Decent Potential , Terrible Execution - Not Ready For Release
The game has tremendous potential, but its presentation suggests a level of functionality that simply does not exist. At this point, I genuinely question whether this game was ready to be released to the App Store.
1. Character Customization – 2/10
The character customization is extremely limited. Players cannot customize their coach’s appearance, facial features, height, or any other physical characteristics. The only available customization appears to be changing the character’s name.
Calling this character customization is misleading. There is virtually no customization involved.
2. Gameplay – 1/10
The gameplay is one of the biggest disappointments. It lacks realism, defensive responsiveness, and consistency.
Tackling mechanics are particularly problematic. Players can gain significant yardage despite multiple defenders being within tackling distance. There are situations where five defenders can surround a ball carrier, yet the player continues gaining yards as if the defenders are barely interacting with them.
This creates an unrealistic offensive environment where nearly every game becomes a high-scoring affair. There is very little defensive dominance, and shutting down an opposing offense feels unnecessarily difficult.
Additionally, passing mechanics are inconsistent, with an excessive number of incompletions and situations where catches and defensive interactions simply do not make sense.
A college football simulation should provide opportunities to win through defensive strategy, offensive execution, and realistic football mechanics. Unfortunately, the current gameplay does not deliver that experience.
3. Recruiting System – Extremely Disappointing
This is arguably the most frustrating aspect of the entire game.
The recruiting system presents multiple stages:
• Discovery
• Finding and evaluating prospects
• Building interest through pitches
• Closing and securing commitments
However, the system appears to become dysfunctional once prospects reach the pitch stage. Even after accumulating 100 points, there seems to be no reliable way to close recruits and secure commitments.
I played two full seasons attempting to understand and navigate this system. Despite investing considerable time and effort, I could not consistently recruit players or build my program.
The transfer portal is another major issue. When attempting to acquire players, I receive messages indicating that I cannot sign them. This defeats the entire purpose of having a transfer portal.
Why include recruiting stages and transfer portal functionality if players cannot reliably use them?
There is also an extremely confusing issue with the recruiting board. At the beginning of the season, players apparently have to create or add a recruit before additional recruiting prospects become visible. This is something that should be clearly explained. Players should not have to spend several weeks wondering why their recruiting board is empty before discovering an unintuitive workaround.
4. Program Development, NIL, and Finances
The program development system feels extremely restrictive, especially for smaller schools.
Playing at a smaller university should provide an opportunity to build a program from the ground up. That is one of the most appealing aspects of college football simulations.
However, NIL funding, alumni support, business partnerships, and fundraising appear to provide very little meaningful progression.
I experienced situations where NIL funding was extremely limited despite having a successful season. Even after taking Western Michigan to a 10-3 record and earning a ranking of No. 18, there was little indication that my program’s success translated into meaningful financial support or recruiting improvements.
It makes little sense to reward players with the opportunity to build a successful program while providing so few effective ways to actually develop that program.
5. Coaching Carousel and Career Progression
This is my single biggest frustration with the game.
There appears to be no meaningful way to change schools or advance your coaching career.
Once you accept a coaching position, you essentially become locked into that school. There is no satisfying coaching carousel, no meaningful opportunity to explore other programs, and seemingly no realistic career progression.
For example, I coached Western Michigan and finished a season with a 10-3 record after reaching the College Football Playoff. Despite that accomplishment, I received no meaningful coaching opportunities or offers from other programs.
Not even an opportunity to explore another school?
That completely undermines the appeal of a college football dynasty experience.
One of the most exciting aspects of college football is building your coaching career, starting at a smaller program, developing your reputation, and eventually earning opportunities at larger universities.
Why include a coaching career structure if players cannot meaningfully progress through it?
I should not feel permanently trapped at one school, especially after achieving legitimate success.
6. Offensive Schemes and Playbooks
Another disappointing limitation is the inability to properly select your offensive scheme or preferred playbook.
This is a fundamental component of football strategy. Coaches should have the ability to establish their own offensive identity, choose their preferred system, and build their roster around that philosophy.
The inability to meaningfully control these deci
Response from developer
Jackson, thank you for investing two seasons in the game and taking the time to explain your experience. I’m sorry recruiting, transfers and the on-field action left you frustrated. One clarification about coaching progression: the dynasty experience was designed around developing your selected school over multiple seasons. A personal coaching career with job offers to move between schools wasn’t part of that design. We recognize that the “coaching carousel” wording could make that distinction unclear, as it was intended for the assistant coaches on your individual dynasty. Having said that we are making a note of it and we will add it to the upcoming release (see more below). Recruiting, transfers, NIL management and building your program are core parts of the game, and the problems you describe deserve attention. We’re currently rebuilding the game engine for an updated version designed to run entirely on your device, with online access only for imports and exports. Addressing the recruiting, transfer, gameplay consistency and program-development issues you raised is a priority for that update. If you’re willing, please send your season/week and a screenshot of the blocked transfer message to support@gridironaction.com. That will help us investigate your specific experience. Thank you for the detailed feedback and for recognizing the game’s potential.













