Comparison

SHIN理想記帳 vs 華南銀行+

Price, ratings, monetisation and update history for both apps, side by side — with what reviewers say about each.

Head to head
About

SHIN理想記帳

This finance app helps users manage their money through a unique proportional budgeting method, allowing them to allocate income into living, investment, and savings accounts. It also categorizes spending as 'wants' or 'needs' to promote smarter financial decisions and provides detailed reports.

Highlights
  • Proportional budgeting method
  • Allocate income to living, investment, savings
  • Categorize spending as 'wants' or 'needs'
  • Consumption analysis reports
  • Cloud automatic data upload
  • Customizable category icons
  • Daily journaling reminders
Features
Read full description

李勛 SHIN LI/新生代理財投資YouTuber 在沒有富爸爸和任何財經科系背景下,透過自行學習投資理財幸運地在25歲存到了第一桶金!將自己花心思整理的各式小資理財資訊製作成影片,在Youtube成功吸引了超過30萬人訂閱、累積4000萬次觀看。 李勛本次與台灣財經資訊龍頭公司CMoney合作,將自己獨家的記帳方法和理財思維產品化,開發了這款「Shin理想記帳」。 ––––功能特色介紹–––– 獨家1>>比例記帳法 理想記帳中的比例記帳法,是利用比例分配的方式,將每個月的收入按比例分配至「生活、投資、儲蓄」三種帳戶,並可以時時檢視各帳戶狀態,且能夠在帳戶間彼此轉帳。 能夠幫助使用者量入為出,在消費支出前就先將每個月的現金流妥善規劃,確實將財富穩定累積下來。 獨家2>>【想要/需要】報表 更在日常記帳中規劃了【想要/需要】標籤,幫助使用者在記帳時能夠思考消費目的,並能透過報表定期檢視消費細節,真正做到聰明消費。 ◆消費分析 統整整月消費狀況,幫你一眼抓出財務漏洞。 ◆雲端自動上傳資料 換手機、換平台、換版本,安全還原完整資料。 ◆帳務報表 詳盡多彩的報表,即時掌握收支狀況 ◆自訂分類icons 自由調整分類icon,多款可愛icon任你選 ◆記帳提醒 自訂每日提醒時間,系統自動提醒,不用再擔心金魚腦袋 ------- 希望透過ShinLi個人實證有效的理財記帳方法, 與你交朋友,陪伴你存下每一分夢想的基礎。 利用簡單的記帳流程,幫助你養成理財的好習慣 規劃三大帳戶讓你可以清楚看見財富的累積 協助你思考並清楚規劃每筆現金流的意義 搭配 ShinLi 總是第一手更新的各家銀行 信用卡&帳戶 優惠資訊 真正做到『聰明消費,輕鬆理財,理想記帳。』

About

華南銀行+

Manage your finances with this comprehensive banking app. Access account balances, transfer funds, pay credit card bills, invest in funds, and track gold savings. Find nearby branches and ATM locations, and enjoy secure login options.

Highlights
  • Account balance and transaction history
  • Fund transfers (real-time and scheduled)
  • Credit card management and payments
  • Investment portfolio tracking
  • Gold savings account management
  • Foreign exchange services
  • Branch and ATM locator
Features
Read full description

「華南銀行+」APP獨具特色 ※只要您是華南銀行網路銀行客戶,即可使用網路銀行簽入代號及密碼,登入「華南銀行+」APP。如您是第一次登入行動銀行,須線上完成第一次開通程序。 ※帳務查詢:臺幣/外幣存款餘額總覽、臺外幣活存明細查詢、交換票據扣帳失敗查詢、貸款餘額查詢、信用卡消費明細查詢等。 ※轉帳服務:臺幣即時/預約轉帳(包括約定/非約定)、預約轉帳查詢/取消、臺幣常用轉入帳號查詢/新增/修改、交易安控機制變更等。 ※信用卡服務:信用卡/簽帳金融卡總覽、近3期信用卡/簽帳金融卡帳單查詢、線上繳付本行信用卡/簽帳金融卡費、信用卡紅利折現兌換/查詢等、線上申請信用卡、信用卡線上調額、信用卡分期服務。 ※信託理財:投資組合淨值查詢、基金申購/贖回/轉換/變更/解除交易、基金投資總覽、基金投資明細等、優利通、目標理財帳戶、圓夢錢包。 ※黃金存摺:黃金總覽、餘額/交易明細查詢、買進/回售、定期定額申購/變更/終止等。 ※外匯專區:結購/結售、外匯活存轉帳/活存轉定存、購買外幣現鈔暨旅行支票、外匯定存查詢暨變更等。 ※多元理財資訊:國際股匯市/台灣股市/各類基金資訊查詢、利率/匯率看板、黃金存摺牌告、貸款本息試算等,提供隨身理財資訊。 ※客戶服務:結合GPS定位,隨時隨地查詢臨近信用卡特店優惠,也提供臨近分行及ATM據點查詢。 ※快速登入專區 ※華銀支付 ※ APP使用權限說明 1. 麥克風:APP網路客服音訊功能需使用該權限。 2. 位置:使用服務據點功能需使用該權限。 3. 相機:使用華銀支付掃描 QRCode 功能需使用該權限。 4. 照片:使用華銀支付及儲存存摺封面功能需使用該權限。 5. 語音辨識:APP網路客服文字將語音轉為文字顯示在畫面上需使用該權限。 6. 生物辨識:APP使用快速登入需使用該權限。 7. 通知:APP通知中心推播訊息需使用該權限。 8. 網路:APP執行時網路連線資料傳輸需使用。 9. 儲存空間:讀取登入頁勾選記住功能之設定資料檔需使用該權限。 10. 電話:客服專線撥打電話功能需使用該權限。 11. 聯絡人:手機門號轉帳讀取通訊錄之電話號碼需使用該權限。 當您下載此App時,即代表您已詳閱並同意本行「隱私權保護聲明」。 【隱私權保護聲明】https://hncb.tw/83t8sp/ 提醒您:為確保您的帳務及交易安全,請於行動裝置安裝防護軟體。

