Aspen LiDA vs Preserved Killick
Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.
Aspen LiDA
Discover books, movies, and games from your library anywhere. Search the full catalog, including digital content, to find titles, place holds, and manage your loans.
- Search entire library catalog
- Discover books, movies, and games
- Access eContent
- Place holds on items
- Check due dates
- Renew eligible titles
Read full descriptionHide full description
Aspen LiDA allows you to explore your library on the go to find new books, movies, games, or your old favorites! Quickly search the entire catalog, including eContent, and place holds, check due dates and renew eligible titles.
Preserved Killick
Read full descriptionHide full description
Killick is the ultimate companion for readers of Patrick O’Brian’s celebrated Aubrey-Maturin series. Follow the voyages of Jack Aubrey and Stephen Maturin through interactive maps, historical locations, ships, characters, and events drawn from the novels. Whether you’re reading the series for the first time or returning for another circumnavigation, Killick helps bring O'Brian's the world of the Royal Navy during to life. Features include: • Interactive maps showing locations from the novels • Character profiles and relationships • Ships • Book-by-book exploration • Regular content updates and expansion to additional books Killick is designed for readers and enthusiasts who want to deepen their understanding of the people, places, and history behind one of the greatest historical fiction series ever written. Includes the Master and Commander Companion Guide. Additional companion guides for Post Captain, HMS Surprise, and The Mauritius Command are available as optional in-app purchases with more to come. DISCLAIMER Killick is an independent companion application created for readers of Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey–Maturin novels. This application is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Patrick O’Brian’s estate, his publishers, or any related rights holders. All book titles, character names, and related literary references remain the property of their respective copyright and trademark owners. Limited excerpts may be displayed for purposes of commentary, identification, literary reference, and educational discussion. All such excerpts remain the copyrighted property of their respective rights holders. This application is intended to enhance readers’ enjoyment and understanding of the novels through maps, historical context, and location-based reference material.
Screenshots
Verdict
The clearest difference is in-app purchases: Aspen LiDA at none against Preserved Killick's 3. Aspen LiDA also leads on iOS requirement (15.1 vs 26.0). On price, ads and device support there is nothing between them.
Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS
Both are free to download. Preserved Killick sells 3 one-off in-app purchases. Aspen LiDA asks for nothing beyond the download.
| Parameter | Aspen LiDA | Preserved Killick |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Rating | 1.4 (235 ratings) — better | — |
| Positive reviews | 9.2% of reviews | — |
| Number of ratings | 235 — better | — |
| Update frequency | Monthly | — |
| Ads | No | No |
| In-app purchases | No — better | Yes |
| Monetization | Free | — |
| Devices | iPhone, iPad, iPod — better | iPhone, iPad |
| Requires iOS | 15.1 — better | 26.0 |
| Further details — not scored | ||
| Size | 56 MB | 84 MB |
| Age rating | 4+ | 4+ |
| Developer | ByWater Solutions | 321 Technology LLC |
Bugs and requests
Aspen LiDA
Reported bugs
58 issues- App kicks users out
- App doesn't renew books with holds
- App doesn't renew all books even when Renew All is pressed
- App won't open, shows spinning wheel
- App freezes
Show 53 moreShow fewer
- App constantly doesn't load things
- App boots users out and won't allow reopening
- App requires re-login every time
- App loads perpetually
- App won't open, just sits on initial page spinning
- App won't open on modern phone
- App stops working, sits on first screen with spinner
- App logs out in the middle of use
- App doesn't respond when opened
- App crashes
- App won't open at all
- App doesn't recognize number or password
- App has no way of resetting or crashes
- App has a Server Connection Error
- App doesn't load
- App is super slow to load anything
- App is hard to search by genre
- App won't let users search for their library to log in
- App continually logs out
- App won't let users type account number or anything
- App freezes when trying to type library card number
- App doesn't recognize user/new card
- App says 'select library' and nothing happens when searching
- App won't load after update
- App requires signing in every day and is not functional
- App has glitches
- App automatically checks out magazines
- App logs users out and won't let them enter location before login
- App crashes and logs users out
- App cannot search for library
- App search bar shrinks when typing, results not visible
- App is logged out every 3rd time it's opened
- App won't open, stuck at 'SELECT YOUR LIBRARY'
- App doesn't show library name when typed
- App barely works and constantly crashes
- App is slow
- App crashes often
- App doesn't load pages
- App almost never lets users place a hold
- App crashes immediately on opening
- App doesn't retain account data
- App prompts for volume title when placing holds
- App spins and never completes holds
- App crashes all the time
- App crashes after an update
- App cannot find library using location or search
- App doesn't load discover categories
- App indicates a problem after crashing, requires re-entry of library card and PIN
- App doesn't save login info in iPhone password feature
- App doesn't function properly, ebook checkouts don't appear
- App spins and spins and never loads
- App is impossible to search
- App shows 'bad request' when trying to place a hold
Requested features
7 requests- Show position in hold queue
- Allow saving login information
- Implement facial/fingerprint recognition for login
- Improve search functionality for genres/topics
- Allow managing multiple library cards
Show 2 moreShow fewer
- Fix automatic magazine checkouts
- Improve discover categories loading
Preserved Killick
Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.
In-app purchases
Aspen LiDA
No in-app purchases
Preserved Killick
- Post Captain Companion Guide$1.99
- HMS Surprise Companion Guide$1.99
- The Mauritius Command Companion Gui$1.99
Questions
Is Aspen LiDA free?
Is Preserved Killick free?
Do Aspen LiDA or Preserved Killick have ads?
Other comparisons
