the app and revise my review if it improves over time. 👍👍
Show more
Response from developer
Hi! Thank you for sharing your experience! We appreciate your feedback on the app's performance with gold coins and its challenges with protective casings. Your insights are invaluable as we strive to enhance accuracy. We're glad it helps identify rarity, and we hope to earn your trust in the future! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team
The app doesn’t recognize all coins.
I took a picture of my coin and It’s pulling up a different coin.
Not reliable
This app is not reliable. Every time I scan a coin I get off something went wrong. Come back later. Then when it does identify a coin, it gives you completely the wrong coin.
I’ve been able to match more through Google photos than I can through this app which I paid a year membership and I’m trying to cancel but it doesn’t work
I’ve been able to match more through Google photos than I can through this app which I paid a year membership and I’m trying to cancel but it doesn’t work
Show more
Response from developer
Hi! It's disappointing to hear about the issues you're facing with scanning coins. We appreciate your feedback on the app's reliability and the challenges with cancellation. Your experience matters to us, and we’re looking into this. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Coin & Value Identifier - Coinly Support Team
I like this app
Honestly for identification and quick valuations this thing is perfect. I inherited a bunch of coins from my grandfather and had no clue what I was looking at. This app is a game changer!
Found out I had a 1943 wheat penny that’s actually worth something!
Now I scan everything that comes to hand, hoping to find something else valuable:)
Found out I had a 1943 wheat penny that’s actually worth something!
Now I scan everything that comes to hand, hoping to find something else valuable:)
Show more
Fake
Scam all around- this app is identifying 1972 coins as silver. Tried to complain but the feedback button says unavailable. Of course! But the favorable review button works, hmmmm.
Don’t buy
Waste of money. I’ve got 3 quarters I’ve tried to value multiple times. The dates on the quarters are 1965, 1966, and 1969. Every single result showed me value for quarters from 1942-1964. All of my coins are after 1964 so it’s given me zero helpful information and it cost me 7 bucks. Thanks for nothing.
Show more
Great scanning
Quick and clean 😭
Canceling membership
My membership has been cancelled for awhile. Welp they just charged my card for 0 reason. This service is numnuts
New but good app
This app isn’t better than searching up your coin on the internet. Has tons of trip ups with the small details so maybe integrate some human interaction like manually putting in the year so you don’t have to keep redoing the analysis for the correct
year.
year.
Inaccurate
No matter how many different coins a show, the information they give is completely inaccurate. Dates are wrong and everything.
Not accurate
Not accurate
Finally I found normal app
This app is truly a gem, even for me, an experienced collector! Honestly, I've seen many numismatic programs, but this one genuinely impressed me😃 Before, to confirm the identification of a rare coin or clarify pricing nuances, I had to cross-reference data across several thick catalogs that weren't always handy, or spend hours on specialized online auctions. It was incredibly time-consuming and often tiring.
🙌Now, everything is much simpler. All I need to do is scan the coin, and the app instantly provides not only basic information—year, mint, varieties—but, critically, up-to-date pricing data. And it's not just a single figure; it often gives a price range based on condition and rarity, which is invaluable for a collector. It's great that it even finds additional details and historical references, saving time on separate searches.
🙏Thanks to this app, the process of attributing and valuing my collection has become much faster and more efficient.
Of course, for ultra-rare coins or unique varieties, an expert's eye and consultation are still necessary, but for most tasks, this app handles 99% of it. It has become my go-to tool, always at my fingertips.
🙌Now, everything is much simpler. All I need to do is scan the coin, and the app instantly provides not only basic information—year, mint, varieties—but, critically, up-to-date pricing data. And it's not just a single figure; it often gives a price range based on condition and rarity, which is invaluable for a collector. It's great that it even finds additional details and historical references, saving time on separate searches.
🙏Thanks to this app, the process of attributing and valuing my collection has become much faster and more efficient.
Of course, for ultra-rare coins or unique varieties, an expert's eye and consultation are still necessary, but for most tasks, this app handles 99% of it. It has become my go-to tool, always at my fingertips.
Show more
Best coin app
I'm absolutely thrilled
Before, I used to spend hours digging through reference books and forums, trying to identify a coin and understand its value. I'm very far from all these modern technologies))) but my son recommended this app to me. Now, all I need to do is scan the coin, and voilà! The app instantly provides all the necessary information and, most importantly for me, the estimated value. It's incredibly convenient! The interface is so simple that even a child can figure it out, and the scanning results are astonishingly accurate. Thanks to this app, my searches have become not only easier but much more engaging. I've already managed to identify several valuable specimens in my collection that I never even knew about before
Before, I used to spend hours digging through reference books and forums, trying to identify a coin and understand its value. I'm very far from all these modern technologies))) but my son recommended this app to me. Now, all I need to do is scan the coin, and voilà! The app instantly provides all the necessary information and, most importantly for me, the estimated value. It's incredibly convenient! The interface is so simple that even a child can figure it out, and the scanning results are astonishingly accurate. Thanks to this app, my searches have become not only easier but much more engaging. I've already managed to identify several valuable specimens in my collection that I never even knew about before
Show more