Screenshots

SHIN理想記帳4 screens
華南銀行+4 screens

Verdict

The call

The clearest difference is ratings volume: 華南銀行+ at 1.3K against SHIN理想記帳's 5. 華南銀行+ also leads on monetization model (free vs ad-supported). On price, rating, update cadence and ads there is nothing between them.

Scored on Price · Rating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings · Update frequency · Ads · In-app purchases · Monetization · Best chart rank · Devices · Requires iOS

CostPrice · In-app purchases · Ads · Monetization

Both are free to download. Neither carries in-app purchases, so what you see is what you pay.

ReceptionRating · Positive reviews · Number of ratings

On the App Store both sit at effectively the same score — 4.8 for SHIN理想記帳 against 4.7 for 華南銀行+. That said, the two scores are not equally well evidenced: 華南銀行+ has 1.3K ratings behind it against 5, so its average is the more settled of the two.

UpkeepUpdate frequency

SHIN理想記帳 ships an update every 3 weeks, 華南銀行+ monthly. The most recent releases landed on October 9, 2026 and October 13, 2026 respectively.

Scorecard2 real differences · 8 level
SHIN理想記帳 versus 華南銀行+: the parameters behind the verdict, then further details
ParameterSHIN理想記帳華南銀行+
PriceFreeFree
Rating4.8 (5 ratings) — better4.7 (1.3K ratings)
Positive reviews—25.0% of reviews
Number of ratings51.3K — better
Update frequencyEvery 3 weeks — betterMonthly
AdsNoNo
In-app purchasesNoNo
MonetizationAd-supportedFree — better
DevicesiPhone, iPodiPhone, iPod
Requires iOS13.213.0 — better
Further details — not scored
Size98 MB186 MB
Age rating4+4+
DeveloperKINGWAY MEDIA CO., LTD.Hua Nan Commercial Bank

Customer experience

SHIN理想記帳

All ratings5 ratings
Positive100.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative0.0%

華南銀行+

All ratings1,318 ratings
Positive93.6%
Neutral3.3%
Negative3.2%
Written reviews16 reviews
Positive25.0%
Neutral0.0%
Negative75.0%

Bugs and requests

SHIN理想記帳

Not enough reviews yet to summarise bugs or requests.

華南銀行+

Reported bugs

3 issues
  • Unable to log in or access account
  • App freezes or crashes on launch
  • Incompatible with newer iOS versions

Requested features

2 requests
  • Allow changing app language
  • Improve user experience for overseas users

In-app purchases

None

SHIN理想記帳

No in-app purchases

None

華南銀行+

No in-app purchases

Questions

Is SHIN理想記帳 free?
SHIN理想記帳 is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Is 華南銀行+ free?
華南銀行+ is free to download, with no in-app purchases.
Which has better reviews, SHIN理想記帳 or 華南銀行+?
SHIN理想記帳 is rated higher. SHIN理想記帳 averages 4.8 out of 5 from 5 ratings, while 華南銀行+ averages 4.7 from 1.3K ratings.
Do SHIN理想記帳 or 華南銀行+ have ads?
Neither SHIN理想記帳 nor 華南銀行+ shows ads.
Which is updated more often, SHIN理想記帳 or 華南銀行+?
SHIN理想記帳 ships an update every 3 weeks, and 華南銀行+ monthly. Most recently, SHIN理想記帳 was updated on October 9, 2026 and 華南銀行+ on October 13, 2026.

Other comparisons