Smith Brothers Reviews: Is It Legit?

Customer Experience

Positive experience68.8% of reviews
Neutral12.5% of reviews
Negative experience18.8% of reviews

~ Based on 32 written reviews from the US App Store.

What users say about Smith Brothers

Is Smith Brothers Safe?

Smith Brothers appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Smith Brothers is 89/100.

This assessment is based on 177 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.6/5.

Safety Analysis

88.5% of ratings point to a safe experience
4.0% of ratings suggest some concerns
7.5% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 174 App Store ratings for Smith Brothers.

Is Smith Brothers Legit?

Smith Brothers appears to be a legitimate app. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Smith Brothers is 88/100.

Based on 88 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Need fewer app update

Cannot understand why I have to update the app every time I want to do an order or check something in the app.

Otherwise it is well-organized content. Ingredients lists are good.

App getting worse

Love the service, but the app is painful! Every update to this app makes it even more difficult and time consuming to make even a few choices. Please go back to earlier more user friendly versions.

Love Smith Brothers!

The app is so convenient to use and very user friendly. I look forward to getting my delivery every week. Their products are quality and always fresh. Highly recommend!

Good Products, Bad App

Smith Brothers products are great, their dairy product are much higher quality compared to our local grocery stores.

Unfortunately we find the app very frustrating. We only ever want delivery every other week and more often than not if we make a change to our order the schedule gets messed up and we revive order on our off week resulting in delivery fees.
Show more

Excellent app, excellent service

Many of us shop at multiple stores- staples from QFC, meats from PCC, seafood and produce at Whole Foods. But still, I forget items or change my menu plans or run out of things. It’s so handy to know we have a regular weekly delivery time. Also, I run out of refrigerator room sometimes and rely on that Friday delivery for weekend provisions- especially for houseguests arriving. My one complaint is that their milk, cream, and half and half go bad quickly! when I first brought that to their attention, I received a lecture on how to store milk. I’ve been storing dairy products successfully for over 50 years, so their advice didn’t help! Possibly their products are not ultra pasteurized….? ironic for a milkman, eh?
Show more

Excellent app, excellent service

Very helpful app for my weekly shopping. I only wish the search function could handle a misspelled word or make better guesses with my typos.

Perfect time saver.

Free delivery for staple quality products and reasonable prices.

Milkman

Our milkman Kris is awesome. His super cool personality and amazing worker. My dog waits for him every everyday Friday morning at the front door. Thank you Kris for making my dog happy and also updating me about smith brothers online special items. The logo is really cool too. We look forward to ordering more in the future.
Show more

No more running to the store for eggs that are all out of stick or over priced.

Over the moon happy for our orders since December. Milk and cheese are always fresh and meats are always wrapped as to not contaminate anything else in the box! Highly satisfied and delighted with our service!

Great service, pretty good app

I really enjoy the ease of use for ordering products, and the customer service is really good. I have 1 major complaints with the app:
when you add a new product, it defaults to adding it as recurring order for every week.

Overall just okay

Overall just okay - not as convenient as the prior version of the app. The current app cuts off order changes half way through the day prior to delivery. The older app cut off orders in the evening the day before delivery. Another difference is the updated app increased the minimum order by 50%.

Does what it’s gotta do!

Good app to get your milk. it’d be even more cooler if they had a fun little tracker of when your milk would get to the door 😋🥛 thanks smith brothers for the yummiest dairy!!

Not getting notifications

Hi Team,
I’m not getting notifications after updating my phone to iOS 17. Please take a look.

I’ve “allow notifications” turned ON. And also I tried removing and reinstalling the app. It still didn’t fix the problem.

Give me a reminder before 2PM

This is the third week I’ve missed updating my milk order, because you shut off order changes after 2PM on Tuesday. Send a push notification at 1PM, “Last call for milk changes”. I now have three half gallon Half-N-Half’s in my fridge.

I am begging. Give me a reminder.

Pointless

This app doesn't do anything more or anything different than a web browser. Because it is a plain old Safari wrapper. The only difference, is the addition of notifications; a feature that I do NOT appreciate. Thats what emails are for!

I love Smith Bros!

I love getting milk and essentials delivered every week, with easy changes and updates via the app! It feels great to support local farmers and businesses. I like to browse the new offerings every week and pick out small treats to my order. Would give 10 stars if I could!

Frustrating app

Unable to delete items from weekly order. Frustrating and I just go to website instead.

Phone sized on iPad

App might be great. I do not like apps that are hard-coded for phone and render as a small phone-sized rectangle in on iPad.

Does exactly what it needs to

This app does exactly what it needs to do. There’s nothing extra in it, no waste. It’s easy to use. The alerts when your delivery arrives are handy too.

Notifications don’t show up in Notifications

Notifications do not show up in Notifications: banners, home screen, or lock screen. Notifications only show up in app. I have to manually set reminders in Reminders.