Fantastic support
Downgrade of all downgrades
• n/a
BAD:
• Unintuitive symbols panel eats up 1/4th of the screen, didn’t realize I could compact it until I tapped what I thought was a back button.
• The positioning of icons, toolbars, etc eats up more screen space than a reference-heavy app should allow.
• The more “modernized” look maybe upgraded the visuals from 2000 to 2004?
UGLY:
• No more mode switching. One finger marks stitches, two fingers pans. This should be an option to enable this, it makes navigating the app more prone to accidental-marks. Half of why I have this app is for reference while traveling and this is so unintuitive for people on the go especially.
• No dedicated preview mode. The preview is a step back into the project setup wizard, back and next buttons and all. This feels so lazy. If you tap out of the project and return to it, while in preview, you re-enter the setup wizard.
• Annual subscription and still no built-in cloud backup, just updates nobody needed.
This is the last subscription I’ll have for this app. The developers should have taken advantage of TestFlight and beta access, so that users could opt-in to test changes and provide feedback on the series of poor decisions this app has become. Sorry for any hurt feelings, but I want the old app back.
Response from developer
A few of the points you’ve raised are actually already supported in the new version, but the controls have moved, which I appreciate isn’t immediately obvious when you were familiar with the old app. The Symbol List can be collapsed using the arrow in the top right, so it doesn’t need to occupy that much of the screen while you stitch. One of the aims of the redesign was actually to give more space back to the chart rather than permanently filling the screen with buttons. See this video for details https://youtu.be/9uZBHXxIJGY You also don’t have to use two fingers to move around. Tap the magnifying glass so it turns red and you can pan around the chart with one finger without accidentally marking stitches. This video explains the navigation: https://youtu.be/aFLSt9GSJJM Preview is also still available while stitching. Tap the text area in the top toolbar and you can switch between the chart, Preview, Unmarked and your different layers. The separate Chart Preview step in the Project Wizard exists so you can review the finished setup and then move backwards if anything needs correcting. The Project Wizard itself is intentional. Previously, setup functions were largely crammed onto the Markup tab. They are now separated into individual steps so grids, symbols, colours and other setup information can be adjusted without accidentally changing them while stitching. See this link https://help.markuprxp.co.uk/help/wizardtour/ This link is specifically for users moving from the old version: https://markuprxp.co.uk/new-starters/ The app was also tested extensively with our tester group before release, and much of the new version is based on feedback collected from users over several years. Automatic cloud syncing isn’t available yet, although projects can already be backed up and moved between devices using RXP exports, and automatic syncing is something we are investigating. Unfortunately, the old app cannot be brought back. The development platform it was built on was retired, which is why Markup had to be rebuilt in the first place. I think a lot of what feels unintuitive here is familiarity with the previous version rather than functionality having disappeared. We’ve had a few long term users feel exactly the same initially, then come back once the new flow clicked and tell us how much better and more flexible they find it. Any time invested in getting familiar with the new app should pay dividends in improving the enjoyment you get from your cross stitching hobby. Thanks, James








