Sorted Reviews: Is It Legit?

Customer Experience

Positive experience20.6% of reviews
Neutral19.8% of reviews
Negative experience59.5% of reviews

~ Based on 126 written reviews from the US App Store.

Is Sorted Safe?

Sorted: TCG Collection Manager appears safe based on user ratings. AppsHunter Safety Score for Sorted is 86/100.

This assessment is based on 798 user ratings, with an App Store average of 4.3/5.

Safety Analysis

80.6% of ratings point to a safe experience
5.8% of ratings suggest some concerns
13.6% of ratings point to a risky experience

~ Based on 758 App Store ratings for Sorted.

Is Sorted Legit?

Sorted: TCG Collection Manager appears legitimate, with a few gaps. AppsHunter Legitimacy Score for Sorted is 63/100.

Based on 63 of 100 points across 7 verification signals from App Store and developer data.

Top reviews

Gut gewählt aber etwas irreführend

Gute App um seine TCG Karten zu verwalten

Response from developer

Hey Anonymy27.1! Thanks for the kind words and for using Sorted. We appreciate your support!

Bulk is back and broken

Bulk scanning “works” you really can scan more than 1 card at a time but by some arbitrary number of cards or amount of time an add will appear in the middle and completely delete all the cards you tried to scan in bulk. Making it actually take longer than just putting the cards in or following the old format of getting an ad when you went to save the cards
Show more

Why?

Well, it doesn’t have the complete Pokémon card collection like dragon shield did. In dragon shield we had every single card, this “Sorted” only seems to have some of the cards not all of the Pokemon cards please fix it. And what I mean by that is I can search “vstar” on dragon shield and hundreds maybe even thousands of different cards will come up. But when I search “vstar” on sorted exactly 38 cards come up. So that’s what I mean. If this could be fixed PLEASE DO IT. Btw it’s not just Vstar cards it a lot of the cards.
Show more

Response from developer

Hi there! Thanks for the feedback. The card catalogue should be the same between the two apps, and we're always working towards having it as up to date as possible with new releases. We are also currently in the process of adding all Japanese expansions to both apps. We'd love to know which cards you found to be missing - could you reach out through support@tcgsorted.com to give us some more information?

Could be the best Scanner

After switching over from DragonShield with major reservations, I must say once everything runs without bugs, the App has the potential to be the best Scanner for people who both play and collect TCGs.

I hope the makers continue listening to the community on Discord, so that we can smash the bugs one after another.

And most importantly, please add the option to share ones collection with the „outside world“ via a link or something similar.

Thanks and Cheers,
JensTheGatherer
Show more

Response from developer

Hey JensTheGatherer, thanks for the support! It’s great to hear the scanner is working smoothly for you. Sharing collections through a link is a valuable suggestion, and we appreciate you bringing it up. Keep the ideas coming here and on Discord - your feedback matters.

Massive downgrade

No bulk scan features makes this app unusable. Fix it ASAP

Great Concept, Terrible Deck Import Experience

I really wanted to like this app. The concept of managing and tracking my Magic: The Gathering collection in one place is fantastic, but the execution leaves a lot to be desired.

My biggest frustration is the deck import feature. I spent considerable time attempting to import a 100-card Commander deck using multiple file formats, including CSV and MTGGoldfish. Every attempt failed with vague error messages and absolutely no useful explanation of what went wrong.

The ONLY time I successfully imported my cards was after manually scanning every single card into Dragon Shield first, then transferring everything over from there.

Think about that. I had to use an entirely different app, manually scan my collection, and then import it into Sorted just to accomplish something Sorted supposedly supports directly.

The whole point of importing a deck list is to SAVE TIME, not create extra work.

I even searched for examples of successful direct deck-file imports and couldn’t find a verified one.

I’m giving two stars because the app has potential, but advertised features need to actually work. Please fix the import system, provide clear formatting requirements, and replace the generic error messages with useful information.

I’d happily update my rating if these issues are addressed. Until then, the experience is more frustrating than useful.
Show more

Response from developer

Hey LonelyImperial, thanks for giving Sorted a try for your Magic collection! The failed imports and unclear errors sound frustrating. Please email support@tcgsorted.com with your deck file and error details so the team can investigate and help you out!

