MTG Guide Reviews: Is It Legit?

Customer Experience

Positive experience78.5% of reviews
Neutral2.3% of reviews
Negative experience19.3% of reviews

~ Based on 353 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say about MTG Guide

Is MTG Guide Safe?

MTG Guide appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for MTG Guide is 92/100.

This assessment is based on 729 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.6/5.

Safety Analysis

91.2% of ratings point to a safe experience
1.0% of ratings suggest some concerns
7.8% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 728 App Store ratings for MTG Guide.

Is MTG Guide Legit?

MTG Guide appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for MTG Guide is 95/100.

Based on 95 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Bait and switch

As someone who bought this app as a judge resource years ago I was happy to support the dev. But now switching to a subscription model and giving a middle finger to those that bought the app is incredibly scummy.

Scam

Purchased this app more than 5 years ago for $6.99. Im not paying a subscription now. You should not be able to change your app from purchase based to subscription based.

Sold out to subscription Greed

I figured a full price paid would keep this app supported. API availability makes updating this minimal in cost. Forcing paid customers to adopt the same subscription as new people is insane on a greed level. They should have grandfathered original supporters. Now this will be yet another app that will die out.
Show more

Best rules and card rulings app, worth the subscription cost

While I can understand the frustrations of more recent reviewers RE: the recurring subscription, keeping an app and its database/content updated for 17 (!!!) years is no small feat, especially with how many sets wotc are releasing these days.

For me, paying a small yearly fee to ensure this app is kept up to date is a very small concession ESPECIALLY for how often I am pulling it out at game nights to look up cards, go over specific rules, etc.

It also doesn't have any other annoying "features" (read: clutter and useless slop) that so many other MTG-related apps are bloating themselves with.

It is extremely good at the thing you want it to do. Highly recommend, good job dev!
Show more

Ridiculous

Charging a subscription fee for basic features and information that is free and widely available is absolutely insane.

Downgrade!

From free use to subscription although I paid the app before. Very bad policy!

Response from developer

I'm sorry you feel this way. I want to be upfront about why it happened: maintaining the app means ongoing costs I didn't have years ago: database updates, server hosting, and keeping up with each new iOS release. I've been supporting this app for every new magic set for 17 years. Paid-up-front sales weren't covering those costs anymore, so the choice was subscription or shutting it down. The core app you originally bought still works, and the subscription only gates the features that have ongoing costs behind them. I appreciate you having supported the app early on, and I'm sorry this change has soured the experience.

Great app for judging

Same as title.

Subscription Fees

Changed to a subscription fee set up and removed features for people who had already paid for those features. And it wasn’t a cheap app either.

Subscription fatigue

This isn’t really something that needs a subscription? Previously paid for all features to be unlocked, and now dev wants a monthly payment to get them back. I’ll be moving to ManaBox as a free alternative.

Charges customers who already purchased

It's not right to now charge players who previously bought this app. Very poor business practice. I don't recommend this app anymore.

1-star

My reading of one star does not reflect the usability and functionality of the app. It reflects the way the app makes me feel.

Having used this app for over a decade, it is a bit upsetting to have the sudden switch to a subscription.

It was Awesome… now they took away functionality on a laid app!

Paid for the app, they updated with a subscription and TOOK AWAY functionality of the previously paid app!!! I paid for the app… it worked great!… then they took away things they sold me!

Gekauft und nun Abo

Absoluter Betrug. Als Vollversion gekauft und jetzt soll es plötzlich ein abartig teures Abo sein? Was soll der Quatsch?

Greedy Scam

Purchased App years ago and no new features have been added. All information on here is scraped off of Gatherer.c om. Nothing new is provided by the app. And now they want to charge you a subscription fee after paying in full for that app, or they won’t “update” it with new cards a rules. No work is done on their end. It’s just a copy paste of the rules. Total scam. They should shut this app down and start a new one, but they know no one will use the new one if they have to pay a second time. Scummy tech people, finding a way to charge you to use an app you bought in full years ago.
Show more

Premium app no more

Paid for this app quite a few years back with the expectation it would be supported for the price I paid. Instead the dev wants to charge for information Wizards makes available for free and other apps make available for free. Bye!

Now Paywalled.

Moved to subscription, now not usable after purchasing the app. Terrible.

Response from developer

I'm sorry you feel this way. I want to be upfront about why it happened: maintaining the app means ongoing costs I didn't have years ago: database updates, server hosting, and keeping up with each new iOS release. I've been supporting this app for every new magic set for 17 years. Paid-up-front sales weren't covering those costs anymore, so the choice was subscription or shutting it down. The core app you originally bought still works, and the subscription only gates the features that have ongoing costs behind them. I appreciate you having supported the app early on, and I'm sorry this change has soured the experience.

Awesome MTG app!

All in one MTG resource for card info, rules, IPG, and others!

Requires subscription for core features after you bought it

The features of the app itself are totally fine, so I bought it a while ago as a convenience tool, even though all of its Information can easily be accessed, via a google search. But now it locks information about cards from new sets behind a subscription, which makes it useless for me. I am fine with offline card images being a premium Feature, as downloading images is costly for servers, but updating a copy of the scryfall database is something extremely cheap that even I can do.

I recommend just using scryfall.com for the card iformation and the online available comprehensive Rules.
Show more

Do not buy! SCAM!!

App functionality was removed after full payment and now requiring a subscription. Scam!!

Best Magic App for Rules and Judges

Easy access to all cards, errata, rulings, comprehensive rules, and everything. You name it, this app has it. It’s not there for collating your collection or deck building, but for those interested in the nuts and bolts and details of the game, there’s nothing like it!