Comparison

Project Hymnal vs Hymnals 2

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

Project Hymnal

Access a vast collection of hymns and new songs, learn them offline with instrumentals and sheet music, and even contribute your own uploads. This non-profit app aims to make hymns accessible for learning and enjoyment.

Highlights
  • Offline hymn access
  • Learn new songs
  • Listen to instrumentals
  • View music sheets
  • Play guitar
  • Upload new hymns
  • Contribute to hymnal
Features
Read full description

Hymns are enjoyed in many places and in a variety of occasions. Sometimes, it seems like everyone has their own hymn books with different versions of the same hymns. Sometimes, somebody wants to sing a hymn but nobody knows how to sing or play it. Not anymore. Introducing Project Hymnal, the crowd-sourced hymnal. A hymnal where everyone can learn, everyone can contribute to, and everyone will love to use. You will now be able to have the most up-to-date versions of hymns and all the newest songs at your disposal—all offline. Learn a new song, listen to instrumentals, view music sheets, and play guitar all from your device. Any time, anywhere. And if you don't see a song? Upload it through the app. We'll review it and make it available for all our users. The purpose of this non-profit application is to make hymns available to learn, enjoy, and, eventually, personalize. If you own rights to a hymn that was uploaded by one of our users and do not want it in our system, please contact us and we will work with you.

About

Hymnals 2

Access a vast library of Roman Catholic hymnals on your iPad. Purchase popular editions like Gather and Worship through in-app purchases. Organize service lists, annotate pages, and search hymns with ease.

Highlights
  • Purchase popular hymnal editions
  • Create and manage service lists
  • Annotate hymn pages
  • Search hymns by title or number
  • Import PDFs
  • Cloud backup
  • Listen to audio samples
Features
Read full description

Hymnals is a remarkable app that brings all the elements of your favorite hymnal—and more—right to your iPad. The app is free – through it you can purchase the following best-selling Roman Catholic hymnals from GIA Publications, Inc. using an in-app purchase. ● Gather Fourth Edition – Pew, Choir, Keyboard, Guitar, Lead Sheet, C Instrument, B-flat Instrument, E-flat Instrument, Lectionary Psalms, and Melody & Keyboard ● Gather - Third Edition for Pew, Choir, Guitar, Keyboard, C Instrument, and B flat Instrument ● Worship - Fourth Edition for Pew, Choir, Guitar, Keyboard, C Instrument, and B flat Instrument ● Ritual Song - Second Edition for Pew, Choir, Guitar, Keyboard, C Instrument, and B flat Instrument ● Gelineau Lectionary Psalms ● Guimont Lectionary Psalms ● The Lyric Psalter ● One Lord, One Faith, One Baptism ● Cry Out with Joy ● Gather Comprehensive - Second Edition both Pew and Choir ● Lead Me, Guide Me - Second Edition Pew and Keyboard ● Oramos Cantando - We Pray In Song Pew ● More to come Hymnals offer the complete contents of your hymnal in a compact, lightweight form—no more dragging around multiple hymnals and service binders! The app is perfect for choir members or churchgoers. Swipe or tap to easily page through hymns, or create and manage your own Service Lists! The music and words are crystal clear. With Hymnals, you can: ● NEW - View pages side-by-side and take better annotations ● NEW - Swipe or tap left and right to turn pages within a hymn ● NEW - Use arrows to navigate from hymn forward and backward ● NEW - Duplicate hymn pages and reorder into any order ● NEW - Import PDFs from Google Drive and iCloud Files ● NEW - Create bookmarks for quick navigation from one hymn page to another ● NEW - Crop a PDF page ● Back up your hymnals, imported music, service list, and annotations to the cloud with your giamusic.com account. ● Works on iPhone ● Download your hymnal via in-app purchase ● Quickly search for hymns by title or hymn number ● Create your own service lists ● Share service lists with other Hymnals app users ● Arrange your service list and display it in song order ● Listen to audio samples if available (requires an Internet connection) ● Zoom in or out without blurring ● View hymns in both portrait or the wider landscape mode ● Easily toggle to full-screen mode to see the entire hymn page ● Turn pages with AirTurn and PageFlip Bluetooth pedals ● Annotate hymns easy editing tools The free app includes three sample hymns.

Screenshots

Project Hymnal4 screens
Hymnals 24 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is review sentiment: Project Hymnal at 60% against Hymnals 2's 0%. Project Hymnal also leads on rating (4.7 vs 1.7) and in-app purchases (none vs 10). On price, ads and device support there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Hymnals 2 sells 10 one-off in-app purchases. Project Hymnal asks for nothing beyond the download.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

Project Hymnal holds the better App Store score, 4.7 against 1.7. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: Project Hymnal has 63 ratings behind it against 10, so its average is the more settled of the two. Written reviews point the same way: 60% of Project Hymnal's written reviews are positive against 0% of Hymnals 2's.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

Project Hymnal ships an update every 3 weeks, Hymnals 2 every 4 months. The most recent releases landed on November 18, 2026 and November 17, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard7 real differences · 3 level
Project Hymnal versus Hymnals 2: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterProject HymnalHymnals 2
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.7 (63 ratings) — better1.7 (10 ratings)
Positive reviews60.0% of reviews — better0.0% of reviews
Number of ratings63 — better10
Update frequencyEvery 3 weeks — betterEvery 4 months
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNo — betterYes
MonetizationFree — betterFree with in-app purchases
DevicesiPhone, iPad, iPod — betteriPhone, iPad
Requires iOS15.5 — better17.0
Further details — not scored
Size187 MB94 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperSamuel LiuGIA Publications, Inc.

Customer experience

Project Hymnal

All ratings63 ratings
Positive88.9%
Neutral7.9%
Negative3.2%
Written reviews10 reviews
Positive60.0%
Neutral30.0%
Negative10.0%

Hymnals 2

All ratings10 ratings
Positive0.0%
Neutral10.0%
Negative90.0%
Written reviews10 reviews
Positive0.0%
Neutral10.0%
Negative90.0%

In-app purchases

None

Project Hymnal

No in-app purchases

10 purchases

Hymnals 2

One-time10
  • Voices Together SAMPLEFree
  • Gather Comprehensive Second$14.99
  • Gather Third Edition$15.99
Show 7 more
  • Devine Office Hymnal$24.99
  • Worship Fourth Edition Choir$27.99
  • Gather Third Edition Choir$27.99
  • Gather Fourth Choir$31.99
  • Guimont Lectionary Psalms$34.99
  • Gather Third Edition Keyboard$119.99
  • Gather Fourth Edition Keyboard$139.99

Questions

Is Project Hymnal free?
Project Hymnal is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is Hymnals 2 free?
Hymnals 2 is free to download, with in-app purchases available.
Which has better reviews, Project Hymnal or Hymnals 2?
Project Hymnal is rated higher. Project Hymnal averages 4.7 out of 5 from 63 ratings, while Hymnals 2 averages 1.7 from 10 ratings.
Do Project Hymnal or Hymnals 2 have ads?
Neither Project Hymnal nor Hymnals 2 shows ads.
Which is updated more often, Project Hymnal or Hymnals 2?
Project Hymnal ships an update every 3 weeks, and Hymnals 2 every 4 months. Most recently, Project Hymnal was updated on November 18, 2026 and Hymnals 2 on November 17, 2026.

Other comparisons