It’s just okay

Two Stars as the recognition of cards, especially flesh and Blood is not properly working anymore After 3 to 4 Scans. I understand that doing this App needs ppl to subscribe but by enforcing this with maximal Reduction of Card Scanning Results is more frustrating. Application also crashes quite often of you move cards in between different folders. At Decks the recognition of hero , Equipment and Standard cards also not working properly. Even when choosing a market place the App doesn’t Stick to cheapest card. Cheap is possibly better measured in total costs (including shipping) and Not the cheapest prize to be Found in the middle of nowhere.
Show more

Response from developer

Hey Craftfield! Thanks for taking the time to share such detailed feedback. Please email support@tcgsorted.com with a few examples, your device model, and app version so our team can investigate.

It’s good

I like it

Does the thing

Sorts your cards, can make folders, can search collection, keep real time data on price of collection, and the scanner works pretty well.

Still not as good as MTG Scanner

So this is a response review to the developer. They states that you can sort by color and what not. This is not good enough as a replacement for the MTG scanner app. You were able to sort by card type, creature type, color, and so forth all at the same time allowing you to find cards that fit what you need for your play style. Just simply sorting by color or type or Set is not good enough. Notice how I said OR and not AND? This doesn’t let you sort multiple types and what not at the same time like the MTG Scanner app did. That doesn’t help me when I want to search for cards that fit my deck options. If you are going to force us into this one size fits all app then bring over all the features too!
Show more

Response from developer

Hi Wickedninja8599, thanks for the detailed feedback. We understand how much those filters matter for deck building. You can filter your Magic cards by color, card type, format, rarity and more in Advanced Search (the sliders icon on the search screen). Those detailed filters are part of Sorted Premium, and if you had Premium on the MTG Scanner app, it should carry over to Sorted with the same account. If it didn't, email support@tcgsorted.com and we'll sort it out. We've also passed your feedback on deck-building filters to the team. If anything else from the MTG Scanner is missing for you, let us know there or on our Discord.

Love this app

Honestly this is one of my favorite apps, love it!

Looks cool but barely works on my phone

Interface freezes up when I try to view a binder. Have to quit the app completely. I can only view “all cards”.

So many crash I can’t use

I tried to create a folder and scan cards from a pack. Every time I go in the folder the app crashes. Every time I open the options it crashes. Unusable

Chur

Chicken banana

Cool app

Great app

The 5 second ad lock is TRASH

I’ll use literally every other app I can find instead of this one because of the five second ad locking. LOL what a joke.

Good scanning, but problems retrieving information

The scanning works well, but for some reason it doesn’t always retrieve the information. 30% of the time a card will have no price value and I’ll have to go somewhere else to look at the price. This doesn’t only happen for new cards it happens with old cards too.

Scanner

Please fix the recognition of lands, I hate scanning a land and having to search through all lands of that color by set starting from newest. Please make it so it matches set symbols or at least have a drop down tag to select the set symbols so it’s easier… I just want to map my decks and it takes hours to filter through the lands. Mass scan would be nice too if possible. Currently I’m considering scanning one land and just making it say how many of that color I have because the way I like to build my deck is hurting me for this app… I like all unique lands so if I do it properly I have to do that same long process for each.
Show more

Response from developer

Hi Needbetternicknamesystem, thanks for explaining your process. Unique lands are exactly the hard case! Good news: Bulk Scan is coming in an upcoming update. It lets you lock scanning to the set or sets you choose, so the scanner only matches printings from those sets instead of every land of that color. You'll also be able to scan card after card into one batch and add them all to a deck in one go. We've passed your idea about set-symbol matching on to the scanner team as well.

Downgraded to this?

Well the old MTG scanner may have had its quirks, but it had so many great additions and perks this app doesn’t have. Sure it’s great for tracking prices, but it lacks the amazing sorting and filtering the MTG scanner had. In the MTG scanner I could sort by colors, card types, sub-types, and so forth. It was amazing for deck building, but this has none of those filters at all. So for deck building this is useless. I hope they fix that issue and incorporate those filters and settings to this since they clearly are forcing everyone to move to this.
Show more

Scanner burns my hands

The scanner made my phone so hot after 1 min that it burned my hands. Unusable.