Way too inaccurate
Needs one more thing
Can't help but wonder, though--why aren't calories included? I hate having to pay for yet another subscription or go back and forth finding the calories on google. I mean, would it be that much more trouble to include calories in the breakdown? This would be especially helpful for diebetics.
Fast food options
Response from developer
Thank you — hearing this from a nephrology NP means a lot. Great news: fast food already works well with the photo scan and the "Say or Type" quick log (e.g. type "Taco Bell bean burrito" and it scores it against the user's kidney profile). Even better: we're currently testing a menu-scanning mode — photograph a restaurant menu or menu board and get a ranked list of the kidney-safest options for that person's stage. Your point about cost/energy constraints is exactly who we're building it for. We'd genuinely value clinician input — please reach out at support@kidneypal.app
Frustrated
Response from developer
We're sorry that experience isn't what we intended, and your feedback is helping us fix it. To explain what happened: the free plan includes 5 AI food analyses per day (they reset at midnight). Once they're used up, the photo/describe buttons show the upgrade screen — but you never have to accept the trial. You can close it with the X, and you can always log food for free using Manual entry, Saved foods, or Recipes from the + button. We agree the app should say this clearly instead of just showing the upgrade screen, and we're improving that in an upcoming update. We'd love for you to give it another try — support@kidneypal.app if we can help
Make serving sizes adjustable on recipes?
I am only one person. Right now I have to get out my calculator and split ingredients to make one serving. Or figure out what to do with a second (or third and fourth) serving of the recipe, some of which don’t reheat well. I really don’t want to eat 4 servings of something.
Response from developer
Thank you for the thoughtful suggestion! You're right — today the "Servings to Eat" adjuster on a recipe scales the nutrition numbers, but the ingredient list stays fixed at the full-recipe amounts. Automatically scaling ingredient quantities (so a 4-serving recipe shows amounts for 1) is a great idea and it's now on our roadmap — the way we store recipes makes this very doable. Keep an eye on upcoming updates, and if you have more ideas we'd love to hear them at support@kidneypal.app
78 yr old. CKD stage 4
Response from developer
Thank you so much for the kind words — reviews like yours are exactly why we built KidneyPal. We're glad it's helping you stay within your guidelines, and we hope your next labs show it. Wishing you the very best with your health, and if you ever need anything, we're at support@kidneypal.app
Works Well
Response from developer
Thank you for updating your review and for the detailed feedback! You were right about that streak alert — it was a real bug where the 8:30 PM reminder fired even on days you'd already logged. The version you're on now (4.21) fixes it: logging anything silences that day's reminder automatically, so it's safe to turn notifications back on. If it ever misfires again, email us at support@kidneypal.app and we'll jump on it. And your suggestions are good ones — categories for saved foods and showing the quantity field above the nutrient labels are both on our list. Thanks for helping make KidneyPal better!
don't believe everything you see
To evaluate the app, I intentionally created a hypothetical day built around foods that are generally considered kidney-conscious choices, including scallops, rice, asparagus, green leaf salad, fruit, cream of wheat, and small amounts of cheese.
The results were discouraging and didn’t seem practical. The app reported that I was already over or very close to my phosphorus limit while simultaneously showing that I was nowhere near my protein goal. In my case, I was still less than halfway to the protein target despite using most of my phosphorus budget.
That left me with a basic question the app could not answer: How am I supposed to reach the recommended protein goal without exceeding the phosphorus goal?
I also found another review reporting that the kidney burden scoring had become overly aggressive. The developer responded and acknowledged that a recent update had made the scoring algorithm too strict. Based on my experience, the issue may still not be fully resolved.
The nutrient tracking may still be useful, but the overall scoring and recommendations did not feel realistic for someone actually trying to build a sustainable kidney-friendly diet. Instead of helping me make better food choices, the app left me feeling that almost every reasonable meal was a problem.
The concept is excellent, but the recommendations need to be more practical and transparent, especially when balancing phosphorus restrictions against protein requirements.
Response from developer
Thank you for such a thoughtful review — you've hit on the hardest real tension in renal nutrition, and you deserve a real answer. The squeeze you describe isn't a calculation error: nearly all protein foods carry phosphorus, and some "kidney-conscious" picks are deceptively costly — scallops run ~15mg of phosphorus per gram of protein (plus high natural sodium), and cheese ~20+. Renal dietitians resolve this with the phosphorus-to-protein ratio: egg whites (~1.5), chicken breast or cod (~6), and turkey (~7) reach your protein goal with roughly half the phosphorus. Additive phosphorus ("PHOS" on ingredient lists) effectively counts double — it's ~100% absorbed vs ~50% for natural sources. You were right that the app should have taught you this, so we've just shipped that: meal analysis and chat now explain the ratio and suggest protein swaps that preserve your protein target instead of just flagging phosphorus. Scoring is also fully deterministic now — each score shows which nutrient drove it against your personal daily limits. We'd genuinely value your take if you try it again: support@kidneypal.app
Editing
Response from developer
Thanks for 50 days of logging—that's commitment! To answer your questions: phosphorus, magnesium, and vitamin K estimates come from our AI, which draws on nutritional research since these often aren't on labels. You can edit identified foods by tapping on them after analysis. As for the streak notification, this is a notification bug we are working to resolve. Please email us at support@kidneypal.app with any other issues or feedback you have
Concerned
Response from developer
This is exactly why we built KidneyPal—to help people feel like they can do this. A new diagnosis is overwhelming, but you've got this. Thank you for sharing.
Not a good experience
Response from developer
Thank you for the honest feedback — the interface compliment means a lot, and your criticisms were fair. A lot has shipped since your review. There's now a Help chat inside the app (Settings → Help) that answers "how do I…" questions instantly, right when you need it — no email round-trip — plus a full written guide at kidneypal.app/guide. On nutrient counts: only the Manual option asks you to type nutrients in yourself, and it's now clearly labeled that way — Scan (photo), Quick Log (voice or text), barcode, and label scanning all calculate the complete breakdown for you automatically, and you can review and edit anything before it's logged. Voice logging has also had accuracy improvements in recent updates. If you're willing to update the app and give it another look, we'd love to hear how it goes — support@kidneypal.app reaches the team directly.
Great all
Response from developer
Thank you so much for the feedback and we are glad you find KidneyPal useful
Not “the” app
Response from developer
Sounds like you might have accidentally used the manual entry, which is for manually entering every nutrient yourself in the rare cases that might needed. If you want automatic estimates for your log entries you should use the main top two log choices of photo scan and text/speech logging.
Great scanner: accurate and I love this app!
Wonderful App!
Response from developer
Thank you so much for the feedback! If you have any issues you can write us at support@kidneypal.app
Kept being asked to sign up
Response from developer
Hi this sounds like a bug we have since fixed, please email us at support@kidneypal.app and we will help you get set up
Calorie
Response from developer
Hi there, There is a calorie counter inside the app, you can enable it in the settings screen.
Personalization
Response from developer
That's a great point—not everyone with CKD needs to limit the same nutrients. We're looking into adding more customization so you can adjust or turn off specific limits based on your labs. Thanks for the feedback!
Yay!
Response from developer
Yay! Thanks for the kind words.
New User
Response from developer
Thanks for exploring! We're here if you need anything.
